Live data from Hacker News

Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

blacklistedengineer.blogspot.com

21–30 of 33 posts

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#21

I think we've all seen a good engineer get fired because he's a pushover. You know who doesn't get fired? Story time: We had the most brilliant and insufferable devops engineer I've ever met. I don't mean just your standard grump overworked sys admin. This guy was a treasure. 1) Previously all engineers had 20% time and would work on personal projects. We had a ton of extra servers lying around and it was fairly simp…

Wouldn't have to worry about firing me, I'd quit.

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#22

I think we've all seen a good engineer get fired because he's a pushover. You know who doesn't get fired? Story time: We had the most brilliant and insufferable devops engineer I've ever met. I don't mean just your standard grump overworked sys admin. This guy was a treasure. 1) Previously all engineers had 20% time and would work on personal projects. We had a ton of extra servers lying around and it was fairly simp…

Wouldn't have to worry about firing me, I'd quit.

I stuck it out until he confiscated the personal laptop of an engineer who had permission to use it on network.

After that I got permission to work from home for a month and used the opportunity to find a new job.

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#23

I think we've all seen a good engineer get fired because he's a pushover. You know who doesn't get fired? Story time: We had the most brilliant and insufferable devops engineer I've ever met. I don't mean just your standard grump overworked sys admin. This guy was a treasure. 1) Previously all engineers had 20% time and would work on personal projects. We had a ton of extra servers lying around and it was fairly simp…

I wonder how many good people just had enough of it and left. In environments like these you either go mad or get so detatched from your company, that you don't give a shit about anything anymore... or you just leave...

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#24

Unfortunately I think this person seems mentally ill. I have a friend who in his 30s became a paranoid schizophrenic and although he was very articulate, he had major flaws in his logic and behaved erratically. He also filed many lawsuits and was litigious as well. It sounds like this person was dismissed from his job (he mentioned it in one of his videos), and he hasn't been able to find employment because of his me…

Don't you think there is a good chance his mental illness is actually a result of being consumed by such an awkward situation? The details he provides about proof of employment and wrong-doing by Chrysler when asked to confirm it are very clear. If those are real, we can't tell - this looks like something a good journalist would be able to uncover, and maybe help achieving some kind of closure.

No I don't think so. It sounds like he was fired for at the very least strange behavior, and all of his potential employers picked up on it. If he were technically good, it wouldn't matter what Chrysler said. But it seems like he's not technically good.

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#25

Unfortunately I think this person seems mentally ill. I have a friend who in his 30s became a paranoid schizophrenic and although he was very articulate, he had major flaws in his logic and behaved erratically. He also filed many lawsuits and was litigious as well. It sounds like this person was dismissed from his job (he mentioned it in one of his videos), and he hasn't been able to find employment because of his me…

Don't you think there is a good chance his mental illness is actually a result of being consumed by such an awkward situation? The details he provides about proof of employment and wrong-doing by Chrysler when asked to confirm it are very clear. If those are real, we can't tell - this looks like something a good journalist would be able to uncover, and maybe help achieving some kind of closure.

It doesn't matter if his case is real or not. What matters is, for 17 years, a mechanical engineer basically just lived like a bum rather than trying to get any kind of real job, even something as simple as a fry cook, waiter, janitor, anything. He had already been a janitor and maintenance mechanic once, so that should have been easy to get again.

What _is_ clear is he can barely write, he records videos of himself outdoors that are barely audible, and even if he won this strange case, he's clearly not employable now. More than likely his mental illness started after he became an engineer and quickly progressed.

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#26
post #2

and a copy of my Chrysler contractor ID badge How is that not the end of proof needed to a court? Unless they are claiming he made a counterfeit badge which is silly. There also have to be tax records on the state and federal side that a court can order them to retrieve? The saddest part of that whole story is what I recognize as the descent into the mental state of homelessness, because once you are there, it's REAL…

> How is that not the end of proof needed to a court?

Because this guy is, in all probability, mentally ill. There's no evidence I can find of Chrysler actually speaking to prospective employers or lying about whatever employment history he has.

Here's (what he calls) the Oakland circuit court case judgement, an appeal of his original case: http://www.michbar.org/file/opinions/appeals/2003/120403/212...

