Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 63 posts

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#41
post #35

Here's my idea for getting more money to open source. Someone please implement it, I'm too busy right now. Central repository (database with website and API frontends) that contains links to donation pages for all open source software. This is crowdsourced information. So if you search for "spark", apache spark appears with link to donation page, and of course more obscure packages will be added as well. Then a CLI t…

Nice idea!

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#42
post #40
post #35

Here's my idea for getting more money to open source. Someone please implement it, I'm too busy right now. Central repository (database with website and API frontends) that contains links to donation pages for all open source software. This is crowdsourced information. So if you search for "spark", apache spark appears with link to donation page, and of course more obscure packages will be added as well. Then a CLI t…

I think this is a great idea. I would love to build it, but don't think I have the breadth of knowledge necessary. Does anything already exist like the CLI tool to determine what OS packages are in your project?

I think the first step is a website that has all of the donation information. This has a search engine to query projects, and the ability to submit / edit information like a wiki. This step needs to happen first. Once this is working, you can start building tools off of this information, like the rest API and the scanning tool.

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#43

Paying per commit seems as sensible as paying per LOC (related story: [1]). Simple recurrent monthly donations as one can easily set up (eg. on Flattr) make more sense, in my opinion. [1] http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Negative_2000_Lin...

Issues closed is probably a better metric, though there's no actually good metric for software development.

"Released Versions" would be a metric more in line with other creative arts on Patreon (finished comics, finished short stories, finished songs, ...). You can still game what constitutes a "released version", for instance including every patch release kicked off by a CI system, but if you stick towards something more like semver's definition of a minor release as your goal you have something of a benchmark idea of what constitutes a "finished release".

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#44
post #37
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Patreon is more popular, though, and used by a lot of artists. You'll need more arguments than "well it exists too" to convince users to sign up for both.

It seems to not be there now, but some months ago, patreon's entry page listed out the types of "creators" that one could sign up as. As I recall, this list seemed to take actual pain to not mention open source software, among an otherwise exhaustive list of creative endeavors including not just art, music, writing, but technical endeavors as well as such as research. I always took this to mean "programmers not welco…

I'm not so sure, there are compelling arguments for both "Writing" and "Crafts & DIY." I think I prefer the latter.

$Manager: What are you working on today?

$Programmer: The usual Cratfting/DIY.

$Manager: OK, sounds good.

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#45
post #40
post #35

Here's my idea for getting more money to open source. Someone please implement it, I'm too busy right now. Central repository (database with website and API frontends) that contains links to donation pages for all open source software. This is crowdsourced information. So if you search for "spark", apache spark appears with link to donation page, and of course more obscure packages will be added as well. Then a CLI t…

I think this is a great idea. I would love to build it, but don't think I have the breadth of knowledge necessary. Does anything already exist like the CLI tool to determine what OS packages are in your project?

Stackshare could be a basic source, as an example, check Airbnb:

http://stackshare.io/airbnb/airbnb

(so a company imports its Stackshare profile & you make a list of the open source projects they're using, and if you have donation information from those projects you show it)

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#46
post #45
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this is a great idea. I would love to build it, but don't think I have the breadth of knowledge necessary. Does anything already exist like the CLI tool to determine what OS packages are in your project?

Stackshare could be a basic source, as an example, check Airbnb: http://stackshare.io/airbnb/airbnb (so a company imports its Stackshare profile & you make a list of the open source projects they're using, and if you have donation information from those projects you show it)

That's a superb idea, but I think that would happen after first getting the basic donation information. I will set up a website to gather this with a description of what the project is trying to accomplish, and see if it gets any traction.

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#47
post #45
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this is a great idea. I would love to build it, but don't think I have the breadth of knowledge necessary. Does anything already exist like the CLI tool to determine what OS packages are in your project?

Stackshare could be a basic source, as an example, check Airbnb: http://stackshare.io/airbnb/airbnb (so a company imports its Stackshare profile & you make a list of the open source projects they're using, and if you have donation information from those projects you show it)

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#48
post #46
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Stackshare could be a basic source, as an example, check Airbnb: http://stackshare.io/airbnb/airbnb (so a company imports its Stackshare profile & you make a list of the open source projects they're using, and if you have donation information from those projects you show it)

That's a superb idea, but I think that would happen after first getting the basic donation information. I will set up a website to gather this with a description of what the project is trying to accomplish, and see if it gets any traction.

Yes, let me know, I'll be happy to help and/or continue the brainstorming You can ping me: matias AT insaurral.de :D

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#49
post #48
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a superb idea, but I think that would happen after first getting the basic donation information. I will set up a website to gather this with a description of what the project is trying to accomplish, and see if it gets any traction.

Yes, let me know, I'll be happy to help and/or continue the brainstorming You can ping me: matias AT insaurral.de :D

Thanks! I'll shoot you an email

Re: Ask HN: Patreon for open source?

#50
post #46
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Stackshare could be a basic source, as an example, check Airbnb: http://stackshare.io/airbnb/airbnb (so a company imports its Stackshare profile & you make a list of the open source projects they're using, and if you have donation information from those projects you show it)

That's a superb idea, but I think that would happen after first getting the basic donation information. I will set up a website to gather this with a description of what the project is trying to accomplish, and see if it gets any traction.

I think http://donate.money would be a great place for this.
Post reply on HN