Live data from Hacker News

Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

acsh.org

11–20 of 131 posts

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#11

Too bad it tastes weird.

I don't really understand the popularity of artificial sweeteners. They all taste totally teh ick to me. I would much rather have something that is not sweet than something that is artificially sweet.

But judging from the beverage selection available at just about any convenience store, I'm possibly the only person in the USA who would rather drink something that isn't sweet than something that contains 0 calorie sweeteners.

Maybe I'm just really picky.

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#12

Too bad it tastes weird.

Have you tried aspartame? I've found that Coke Zero tastes much closer to real sugar than Diet Coke.

Diet Coke uses aspartame also.

I figured the difference between Coke Zero and Diet Coke was branding for people who don't want to drink something labeled as diet.

EDIT: I drink both regularly (including today), and I personally do not perceive difference in taste. YMMV.

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#14
It's good to see that Splenda isn't the potential toxic substance we began to wonder it was, but I agree that it tastes icky.

That said, I wonder why Stevia isn't considered to sweeten drinks? It's very sweet, it's natural like sugar (meaning it's not synthetic or lab-grown), it also has zero calories, and it doesn't taste icky!

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#15
For anyone considering taking Splenda as a form of weight control: It's true that Splenda has 0 calories, but it also causes your body to develop greater cravings for sweet (sugary) food/drinks. In the long term, this can cause you to eat/drink in a more unhealthy manner, undoing all the caloric benefits you thought you were getting from Splenda.

https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/healthy-drinks/...

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#16
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you tried aspartame? I've found that Coke Zero tastes much closer to real sugar than Diet Coke.

Diet Coke uses aspartame also. I figured the difference between Coke Zero and Diet Coke was branding for people who don't want to drink something labeled as diet. EDIT: I drink both regularly (including today), and I personally do not perceive difference in taste. YMMV.

Coke Light => Women

Coke Zero => Men

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#17

It's good to see that Splenda isn't the potential toxic substance we began to wonder it was, but I agree that it tastes icky. That said, I wonder why Stevia isn't considered to sweeten drinks? It's very sweet, it's natural like sugar (meaning it's not synthetic or lab-grown), it also has zero calories, and it doesn't taste icky!

I've always assumed Stevia hasn't taken off yet because that means companies have to spend money on trying to rework "flavor profiles" to work with Stevia.

I long for a Stevia-powered Coke Zero...until they realize Stevia also causes horrible things in humans :-/

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#18

Too bad it tastes weird.

I don't really understand the popularity of artificial sweeteners. They all taste totally teh ick to me. I would much rather have something that is not sweet than something that is artificially sweet. But judging from the beverage selection available at just about any convenience store, I'm possibly the only person in the USA who would rather drink something that isn't sweet than something that contains 0 calorie swe…

I think that a lot of it is what you're accustomed to drinking. I used to only drink regular colas and hated the taste of diet. I now drink only diet, and regular tastes too sweet to me.

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#19

It's good to see that Splenda isn't the potential toxic substance we began to wonder it was, but I agree that it tastes icky. That said, I wonder why Stevia isn't considered to sweeten drinks? It's very sweet, it's natural like sugar (meaning it's not synthetic or lab-grown), it also has zero calories, and it doesn't taste icky!

I've always assumed Stevia hasn't taken off yet because that means companies have to spend money on trying to rework "flavor profiles" to work with Stevia. I long for a Stevia-powered Coke Zero...until they realize Stevia also causes horrible things in humans :-/

It's not 0 calorie, but Coke does have a stevia drink called Coke Life (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coca-Cola_Life)

Re: Chemists Were Wrong About Splenda

#20

It's good to see that Splenda isn't the potential toxic substance we began to wonder it was, but I agree that it tastes icky. That said, I wonder why Stevia isn't considered to sweeten drinks? It's very sweet, it's natural like sugar (meaning it's not synthetic or lab-grown), it also has zero calories, and it doesn't taste icky!

Up until 2008, it was banned in the US for food use.

Wouldn't be surprised if sugar companies had something to do with that.

Post reply on HN