Live data from Hacker News

Building a more power-efficient browser

blogs.windows.com

71–80 of 105 posts

Re: Building a more power-efficient browser

#71
post #69
post #57

Honestly I'd be happy if they could stop Windows 10 from turning my laptop into a hair dryer randomly while it is otherwise entirely idle. The thing is sitting there doing nothing, suddenly the fan will start roaring and the CPU utilization spikes.

Seriously why on Earth does this happen? Even if Edge ends up being more power-efficient the rest of the OS (Windows 10) is going to ensure that I will get no more than 3 hours of battery life on my laptop.

I'm not certain what causes it for you, but for me it was microsoft's antimalware scans. These are supposed to run only in 'idle' mode but for whatever reason were running while I was using my computer.

What's worse is the automatic OS restarts that seem to also think I'm in idle mode.

Re: Building a more power-efficient browser

#72
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In Safari, which slows background JavaScript down or stops it altogether, music stops playing occasionally on Soundcloud when a song ends. The only option to prevent this is to make the Soundcloud tab the sole tab in the browser window. The window can be in the background but the tab is not treated as background tab because it is the active tab in the window.

I personally would be happy if all background tabs would stop completely if they don't have focus for a configured amount of time, and don't have a network connection currently in use. To keep a tab active pin it, those tabs will be immune from that. And not for power consumption but simply for browser speed!

There's a chrome extension called 'the great suspender' that does exactly that.

Re: Building a more power-efficient browser

#73
post #69
post #57

Honestly I'd be happy if they could stop Windows 10 from turning my laptop into a hair dryer randomly while it is otherwise entirely idle. The thing is sitting there doing nothing, suddenly the fan will start roaring and the CPU utilization spikes.

Seriously why on Earth does this happen? Even if Edge ends up being more power-efficient the rest of the OS (Windows 10) is going to ensure that I will get no more than 3 hours of battery life on my laptop.

Windows update via svchost.exe has been the problem on the machines I support. I randomly eats 100% of the CPU for minutes at a time.

http://www.wintips.org/how-to-fix-svchost-exe-netsvcs-memory...

Re: Building a more power-efficient browser

#74
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seriously why on Earth does this happen? Even if Edge ends up being more power-efficient the rest of the OS (Windows 10) is going to ensure that I will get no more than 3 hours of battery life on my laptop.

I'm not certain what causes it for you, but for me it was microsoft's antimalware scans. These are supposed to run only in 'idle' mode but for whatever reason were running while I was using my computer. What's worse is the automatic OS restarts that seem to also think I'm in idle mode.

If you're using Windows 10, have you set your active times?

Re: Building a more power-efficient browser

#75
As computing moves from a desktop centric function to a mobile centric function, a more power efficient software should be one of the top design requirements. This is a problem across all platforms.

Imagine if your phone/laptop's full charge lasts for 1 week instead of 1 day.

Re: Building a more power-efficient browser

#78
post #72
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I personally would be happy if all background tabs would stop completely if they don't have focus for a configured amount of time, and don't have a network connection currently in use. To keep a tab active pin it, those tabs will be immune from that. And not for power consumption but simply for browser speed!

There's a chrome extension called 'the great suspender' that does exactly that.

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-gb/firefox/addon/suspend-tab/ for Firefox.

Re: Building a more power-efficient browser

#79
post #49
post #40

Google did make battery life improvements by reducing wakes at least on the Mac in response to Safari performing better. Some interesting details are at https://plus.google.com/+PeterKasting/posts/GpL63A1K2TF Perhaps Edge will a nice competitive impact on the Windows side :P.

Perhaps they should have cared years ago when this problem was first clear. I don't know about on Windows but on OS X the difference has been massive for years and years.

It's been true for a while on Windows, going back to IE9: https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/ie/2011/03/28/browser-power...

Re: Building a more power-efficient browser

#80
post #60
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Still it shows what's done just to make somebody's bonus (or just prestige in the meetings?) thanks to the change in the telemetry reports. Luckily both Safari and Firefox don't animate it. And if I'm not wrong, Safari was the first to have it, years ago, at the time Jobs was there. Never animated. Anyway, if the feature is useful, people will use it. If it's not, they won't. Not making the whole experience a "big ad…

People will use it, but only if they know it's there. I've met a ton of Safari users who have no idea what that thing is or even that it's there in the first place. They tend to love it after I pointed out to them. Microsoft is probably doing the right thing here.

We get great feedback from users who discover the feature and want it to be discoverable without being obtrusive. If you haven't seen the animation, you might be overestimating it - it's extremely subtle and tasteful, just a tiny flip of the pages in the reading mode button when it goes from an inactive to active state.
Post reply on HN