To wit: he claimed that Chrysler lied about his employment history to a perspective employer, but the only perspective employer presented as evidence testified that she hadn't even contacted Chrysler about him.

Lacking literally any evidence of wrongdoing on Chrysler's part, the case was dismissed, and this appeals court upholds that dismissal.

He lists other "case numbers", most of which I can't turn up (no pacer access here), but I suspect it's just a litany of affirmations of the original judgement, or refusals to hear the case, or that they're simply filings of various sorts that never went anywhere. This simply looks like a persecution he is suffering in his mind.

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#27

Unfortunately I think this person seems mentally ill. I have a friend who in his 30s became a paranoid schizophrenic and although he was very articulate, he had major flaws in his logic and behaved erratically. He also filed many lawsuits and was litigious as well. It sounds like this person was dismissed from his job (he mentioned it in one of his videos), and he hasn't been able to find employment because of his me…

Don't you think there is a good chance his mental illness is actually a result of being consumed by such an awkward situation? The details he provides about proof of employment and wrong-doing by Chrysler when asked to confirm it are very clear. If those are real, we can't tell - this looks like something a good journalist would be able to uncover, and maybe help achieving some kind of closure.

Keeping in mind that we're speculating on a case without any direct access to the subject, it's actually really unlikely that we're looking at a single episode caused by one situation (his employment with Chrysler) that's lasted for thirty years. But it's entirely possible that the situation could have made existing problems significantly worse.

There are certainly aspects of his writing that might be suggestive (the graphorrhea and rambling over minor details, irrational paranoia, etc.) of certain mental illnesses. Since paranoid schizophrenia was mentioned by the parent comment, take that for example: it's not something that comes about because of a single situation later on in life. There are clear, measurable physical symptoms in that instance such as a significant and measurable difference in grey matter. That doesn't happen because of any episode you've experienced.

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wouldn't have to worry about firing me, I'd quit.

I stuck it out until he confiscated the personal laptop of an engineer who had permission to use it on network. After that I got permission to work from home for a month and used the opportunity to find a new job.

Do you know if (m)any of your coworkers also quit?

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I stuck it out until he confiscated the personal laptop of an engineer who had permission to use it on network. After that I got permission to work from home for a month and used the opportunity to find a new job.

Do you know if (m)any of your coworkers also quit?

Several asked to be transferred to other departments. That's what prompted his demand to be the sole point of provisioning. He had final say over Finance, Analytics, internal reporting tools, if he didn't like you it didn't get a server.

I had been with the company for four years at that point and I knew a lot of other old timers. Overnight it went from a flat organization with a progressive expectation that "No one is going to tell you what to do. You are here because you kick ass and we expect great things." to a strict hierarchy with several layers of management and influence.

Everyone who had been there as long as I had was equally unhappy with the new direction. This was all done under the guise of, "Getting the budget under control." when we all clearly saw the budget was fatter than ever. Where we had a diversity projects and research going on before, now we had 1 or 2 large money making projects. Where we had an expectation that we needed to be competitive and lean and every aspect mattered before, now they were hiring more and more management instead of workers.

We were doing so well that many former co-workers contacted me and other old timers during this time and we warned them off. Many simply didn't renew their contracts because they saw the writing on the wall.

Only one other person outright quit and that was really heartbreaking to watch. He had just transferred from California and the bullying was so bad he told me he was going home to stay with his sister and start going to therapy. He couldn't stand the idea of working in tech anymore.

Re: Engineer claims he has been blacklisted by Chrysler for 17 years

#30
post #2

and a copy of my Chrysler contractor ID badge How is that not the end of proof needed to a court? Unless they are claiming he made a counterfeit badge which is silly. There also have to be tax records on the state and federal side that a court can order them to retrieve? The saddest part of that whole story is what I recognize as the descent into the mental state of homelessness, because once you are there, it's REAL…

In Utah they found out that just providing the homeless with a place to live was the first step to making a host of changes. You are correct, it is a difficult hole to dig oneself out from.

http://www.npr.org/2015/12/10/459100751/utah-reduced-chronic...

Post reply on HN