Live data from Hacker News

Headphones Everywhere

newyorker.com

81–90 of 105 posts

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#81

When drinking tea, I drink tea. [1] When coding, I code. When listening to music, I listen to music. When sitting on a plane, I sit on a plane. Resist the urge to distract yourself and see what happens.[2] [1] There is the story of the Zen student whose teacher taught him "When drinking tea, just drink tea." The same student later discovered his teacher drinking tea and reading the newspaper. When confronted the teac…

When you're drinking tea you're allowing the hot water to distract you from the ingredients of the tea, you should really just chew the herbs. All experience is blended, it's good to enjoy what you're doing fully but that doesn't preclude adding additional things to the experience. Sometimes the addition of those things allow you to have a fresh look at the situation you're in. Just sit on the grass, sit on the grass and read a book, sit on the grass and listen to music. You could mark two of those situations as distracts or redefine them as unique blended experiences to enjoy. I prefer the latter. Mindfulness practice is valuable though, I just think blended experiences like blended foods are equally valuable. I'd rather have a sandwich then separately eat bread, lettuce, cheese, tomato and mustard.

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#82

When drinking tea, I drink tea. [1] When coding, I code. When listening to music, I listen to music. When sitting on a plane, I sit on a plane. Resist the urge to distract yourself and see what happens.[2] [1] There is the story of the Zen student whose teacher taught him "When drinking tea, just drink tea." The same student later discovered his teacher drinking tea and reading the newspaper. When confronted the teac…

When you're drinking tea you're allowing the hot water to distract you from the ingredients of the tea, you should really just chew the herbs. All experience is blended, it's good to enjoy what you're doing fully but that doesn't preclude adding additional things to the experience. Sometimes the addition of those things allow you to have a fresh look at the situation you're in. Just sit on the grass, sit on the grass…

The teaching to "Just drink tea" is a training principle. The reason that the teacher can read the news paper and drink tea, is that he's completed his training.[1]

Most of us never attempt any such training though.

In my comment I wasn't attempting to make a moral or aesthetic prescription. I was just pointing out that training the ability to focus on doing one thing is worthwhile.

[1] Also most Buddhist teachings reveal several layers of meaning when actually attempted. You are supposed to _try_ and sit and drink tea only, and see what happens, and what that reveals about your mind.

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#83
I've found that the more urban and compressed the environment, the more headphones you see. I started doing it too when riding the bus or working in my "open plan" office, to the point that I wore them on average 10 hours a day.

Now I live in the countryside, my nearest neighbor is a mile away, and I haven't used headphones in 6 months, nor have I even thought about them until reading this article. And I still don't feel like using them.

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#84
post #15

> Is the ubiquity of headphones just another emblem of catastrophic social decline, edging us even deeper into narcissism and unsociability? No. * closes tab

As always, nobody is impressed that you found a reason not to read the article. As a general rule, if you couldn't even make it to the first line, you probably aren't capable of making a useful comment.

50-odd upvotes says otherwise

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#85
Perhaps I am just paranoid but I don't enjoy the complete blocking of environmental sound cues that occurs when wearing most headphones. It would be nice to have more headphones which focus on delivering an ambient noise passthrough mode.

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#86
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the argument is that earphones could be used as a garroting device.

As well as cellphones being used to send orders to lackeys outside of prison.

Yeah sure the modern personal electronic device has lots of features you wouldn't want in a prison. But everything in prison has been modified for prison use: beds, toothbrushes, toilets, etc. Electronic devices can also be modified to fit the prison environment. Prisoners who are busy playing Angry Birds aren't busy plotting angry mayhem.

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#87

> “Do people really like music this much?” I have wondered, incredulously, while tallying endless white earplugs. Does the New Yorker really pay good, honest money for such laughably sheltered premises? It's no accident Taylor Swift's take-home last year was $170 million. Sometimes people wear headphones simply to tune out the grocery store's bland Adele-centric easy listening. Loving music is pretty much a human bei…

One could argue that clearly that is exactly how much people like music at that particular time and place, assuming she can distinguish those listening to music from those not

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#88
When you listen on headphones, sound in the middle of the mix, which might seem to come from the middle of and slightly behind home speakers, appears to come from the middle of your skull. I find this fascinating. It's a use case that probably never came up during evolution, yet works reasonably

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#89
post #84

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As always, nobody is impressed that you found a reason not to read the article. As a general rule, if you couldn't even make it to the first line, you probably aren't capable of making a useful comment.

50-odd upvotes says otherwise

Every kind of crap can get upvotes given enough people with no judgement.

Re: Headphones Everywhere

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the argument is that earphones could be used as a garroting device.

Would be interesting if they designed a pair of earbuds that had a deliberately weak cable so it couldn't be used as a weapon

It might be better to design a prison that actually rehabilitated people. Then perhaps there might be a little less violence.
Post reply on HN