Live data from Hacker News

Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

venturebeat.com

31–40 of 200 posts

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#31
Kind of sad to see so many products that are derivative, either directly (we scrape twitter!) or indirectly (We're going to do what X did, only for Y!)

Of course it probably all makes good business sense and I wish them all luck and to be happily bought out.

I just wish there was something original - X because it's a good idea and will bring great good, rather than X because Y...

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#32
post #2

I'll take the contrarian stance and say I'm not really impressed with the list. There are some that may be good, but there's not much new. Mostly me too products. Perhaps my expectations are too high.

Greplin looks like an interesting possibility. Some of the others have potential. But, yes, I think you've got the general sentiment.

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#33
post #2

I'll take the contrarian stance and say I'm not really impressed with the list. There are some that may be good, but there's not much new. Mostly me too products. Perhaps my expectations are too high.

Yeah, me-too products are never really interesting. I mean, does the world really need another search engine? There's already Lycos and Altavista.

Calling an internet startup's idea "me-too" is a pretty lame criticism. Most of the most successful startups had "me-too" ideas on paper. The proof is in the eating.

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#34
post #31

Kind of sad to see so many products that are derivative, either directly (we scrape twitter!) or indirectly (We're going to do what X did, only for Y!) Of course it probably all makes good business sense and I wish them all luck and to be happily bought out. I just wish there was something original - X because it's a good idea and will bring great good, rather than X because Y...

They're not really "Just X, only for Y" - that's just the fastest and simplest way to explain what they're doing.

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/XMeetsY

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#36

I'm really interested to see what happens to Crocodoc. Back in high school a programmer friend and I built a rough website to do joint collaboration that we called Collaborate. In our minds it was mainly a solution for all the peer reviewing we had to do for English class, but it follows the same track as Crocodoc. We ended up shutting it down because Google released Google Docs and a number of other real-time collab…

For every person using Google Docs, there are another 10 or 100 who haven't heard of it, don't understand it or think it is too hard.

Don't give up in the face of competition. It just validates the marketplace.

For instance - Dropbox went up against many other cloud storage systems and is winning.

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#37
post #2

I'll take the contrarian stance and say I'm not really impressed with the list. There are some that may be good, but there's not much new. Mostly me too products. Perhaps my expectations are too high.

Well this post certainly needs a counterpoint. I don't think your generalization should be the dominant stamp on the latest batch. A percentage are really interesting, and unless you compare this to past groups how can you say this is a weak showing? Yes, some are twitter widgets but they're not bad for twitter apps. I can already think of a number of customers for 500 friends. Broad-brushed pessimism is the wrong frame when a number have obvious potential and we have no idea what pivots lie ahead for the others based on an elevator pitch. Let's judge Ycom by it's long-term record.

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#38
post #2

I'll take the contrarian stance and say I'm not really impressed with the list. There are some that may be good, but there's not much new. Mostly me too products. Perhaps my expectations are too high.

Hey this is Alex from LaunchHear. We just finished our presentation fifteen minutes ago and we're hanging around outside the YC building now. I just wanted to say that a lot of these startups are actually really impressive, it's probably just not obvious from the three sentence descriptions.

Also, a bunch of these startups are still under embargo so they aren't even being written about. Give it a year or so and then start complaining.

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#39
post #2

I'll take the contrarian stance and say I'm not really impressed with the list. There are some that may be good, but there's not much new. Mostly me too products. Perhaps my expectations are too high.

Crocodoc looks like a solution for a serious painpoint of mine.

Re: Y Combinator presents 26 new startups

#40
post #2

I'll take the contrarian stance and say I'm not really impressed with the list. There are some that may be good, but there's not much new. Mostly me too products. Perhaps my expectations are too high.

if it helps, farmville was a near duplicate rip-off of farm town, and it's now one of the most successful facebook apps. you don't always need to have 100% unique ideas. zynga spent more money advertising, and is now profitable with something like 100+ million players.
Post reply on HN