Live data from Hacker News

Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

nytimes.com

11–20 of 59 posts

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#11

The article talks about 'track and field', which isn't a term I've ever heard before. It's the athletics team that's been banned isn't it? The article even sounds confused that 'track and field' is administered by an organisation called 'International Association of Athletics Federations', which could have been a clue that the name was wrong.

At least here in Canada the term "track and field" is used to refer in general to running, jumping and throwing athletic sports.

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#12

The article talks about 'track and field', which isn't a term I've ever heard before. It's the athletics team that's been banned isn't it? The article even sounds confused that 'track and field' is administered by an organisation called 'International Association of Athletics Federations', which could have been a clue that the name was wrong.

In the US "Athletics" is generally understood to be any sport that is athletic. The "Athletics Department" at a school oversees Swimming, Squash, Football, Basketball, etc. Track & Field is a specific sport for which a school would compete: while individuals win their Track or Field competitions, the school gets points for each individual competition. This may not be how the terms are viewed outside the US, though. But high schools will have "Track & Field season", usually in the spring, which is when they have their meets.

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#13

"In general, nations have been barred because of geopolitical considerations, not doping" Right, because doping really is the sole reason for banning Russia from the games and geopolitical considerations have nothing to do with this decision at all.

Did you miss the part where it's only the Track and Field team? Russian athletes will still participate in many other events.

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#14

"In general, nations have been barred because of geopolitical considerations, not doping" Right, because doping really is the sole reason for banning Russia from the games and geopolitical considerations have nothing to do with this decision at all.

Have you read about the sophistication of Russia's doping program? Its unprecedented.

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#15

I'm at a bit of loss when it comes to being able to care. Maybe for the athletes that were possibly forced into doping, but otherwise, this is a power struggle between an incredibly corrupt state actor and an incredibly corrupt IOC. Besides, if the condition reports out of Rio are to be believed (and I see no reason not to) it's not the worst thing to stay home. http://espn.go.com/espn/feature/story/_/id/14791849/tra…

I that for any athlete, being forced out of an olympics is quite a disaster. You only have a few options within the time you are at your best, maybe two or three. I'm not saying that it is unjustified. But you can't just replace competing at the olympics with, say, a world championship.

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#17

The article talks about 'track and field', which isn't a term I've ever heard before. It's the athletics team that's been banned isn't it? The article even sounds confused that 'track and field' is administered by an organisation called 'International Association of Athletics Federations', which could have been a clue that the name was wrong.

In the US, "athletics" is usually called "track and field". Here we have "USA Track & Field" as our governing body.

[deleted]

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#18

I'm at a bit of loss when it comes to being able to care. Maybe for the athletes that were possibly forced into doping, but otherwise, this is a power struggle between an incredibly corrupt state actor and an incredibly corrupt IOC. Besides, if the condition reports out of Rio are to be believed (and I see no reason not to) it's not the worst thing to stay home. http://espn.go.com/espn/feature/story/_/id/14791849/tra…

If I read the article correctly, this isn't the IOC that is imposing the ban.

It's the IAAF, and for which the IOC needs to comply with.

From a different source, the IOC (with IAAF's blessing?) was considering allowing individual Russian Athletes to file an appeal, on the basis that punishing one athlete for the behavior of another is not justice.

I'm struggling to come up with a governing sports body that isn't corrupt on some level.

As a fan of US professional sports, I've yet to come across an athletic association that wasn't mired in some level of controversy endemic to the organization.

High school athletic programs, and even little league baseball have problems with "corruption."

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#19
This whole doping scandal explains why Russia won so many medals (gold in particular) at the last Olympics after a long decline.

2014: 33 (13 gold)

2010: 15 (3 gold)

2006: 22 (8 gold)

2002: 13 (5 gold)

1998: 18 (9 gold)

1994: 23 (11 gold)

We also have a dead head of the anti-doping committee (Nikita Kamayev), and a dead ex-head of the same committee (Vyacheslav Sinev), both suspiciously dead within two weeks.

http://www.unian.info/world/1264887-two-senior-ex-officials-...

Re: Russian Track and Field Team Barred from Rio Olympics

#20

The article talks about 'track and field', which isn't a term I've ever heard before. It's the athletics team that's been banned isn't it? The article even sounds confused that 'track and field' is administered by an organisation called 'International Association of Athletics Federations', which could have been a clue that the name was wrong.

Track and field is the American English term for what you're calling "athletics".

Wrong. Track and Field are specific events on a running track, and include events on the field, like shotput and javelin.

Obviously a millenial. I feel like I am wasting my time explaining it, when you could just look it up in a dictionary.

Post reply on HN