Live data from Hacker News

Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

github.com

11–20 of 42 posts

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#11
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can use Shift+Escape for that

Shift + Esc doesn't seem work for me (Chrome 53 dev), and there are a few open bugs about the shortcut not working. Opening Task Manager from the menus works fine though :)

Yeah I often fail to open the TM in Chrome/OSX.

This should be trivial to catch with CI tests...wonder what went wrong there.

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#12
post #6

> A lot of web pages use background network requests for tracking user actions and sending data to remote servers, lazily loading heavy assets etc., and all that goes unnoticed by the user. And there is nothing wrong with it.

It depends. There are situations when a user is heavily constrained by both data and charge (Amp hr) limits. In those situations, heavy background loading is a measurable source of headaches and annoyance.

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#13
post #6

> A lot of web pages use background network requests for tracking user actions and sending data to remote servers, lazily loading heavy assets etc., and all that goes unnoticed by the user. And there is nothing wrong with it.

There's also nothing wrong with wanting to know about it. So I applaud the creation of this extension.

Though he does go on to say:

> Ideally, the browsers "loading icon" should spin for those requests as well

On that point, I don't agree, since it would give the misleading appearance—at least to me—that the page wasn't even done with its initial rendering. But perhaps he is suggesting the standard loading icon should switch to a sort of unobtrusive network in/out indicator after the initial rendering. That I would like.

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#14
post #7
post #4

This looks really interesting, is there a reason why it hasn't been uploaded to the Chrome Store? It would be much easier to install and keep updated.

Author here. I think it involves some payment (IIRC) or some other stupid barrier. If someone is kind enough to take care of that for me, I'd be happy to publish it. I have a couple other extensions which I'd like to publish as well but wasn't able to do so in the past, so I have just stopped trying.

I didn't know that, thank you for clarifying, I would be glad to pay for the fee for you, you may contact me using my twitter username @gmail.com

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#15
post #6

> A lot of web pages use background network requests for tracking user actions and sending data to remote servers, lazily loading heavy assets etc., and all that goes unnoticed by the user. And there is nothing wrong with it.

And there is nothing wrong with blocking these transfers either.

It is the user's own computer and the user's own network subscription after all. User pays for these resources.

As for the software, users get to choose the software. They might prefer software that does not use so much bandwidth. And there's nothing wrong with that.

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#16
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can use Shift+Escape for that

Shift + Esc doesn't seem work for me (Chrome 53 dev), and there are a few open bugs about the shortcut not working. Opening Task Manager from the menus works fine though :)

That's true, for some reason the shortcut does not always work for me either on Windows and on OS X.

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#17
post #3
post #2

Something nice would be to see, next to the tab title, the CPU resource taken by that tab. I don't mind pages loading a lot of resources, I mind pages killing my CPU.

You can use Shift+Escape for that

doesn't seem to work for Firefox :/

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#18
post #14
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Author here. I think it involves some payment (IIRC) or some other stupid barrier. If someone is kind enough to take care of that for me, I'd be happy to publish it. I have a couple other extensions which I'd like to publish as well but wasn't able to do so in the past, so I have just stopped trying.

I didn't know that, thank you for clarifying, I would be glad to pay for the fee for you, you may contact me using my twitter username @gmail.com

No worries! Thank you for offering to pay the fee! Randall has humbly taken care of it this time though :) (Thanks RKoutnik!)

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#19
post #13
post #6

> A lot of web pages use background network requests for tracking user actions and sending data to remote servers, lazily loading heavy assets etc., and all that goes unnoticed by the user. And there is nothing wrong with it.

There's also nothing wrong with wanting to know about it. So I applaud the creation of this extension. Though he does go on to say: > Ideally, the browsers "loading icon" should spin for those requests as well On that point, I don't agree, since it would give the misleading appearance—at least to me—that the page wasn't even done with its initial rendering. But perhaps he is suggesting the standard loading icon shoul…

Author here.

> perhaps he is suggesting the standard loading icon should switch to a sort of unobtrusive network in/out indicator after the initial rendering

yes, that was what I implied, which is why I wrapped "\"loading icon\"" in quotes :) I agree though that the wording isn't very clear, my bad!

Re: Chrome extension to indicate background network activity per tab

#20
post #10
post #4

This looks really interesting, is there a reason why it hasn't been uploaded to the Chrome Store? It would be much easier to install and keep updated.

Yes. Mini-tuto to install by hand: 1. Download zip - https://github.com/awalGarg/netmonitor/archive/master.zip 2. Unzip it 3. Go to chrome extension page (or type `chrome://chrome/extensions/` in the URL bar) 4. Drag and drop the folder `netmonitor` on the page

`chrome:extensions` works too :)
Post reply on HN