Live data from Hacker News

BooXtream EPub Watermark Remover

github.com

21–27 of 27 posts

Re: BooXtream EPub Watermark Remover

#21
post #8
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or host it on a Tor hidden service!

A tor-ified github clone would be interesting. You'd probably see a lot of cool pro-freedom software projects that are illegal in their originating country, like this one.

Actually I've been thinking about it so many times that I'm surprised that nobody did it yet. "Hidden Gitlab", anyone?

Re: BooXtream EPub Watermark Remover

#22
post #5

Any idea how this compares to Apprentice Alf's tools?

This is much newer, but I think it will eventually be included. This tool is an implementation of https://pastebin.com/raw/E1xgCUmb

Thanks for that. The reading was a bit thick on the polemics, but I also found it an easy to read and understand overview of ebook watermark functionality for someone like me who's unfamiliar with the field.

Re: BooXtream EPub Watermark Remover

#23
post #19

That's not DRM, but Watermarking. I don't see any reason why you should object to watermarking. Contrary to DRM it doesn't hurt real costumers at all and only helps finding people that distribute books without compensating the author.

Some reasons why watermarks could be objectionable are covered in the accompanying Torrentfreak article (already linked in other comments here): "'Books should be used as tools for disseminating knowledge and information. What ‘social DRM’ watermarking systems do instead is turn books into tools of surveillance and oppression by monitoring who shares what knowledge, where,' IBI explain. "'We don’t like this, and beca…

The first one lauds giving other people access to books for free, leading to the author not getting compensated. Not even DRM (which watermarking isn't) prevents you from sharing knowledge for free. Just write something on your own containing that knowledge and put it up for free.

The thing with the regime seems a bit constructed, but even then authors can just decide to publish those few books where this applies without watermarks. If your goal is to reach people living in a regime you would want to translate the text from english into the language of the place anyway (I don't know of english speaking regimes)

Re: BooXtream EPub Watermark Remover

#24

Every day I see submissions here that are cracks, keygens, etc., and they always get flagged and killed. I'm not familiar with BooXtream, specifically, but I'm curious what it is about this that is different? This is for DRM, sure, but it seems very similar to me.

> submissions here that are cracks, keygens, etc., and they always get flagged and killed

Those are almost always spammy. If there's something intellectually interesting about the post, that would be different. (Not saying that's the case here.)

Re: BooXtream EPub Watermark Remover

#27

That's not DRM, but Watermarking. I don't see any reason why you should object to watermarking. Contrary to DRM it doesn't hurt real costumers at all and only helps finding people that distribute books without compensating the author.

I agree with you. Watermarking hurts only pirates. Who would trust a watermarking remover ?
Post reply on HN