Live data from Hacker News

US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

android.googleblog.com

21–30 of 106 posts

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#21

Good to see the network growing! Looking at US Cellular's coverage map ( https://www.uscellular.com/coverage-map/coverage-indicator.h... ), this news won't benefit the sf bay area, but help users in the northwest, northeast, and midwest.

It'll be good for truly last mile users, I imagine SF bay area has plenty of options (although I know they want Google too), this seems to provide a possible broadband ISP option for those that would otherwise have none.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#22
post #6
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can you expand on your experience? Is there just not enough coverage or is it something else that makes it mediocre? Where are you located? I was thinking of switching from Verizon (bay area) and would be interested to hear from someone who's already using it.

As someone from the bay area who has also had a mediocre experience, I can maybe answer: Speeds have been fine, but there are areas where it'll show full bars but provide no data (like in BART stations, my hunch is that those use femtocells that don't handle FI users properly). Additionally, occasionally it'll swap networks (I think, goes from LTE/HSPA/3G) and the 'swaps' have like 30 second switchover times. Then th…

Data service is great, voice is terrible, at least in my experience in the Bay Area. I can even use my phone under the Transbay Tube (which I couldn't when I had AT&T). I also have problems with shortcodes taking forever to arrive (but they usually do show up). Voice however is horrible. All kinds of fade outs and drops happen when talking for more than a few minutes. Overall though I'm way happier with them than I was with AT&T.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am also using and loving Google Fi so far. No manipulative billing practices designed to obscure the true cost. Reasonable metered data prices. The only downside is having to use a Motorola phone. They seem to always break within 1.5 years of purchase.

I'm quite excited to try it. Unfortunately (or fortunately) i'm on T-Mobile, with a no contract $30/m Unlimited text/data plan (very few minutes) , and that's just really hard to beat. Note that this plan might not be available anymore.. not sure really, but i know i often get flack for being on this plan from tmo. It clearly isn't making them enough money, but my god, i love it.

It's 100 minutes a month if I'm not mistaken. Can't say for sure if the plan still exists, but it's almost impossible to find any advertising regarding it. You have to specifically ask for it like those quesadillas at Chipotle. I was happy with it for a couple years but switched to google Fi when I got my Nexus 6P and I'm perfectly happy with it.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#25

Its good to see them expanding the networks, if only a little. I've been on Project Fi for ~6 months or so and its been a fairly mediocre experience so far, but it works well enough for the price point I suppose.

I am also using and loving Google Fi so far. No manipulative billing practices designed to obscure the true cost. Reasonable metered data prices. The only downside is having to use a Motorola phone. They seem to always break within 1.5 years of purchase.

You can stick an activated Fi SIM in an iPhone if you want. It's undocumented, but it works fine. The only thing I lost was smooth switching between cellular and wifi, but otherwise I've been quite happy with it.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#26

Unless they offer LTE in Canada, this doesn't compare well to my T-Mobile plan, other than diverse networks. That's the one thing that definitely put me off trying it.

I haven't been to Canada with Project Fi, but I got LTE all over London, Madrid, Copenhagen, Berlin and Málaga with them. I'd think that Canada has similar infrastructure in place :)

There is, at least in Montreal and the parts of Ontario that I visited on the way up there. (Traveling from central NY)

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#28
post #24

I wanna switch to project fi but I just can't get over how cheap tmobile's 5GB LTE for $30 is.

I switched from tmobile's $30 unlimited (5gb lte) plan. I'm definitely paying $10-15/month more now, but I also travel frequently. The international coverage makes it worthwhile for me.

As far as phone expenses go, I think I'm still doing pretty well though.

Re: US Cellular Now a Part of Project Fi's Network

#30
post #29

This is cool and all, but I'm worried that Google will just pull the plug during one "spring cleaning" event. Plus T-Mobile's $100/4 lines/2 GB per line is just unbeatable right now... cheaper and more data.

> Plus T-Mobile's $100/4 lines/2 GB per line is just unbeatable right now... cheaper and more data.

Except you don't have worldwide roaming included in your plan, which you have to pay extra for.

That's a reason why I'm not changing from Fi. Also the fact that data I don't use is reimbursed.

Post reply on HN