Live data from Hacker News

Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

news.usni.org

31–40 of 60 posts

Re: Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

#31

Just another example of Obama politicizing the armed forces. National defense is the last thing on his mind.

ship naming has been random and political since forever.

submariners used to call SSN 685 "lipscomb fish"...glenard p. lipscomb had nothing to do with the navy and did nothing but die as a congressman the year the ship was being named.

uss jimmy carter? the ex-secretary club (forrestal, john warner, thomas s. gates)?

Re: Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

#32
post #24

There's something wrong happening when a ship is named after an individual, but not because anything the individual did ... Instead for some political response they are trying to make. This move isn't about honoring the guy, but to legitimize the movement he was part of. IMO, it is an insult to all those other people who have been honored for the sacrifices they have made.

IMO naming a machine of death after a man of peace is an insult to all those other people fighting for human rights, freedom and peace everywhere.

You didn't read the article before posting?

Re: Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh no! The Gay Agenda is attacking you from all sides!

And yet - Gays are over-represented in all media and politics by a factor of 3-10x. Homosexuality is now considered a virtue. Double-standards and special provisions are being constructed for LGBTs under the name of "equal rights". Anyone that does not agree with the agenda and propaganda is labeled a hate monger. Etc.

I'm really surprised to see this comment on HN. Maybe dang should nuke this whole story before it gets ugly...

Re: Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh no! The Gay Agenda is attacking you from all sides!

And yet - Gays are over-represented in all media and politics by a factor of 3-10x. Homosexuality is now considered a virtue. Double-standards and special provisions are being constructed for LGBTs under the name of "equal rights". Anyone that does not agree with the agenda and propaganda is labeled a hate monger. Etc.

Yes yes, and you're not a bigot, you just don't think gay people deserve equal rights. Which is totally different.

Re: Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

#36

There's something wrong happening when a ship is named after an individual, but not because anything the individual did ... Instead for some political response they are trying to make. This move isn't about honoring the guy, but to legitimize the movement he was part of. IMO, it is an insult to all those other people who have been honored for the sacrifices they have made.

It sounds like you may not know who Harvey Milk is or what he did. Read up on him, it's interesting stuff.

Really, though, why not just be honest about your intentions? You're a bigot and you think gay rights activists should be reviled, but you're afraid to actually come out and say that, so instead you're coming up with a thin pretext and pretending that's the real reason you're opposed. But you're not fooling anyone, so why not be honest at least?

Re: Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Oh no! The Gay Agenda is attacking you from all sides!

And yet - Gays are over-represented in all media and politics by a factor of 3-10x. Homosexuality is now considered a virtue. Double-standards and special provisions are being constructed for LGBTs under the name of "equal rights". Anyone that does not agree with the agenda and propaganda is labeled a hate monger. Etc.

People who spill hateful things from their mouths are labeled hate mongers. No one is pushing an agenda on you or anyone else. The "double standards and special provisions" are necessary to protect a class of people who are subjected to relentless torment at the hands of others who don't think they deserve equal rights.

Re: Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

#39
That's surprising, given Milk's support for Jim Jones and his People's Temple[1,2], whose followers murdered a U.S. congressman and committed mass suicide.

[1] http://jonestown.sdsu.edu/?page_id=16566 [2] http://www.lettersofnote.com/2010/02/in-defence-of-jim-jones...

Re: Navy to Name Ship After Gay Rights Activist Harvey Milk

#40
post #24

There's something wrong happening when a ship is named after an individual, but not because anything the individual did ... Instead for some political response they are trying to make. This move isn't about honoring the guy, but to legitimize the movement he was part of. IMO, it is an insult to all those other people who have been honored for the sacrifices they have made.

IMO naming a machine of death after a man of peace is an insult to all those other people fighting for human rights, freedom and peace everywhere.

not sure i follow this. said man of peace was a navy officer and the article notes that he died wearing memorabilia from his service. do you have some reason to believe he would have agreed with you?
Post reply on HN