Live data from Hacker News

US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

android.googleblog.com

51–60 of 106 posts

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm quite excited to try it. Unfortunately (or fortunately) i'm on T-Mobile, with a no contract $30/m Unlimited text/data plan (very few minutes) , and that's just really hard to beat. Note that this plan might not be available anymore.. not sure really, but i know i often get flack for being on this plan from tmo. It clearly isn't making them enough money, but my god, i love it.

It's 100 minutes a month if I'm not mistaken. Can't say for sure if the plan still exists, but it's almost impossible to find any advertising regarding it. You have to specifically ask for it like those quesadillas at Chipotle. I was happy with it for a couple years but switched to google Fi when I got my Nexus 6P and I'm perfectly happy with it.

As my tmo plan may suggest, i rarely use minutes. Fi only offers a minutes oriented plan, and i hate that pricing. Feels like i would be wasting money.

Oh, question for you if you don't mind: Since you were on Tmo, can you compare the reception/coverage for Fi vs Tmo? In theory Fi would have better reception due to more networks, but i'm not really sure how much Tmo and Sprint differ in network size/locations. Thoughts?

I'm in USA-WA and the hills/mountains really cause reception issues. So the reception coverage is important to me. (Nothing beats Verizon, unfortunately)

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am also using and loving Google Fi so far. No manipulative billing practices designed to obscure the true cost. Reasonable metered data prices. The only downside is having to use a Motorola phone. They seem to always break within 1.5 years of purchase.

You can stick an activated Fi SIM in an iPhone if you want. It's undocumented, but it works fine. The only thing I lost was smooth switching between cellular and wifi, but otherwise I've been quite happy with it.

And iMessage on your root phone number, right?

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#53
post #38

I must say Project FI has worked out really nice for me. I'm usually in Wifi range, so my data usage is very low. Works out to around $27 each month. And the service is really good. BUT, I live in the constant fear of Google shutting down the service. In fact I'm slowly finding myself skeptical of adopting new Google products because I'm worried it will go away.

I hear you on the fear of Google shutting it down but I wouldn't with Project Fi. This is a communications product. They need people to get fast access to their products. This product will never go away, just like their Fiber efforts. They purchased Grand Central like 10 years ago and never killed it. Grand Central -> Google Voice -> Project Fi.

Google voice languished for years with no updates, no bug fixes (despite a lot of serious problems!)

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#55
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I hear you on the fear of Google shutting it down but I wouldn't with Project Fi. This is a communications product. They need people to get fast access to their products. This product will never go away, just like their Fiber efforts. They purchased Grand Central like 10 years ago and never killed it. Grand Central -> Google Voice -> Project Fi.

Google voice languished for years with no updates, no bug fixes (despite a lot of serious problems!)

And it is specifically excluded from Google Fi (you may import your number, but no going back).

My biggest gripe with Fi is that there is no way to check voicemail or handle SMS through the web interface. That was the most useful aspect of Voice for me.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#56
post #38

I must say Project FI has worked out really nice for me. I'm usually in Wifi range, so my data usage is very low. Works out to around $27 each month. And the service is really good. BUT, I live in the constant fear of Google shutting down the service. In fact I'm slowly finding myself skeptical of adopting new Google products because I'm worried it will go away.

Android is so core to Google's business that I don't think they will kill it. It's become something of a selling point on their Nexus phones. I'll be disappointed if I have to switch.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#57
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, US Cellular seems to be the only cell phone towers I can get on roaming when an area is "middle of nowhere" and I'll see a small dealer/shop in small towns. Like you said, they seem to specialize in markets that other carriers wouldn't bother with, like remote parts of Alaska, or small mountain towns.

As far as the Rockies are concerned, Verizon seems to have the best coverage by far. I've had a cell phone since '96, and ~99% of the resort towns have the big 4, but VZ is in the most remote places I've seen. Edit: Here is an interesting chart of wireless providers in the US [0]; lots more providers w/ 10K-1M subcribers than I realized. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_wireless...

Which part of the Rockies? AT&T has hands-down the best coverage at the ski resorts in Colorado. They even have coverage in A-Basin, which is a dead zone to everyone else.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's 100 minutes a month if I'm not mistaken. Can't say for sure if the plan still exists, but it's almost impossible to find any advertising regarding it. You have to specifically ask for it like those quesadillas at Chipotle. I was happy with it for a couple years but switched to google Fi when I got my Nexus 6P and I'm perfectly happy with it.

As my tmo plan may suggest, i rarely use minutes. Fi only offers a minutes oriented plan, and i hate that pricing. Feels like i would be wasting money. Oh, question for you if you don't mind: Since you were on Tmo, can you compare the reception/coverage for Fi vs Tmo? In theory Fi would have better reception due to more networks, but i'm not really sure how much Tmo and Sprint differ in network size/locations. Though…

Total Wireless offers a plan with unlimited talk and text and 5GB of data for $35 on Verizon's network. It is throttled at 5Mbps, but if you use little enough data to make Fi worthwhile I don't think that will be an issue for you.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#59
post #55
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google voice languished for years with no updates, no bug fixes (despite a lot of serious problems!)

And it is specifically excluded from Google Fi (you may import your number, but no going back). My biggest gripe with Fi is that there is no way to check voicemail or handle SMS through the web interface. That was the most useful aspect of Voice for me.

https://support.google.com/fi/answer/6188337?hl=en

"Once you do this, your text messages and voicemail will sync across Hangouts everywhere, including: Gmail chat, Google+ Page or profile, Chrome desktop app, Android or iOS device, Inbox by Gmail, or the Chrome extension."

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#60
post #55
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google voice languished for years with no updates, no bug fixes (despite a lot of serious problems!)

And it is specifically excluded from Google Fi (you may import your number, but no going back). My biggest gripe with Fi is that there is no way to check voicemail or handle SMS through the web interface. That was the most useful aspect of Voice for me.

It's possible to transfer your number back to Google Voice after you cancel Project Fi:

https://support.google.com/fi/answer/6079398

However, it's not guaranteed:

"Google Voice’s number availability changes regularly, so even if your number was previously on Google Voice, it can’t always be transferred back. If you’d like to keep this number, we recommend transferring it to another carrier that supports it."

Post reply on HN