Live data from Hacker News

Alan Kay has agreed to do an AMA today

news.ycombinator.com

141–150 of 931 posts

Re: Alan Kay has agreed to do an AMA today

#141
post #82

What do you think of Bret Victor's work? ( http://worrydream.com/ ) Or Rich Hickey? Who do you think are the people doing the most interesting work in user interface design today?

They collaborate together at YCR / HARC!

YCR is not "my group" -- I'm very happy to have helped set up HARC! with its very impressive group of Principal Investigators (including Bret).

Re: Alan Kay has agreed to do an AMA today

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't the answer contained in the quote? Do a cost/benefit analysis of the "amount of time and energy" that would go "down these ratholes" versus the "the time not wasted in trying to fix other people’s not quite right tools."

But how can you assess this until you have gone down those rat holes?

You gain experience by going down similar rat holes, until you feel that you can adequately compare the situation you are in now to an experience in the past.

You'll still be wrong, but perhaps less often.

Re: Alan Kay has agreed to do an AMA today

#147
post #91

Hi Alan, On the "worse is better" divide I've always considered you as someone standing near the "better" (MIT) approach, but with an understanding of the pragmatics inherent in the "worse is better" (New Jersey) approach too. What is your actual position on the "worse is better" dichotomy? Do you believe it is real, and if so, can there be a third alternative that combines elements from both sides? And if not, are w…

I don't think "pop culture" approaches are the best way to do most things (though "every once in a while" something good does happen).

The real question is "does a hack reset 'normal'?" For most people it tends to, and this makes it very difficult for them to think about the actual issues.

A quote I made up some years ago is "Better and Perfect are the enemies of What-Is-Actually-Needed". The big sin so many people commit in computing is not really paying attention to "What-Is-Actually-Needed"! And not going below that.

Re: Alan Kay has agreed to do an AMA today

#149
post #11

Hi Alan, What do think about the current state of language design (Swift, Rust, Go)? Anything that makes you happy/annoys you?

I think all languages today annoy me -- just put me down as a grump. They seem to be at a very weak level of discourse for the 21st century. (But a few are fun when looked at from the perspectives of the past e.g. Erlang ...)
Post reply on HN