Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

m.youtube.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–50 of 51 posts

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#41

Post by mikeash »

freehunter wrote: post #33
jorts wrote: post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've never figured out what the green button does besides make the window larger and randomly sized. I always figured there was something that the size was tied to but never invested the time in figuring it out. I use SizeUp and never click on any of the buttons now anyway. I do miss Windows for this functionality.

Most programs I use, the green button causes the window to go full screen and switch to another desktop. But double clicking the title bar in Safari, for example, sets it to what seems to be an arbitrary width and maximized from top to bottom of the screen. I don't know how to get it to fill the entire screen without switching to another desktop.

The intent is to size the window to fit the content. For example, if you're viewing an image, then the window's size would be set to the image's size (or to the screen size, if the image is bigger than the screen).

For something like Safari, there often isn't a single sensible content size, so it ends up just trying something reasonable for the width.

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#42

Post by kemayo »

hamstergene wrote: post #27
gagege wrote: post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not familiar with this complaint. Can you explain it to me? When I click the green button the app fills up the screen, then I can just three-finger-swipe between windows, I love it. Is that what you don't like?

There is a legion of people who think macOS has maximize functionality. They would activate green zoom button and if zoomed size happens to be smaller than whole of desktop's working space (e.g. Safari), complain that maximize button is bugged.

In fairness, macOS' behavior is less predictable than maximize, insofar as what happens when you press the green button depends on the contents of the particular window.

Whether this is a problem or not depends on one's own particular tastes in OS behavior.

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#43

Post by mikeash »

Razengan wrote: post #35
staticelf wrote: post #2

Still can't believe they haven't fixed the maximize the window functionality. Windows has so much better window management. When I saw this title I thought "finally" but it appears that I'm going to be disappointed yet again.

Fullscreen gives you more space than "maximizing" and macOS has always had better multi-desktop management than Windows. With the two/three-finger swipe gestures on trackpad/Magic Mouse, in combination with the Mission Control hotkeys/hot corners, it's very convenient to slide between multiple fullscreen windows. For example I have one hot-corner set to show all desktops and another corner to show all windows for the…

Before Spaces was introduced in 10.5, the Mac had no multi-desktop management.

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#44

Post by makecheck »

fzzzy wrote: post #18
pidg wrote: post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Holding the Option key when clicking the Full Screen button is part of my muscle memory now. I never understood the reasoning behind trying to change user behavior to favor 'full screen' over 'maximize' in a multitasking OS.

You can also just double-click on the title bar. I used to be mad that they switched the meaning of the + button, but once I discovered the double click trick I have been happy. I think it is even more convenient. Another thing that made me mad in the past was when they switched New Folder from being Command-N to Command-Shift-N during the transition from Mac OS 9 to Mac OS X. Nowadays I tend to just make new folders…

The command-N change made it more consistent with most applications where “new” creates a window of some kind.

Besides, in the Keyboard section of System Preferences, you can remap any menu command to any key sequence that you want. (It is unfortunate that these mappings are as buried as they are.)

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#45

Post by zyx321 »

ja27 wrote: post #39

I've spent maybe 1% of my time on Windows in the past five years and I'm still constantly trying to snap my MacBook's windows by dragging to the edges of the screen. I've been on ChromeOS a lot lately and I really like the keyboard shortcuts there. Alt-[ or Alt-] to put a window on half the screen or Alt-= to maximize and Alt-- to minimize.

Next time you're on Windows, try Win + Arrow keys.

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#47

Post by outworlder »

kitsunesoba wrote: post #20

For window snapping I like to use Moom. I like it because it offers snapping without injecting any behaviors into window dragging so I don't find myself accidentally snapping windows when I'm really just trying to move them. It also lets me choose when I want to snap, so I get to keep standard Mac window management most of the time, but have snapping around in the cases where it makes sense.

+1 for Moom. It does what it's designed to do beautifully.

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#48

Post by WayneBro »

starquake wrote: post #5
staticelf wrote: post #2

Still can't believe they haven't fixed the maximize the window functionality. Windows has so much better window management. When I saw this title I thought "finally" but it appears that I'm going to be disappointed yet again.

I think they didn't fix it because they didn't think it's a problem. I understand it might be hard to get used to if you're used to using applications fullscreen. But when you use a 27" iMac you kinda get why it works that way. I just have a lot of big windows and actually never want to maximize any of them. Partly overlapping windows also makes it easy to switch between them. So it actually suits the way I work quit…

They didn't think that a one-button mouse was a problem for the longest time either. Apple can be wrong and they're certainly wrong here.

OS X window management is completely incoherent and not well thought out compared to Windows.

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#49

Post by ksk »

starquake wrote: post #5
staticelf wrote: post #2

Still can't believe they haven't fixed the maximize the window functionality. Windows has so much better window management. When I saw this title I thought "finally" but it appears that I'm going to be disappointed yet again.

I think they didn't fix it because they didn't think it's a problem. I understand it might be hard to get used to if you're used to using applications fullscreen. But when you use a 27" iMac you kinda get why it works that way. I just have a lot of big windows and actually never want to maximize any of them. Partly overlapping windows also makes it easy to switch between them. So it actually suits the way I work quit…

>But when you use a 27" iMac you kinda get why it works that way.

That is optimizing for the least common use case. It makes even less sense to do that, than to just have a maximize button.

Re: Window Snapping in macOS Sierra [video]

#50

Post by staticelf »

bluejekyll wrote: post #11
staticelf wrote: post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well on my main computer I am running a 34" screen with 3440x1440 in resolution. But when on a MacBook you really want to be able to maximize the window. Also, on my large screen, with Windows, I can drag any window to the side and have it maximize the space that is left which is just perfect.

Have you tried the split screen with two full screen apps? I do this all the time now with an editor and terminal next to each other. In fact I pretty much use full screen apps and spaces all the time now, reminiscent of my UNIX setup with fvwm.

Yes I do that all the time on Windows, it's a lot harder on a macOS though.
Post reply on HN