Live data from Hacker News

Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

bloomberg.com

61–70 of 89 posts

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#61
post #56

If you think stuff like this is cool, and you'd like to be a part of the software engineering effort at Parker Institute for Cancer Immunotherapy, msg me. ccary@parkerici.org We are building out our platform for bioinformatics. Some engineering topics: * Large scale data processing (Cloud & on-prem HPC based) * Bioinformatics / ML algorithms * Data storage & retrieval (File systems & databases)

Yes, please elaborate on what the software engineering effort involves! Is this a bioinformatics thing? What kind of work does it involve? Does it require a strong theoretical background? etc.

(Edit: Thanks! Just noticed you added it.)

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#62
post #2

I hope that by the time I'm succumbing to the effects of aging, we'll have techniques with tools like CRISPR to make it easier.

And are you doing something about it (donating/investing/working/etc) ?

Off-topic: is your account named after the diatonic scale? I love the dorian scale.

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#63

I'm calling it here, this trial will fail hard. The basic idea is this: the cancer has a number of mutations that produce novel antigens that don't exist in normal cells. If we can train T-cells to recognize these, they can attack the tumor with great specificity and kill those cells. The problem is, all the tumor has to do to evade this targeting is shed the problematic mutation, which is easily done - tumors are gr…

Well, if it only fails to cause autoimmune diseases as a collateral effect, it'll be already a huge win for CRISPR techniques in the future.

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#64
post #56

If you think stuff like this is cool, and you'd like to be a part of the software engineering effort at Parker Institute for Cancer Immunotherapy, msg me. ccary@parkerici.org We are building out our platform for bioinformatics. Some engineering topics: * Large scale data processing (Cloud & on-prem HPC based) * Bioinformatics / ML algorithms * Data storage & retrieval (File systems & databases)

[deleted]

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#65
post #56

If you think stuff like this is cool, and you'd like to be a part of the software engineering effort at Parker Institute for Cancer Immunotherapy, msg me. ccary@parkerici.org We are building out our platform for bioinformatics. Some engineering topics: * Large scale data processing (Cloud & on-prem HPC based) * Bioinformatics / ML algorithms * Data storage & retrieval (File systems & databases)

Yes, please elaborate on what the software engineering effort involves! Is this a bioinformatics thing? What kind of work does it involve? Does it require a strong theoretical background? etc. (Edit: Thanks! Just noticed you added it.)

maybe WRT to https://www.google.com/search?q=genome+sequencing+algorithms which would be needed to find unique patterns among billions of base pairs for CRISPR to target. it's microscopic big data :D

[1] http://benchling.engineering/dna-regex-search/?hn

[2] http://benchling.engineering/optimizing-crispr/

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I tend to believe the NIH is better at administrating grants than I am.

They're actually pretty terrible. It isn't a high bar to do better than the NIH when it comes to supporting new technologies. Almost all important early fundamental research, the high-risk part leading up to new knowledge and potential new technologies, is supported by philanthropy. The NIH really only funds follow-on work for things that are already known. In order to win a grant you have to have already proven your…

Ironically, you skipped "Give it to a lab whose research you want to support."

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And are you doing something about it (donating/investing/working/etc) ?

Off-topic: is your account named after the diatonic scale? I love the dorian scale.

First time reading about it. I just iterated until I found a unique and easily rememberable username a long time ago (d-day 1943).

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Off-topic: is your account named after the diatonic scale? I love the dorian scale.

First time reading about it. I just iterated until I found a unique and easily rememberable username a long time ago (d-day 1943).

Funny coincidence. The most common dorian scale is called "D dorian".

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#69

I'm calling it here, this trial will fail hard. The basic idea is this: the cancer has a number of mutations that produce novel antigens that don't exist in normal cells. If we can train T-cells to recognize these, they can attack the tumor with great specificity and kill those cells. The problem is, all the tumor has to do to evade this targeting is shed the problematic mutation, which is easily done - tumors are gr…

My understanding is that this trial is just

    1. adoptive CAR T cell transfer 
        (which has been shown to work 
         with varying degrees of success)
    2. PD-1 is CRISPR'd out (to combat exhaustion) 
    3. The TCR is CRISPR'd out (to increase specificity)
CAR Ts have certainly had some success; my concern with this trial would be more autoimmune problems, not that it would fail hard.

Is there something else about this trial that would make it unsuccessful?

Re: Crispr Wins Key Approval to Fight Cancer in Human Trials

#70
post #2

I hope that by the time I'm succumbing to the effects of aging, we'll have techniques with tools like CRISPR to make it easier.

You don't have to be old to get diseases. The way I see it a few aches and pains are a small price to pay for not being dead.
Post reply on HN