Live data from Hacker News

Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

brianketelsen.com

131–140 of 177 posts

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You missed the rest of the paragraph though: "If you’ve used them, you know that they’re not as nice as the applications available in macOS and Windows." I used Thunderbird for about 10 years on my Mac laptop and every time I tried to switch to Apple Mail (or anything else) I quickly switched back. But the truth is, I have used Linux on my primary desktop PC for about 15 years now and can honestly say that it is a ve…

Haven't Mozilla gave up on Thunderbird though?

Not yet. They're still in the process of moving it to a community run project.

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is baffling. How could something as important as font rendering not be fixed?

Equally baffling is that quotes, which should simply demarcate regions within which special characters are ignored, have special semantic meaning to a CSS parser. That narrative, however, isn't one for which we can blame Microsoft.

They don't have special semantic meaning to CSS the spec. Quotes are needed[0] only if the value has whitespace in it.

0: https://developer.mozilla.org/en/docs/Web/CSS/font-family#Va...

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#133
post #113
post #76

At first I was excited by bash for Windows but I am still not switching. You know why? Malware. Ransomware. I have many layers of defense from various harm (OpenWRT router, uBlock being the two most important ones) but the biggest defense I have is that Windows programs simply do not run on Linux and the Linux market is not big enough to bother with. And I know many of you will say, oh that's not a problem, it never…

Somewhat unrelated, but you should check out pi hole https://pi-hole.net . Ads / spyware traffic won't even enter your network. I still run uBlock, but it goes largely unused.

Pretty good idea -- since I am running OpenWRT already I could just use https://gist.github.com/teffalump/7227752

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#134

A lot of comments about Thunderbird here, despite the article saying "Save your apologist comments and what about Open Office/Geary/Thunderbird comments.". That means don't comment about it. The interesting part of the article is not the part about why this guy uses Windows!

You missed the rest of the paragraph though: "If you’ve used them, you know that they’re not as nice as the applications available in macOS and Windows." I used Thunderbird for about 10 years on my Mac laptop and every time I tried to switch to Apple Mail (or anything else) I quickly switched back. But the truth is, I have used Linux on my primary desktop PC for about 15 years now and can honestly say that it is a ve…

> I would agree that for a long time OpenOffice had compatibility issues (often no worse than trying to open an Office document on a Mac) but those days are long gone.

Downloaded a .docx template from Hubspot recently, LibreOffice could not even begin to open it correctly, the layout was screwed up all over the place.

Using this template probably saved us 20 hours of work. So the only reasonable solution here was to set up a Windows VM, sign up for Office, and use Word to edit the template.

It's very frustrating when people say things like "those days are long gone" and dismiss issues like this as mere "inconveniences" when they are not and we, while being devoted Linux users, are still facing these challenges.

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#135
post #99

For me, modern virtualization has gotten so good that it's my preferred solution. kvm, libvirt, virtio, and PCI passthrough et al have opened up a whole new world of possibilities. Currently still requires fairly specific hardware and kind of a pain to figure out how to make it work, but it's already very impressive. This is still really cool though.

Thing is you can't run Windows natively that way, it has to be a guest operating system. Then you need multiple videocards to pass through, and the guest operating systems require custom drivers at that. My preferred setup would be Windows native, with macOS (ha) and Linux guests running with GPU acceleration—preferably in a manner that doesn't necessitate multiple videocards. Too bad Apple is hellbent on locking mac…

My setup would be native Linux and on top Windows/macos.

Using Proxmox as your host os you get a ZFS root filesystem with ZFS compression, SSD cache, Snapshots. Then you install Windows and maybe try to figure out if you can run MacOS in KVM.

The idea would be to leave the host system rather clean, and maybe even add a Linux guest in Proxmox.

Then in the host you just install a minimal xserver (maybe with i3) and log into your virtual machines via Spice/VNC/RDP. (Maybe add Zerotier on all guest for easy networking)

This way you can get all the benefits of ZFS and use the Proxmox backup functionality and do not have to reboot your system.

At least this is my plan for a new workstation setup. :) Instead of Proxmox, OmniOS (Illumos) together with pkgsrc (for xserver) might be an option.

(Sorry for typos. On mobile )

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#136
post #120

It is rather trivial for Microsoft to implement support for Linux. Also, if Windows source code was freely available there would be support for Windows applications on Linux.

There is support for Windows applications on Linux, no source code needed: https://www.winehq.org/

Yes.

My point was that it is trivial for Microsoft to implement support for an open system, compared to implementing support for a closed system such as Windows.

There would be better support for running Windows applications under Linux if Windows was an open system.

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#137

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Equally baffling is that quotes, which should simply demarcate regions within which special characters are ignored, have special semantic meaning to a CSS parser. That narrative, however, isn't one for which we can blame Microsoft.

They don't have special semantic meaning to CSS the spec. Quotes are needed[0] only if the value has whitespace in it. 0: https://developer.mozilla.org/en/docs/Web/CSS/font-family#Va...

They have special meaning since "generic family names (...) must not be quoted".

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#138

A lot of comments about Thunderbird here, despite the article saying "Save your apologist comments and what about Open Office/Geary/Thunderbird comments.". That means don't comment about it. The interesting part of the article is not the part about why this guy uses Windows!

I think people wouldn't comment on it if the author didin't decide to be obnoxious condescending dick about it.

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You missed the rest of the paragraph though: "If you’ve used them, you know that they’re not as nice as the applications available in macOS and Windows." I used Thunderbird for about 10 years on my Mac laptop and every time I tried to switch to Apple Mail (or anything else) I quickly switched back. But the truth is, I have used Linux on my primary desktop PC for about 15 years now and can honestly say that it is a ve…

> I would agree that for a long time OpenOffice had compatibility issues (often no worse than trying to open an Office document on a Mac) but those days are long gone. Downloaded a .docx template from Hubspot recently, LibreOffice could not even begin to open it correctly, the layout was screwed up all over the place. Using this template probably saved us 20 hours of work. So the only reasonable solution here was to…

Yep. LibreOffice works... except when it doesn't. Similarly, getting Ubuntu 16's AMD drivers to work well is a clusterfuck and a half.

Linux fits 99% of my use cases, and the other 1% is unbelievably frustrating.

Re: Running I3 Window Manager on Ubuntu for Windows

#140
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

X was never designed to work like that. I personally run Visual Studio Code (with a patched X lib to allow Electron to start without graphics acceleration) with the "local window manager" (i.e., Windows itself). Works great.

Okay I'll bite. Why are you running Linux vs∆ code in widnLaASaAAqaa@@@@£

Because I want full integration with a Git CLI that uses the exact same plugins as I use in Linux. Git on Windows is a pain for me.
Post reply on HN