Live data from Hacker News

Educate Your Immune System

nytimes.com

111–113 of 113 posts

Re: Educate Your Immune System

#111
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When presented with milk, many adult mammals (including some humans) will drink it. Humans are simply better than most at getting their way with other species -- this is the primary difference, is it not? For example, I have seen apparently healthy and non-starving adult black bears, some dogs, and cats happily consume cow milk if it is available. There are pros and cons to it, for sure, but there is clearly nutritio…

> healthy and non-starving adult black bears, some dogs, and cats happily consume cow milk if it is available. How does that prove milk is good for us? Or for them? Non-starving animals and humans can also enjoy the taste of junk food, we don't judge junk food's nutritional value based on that.

> How does that prove milk is good for us? Or for them?

Such proof was neither requested nor attempted. The challenge I responded to was, "Name one mammal besides humans who drink milk as adults?"

Clever cats have domesticated their humans (who then domesticate cows) to provide milk on a regular basis. ;-)

Re: Educate Your Immune System

#112
post #74
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Milk is not necessary for humans. AKA kids must be given milk everyday in our schools for them to be healthy. Its a treat and not a requirement.

Drinking milk has been around for more than long enough for (some of) us to have evolved dependence on it. Not saying that we have, but "other animals get by without it" is not a slam-dunk case.

Err, dependence? Maybe a preference, sure, but how are any humans dependent on cows' milk?

Re: Educate Your Immune System

#113
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I did all that except the milking by hand and the rare showering (grew up in 36-40 °C place), in addition to being barefoot in the mud everywhere, and all I got for all that is a propensity for catching the flu every year. My brother grew up when we started moving out of this sort of environment (so he had 4 years less of this) and he falls sick much less than I do. My guess is that other factors dominate.

> a propensity for catching the flu every year. I don't think that a faraway childhood affects resistance to the flu, right now, significantly. Maybe to some of the maladies mentioned in the article. The fact is the immune system is an engine, just like everything else in the human body. People who exercise more get sick less often. People who exercise more get sick less severely. People who have sex more often have…

Ha ha, I walked right into that. Well played.
Post reply on HN