Live data from Hacker News

GNU Taler 0.0.0 released

lists.gnu.org

11–20 of 202 posts

Re: GNU Taler 0.0.0 released

#11
post #9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Linux. Systemd. GNU. YaST. Git. Blender. These are all programs under the GPL, and the reason they are so successful is because of the defense that copyleft provides against proprietary software. In short, no. Not dead in the water.

While parent post may be overstating , GPL does hinder software adoption now days.

Why? Users can still use it, programmers might not be able to make proprietary forks of it, but can certainly write programs to interoperate with it.

Re: GNU Taler 0.0.0 released

#12
post #8
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Linux. Systemd. GNU. YaST. Git. Blender. These are all programs under the GPL, and the reason they are so successful is because of the defense that copyleft provides against proprietary software. In short, no. Not dead in the water.

Taler uses various *GPL3+ licenses, including parts under AGPL3+ Linux, Systemd, Git, and Blender are all (L)GPL v2, and none are AGPL. There are thousands of open source projects I could name that are far reaching and have enormous success, released under permissive licenses such as Apache, BSD, MIT, etc. If the system wasn't so fucked I'd down vote you.

Noted. Good to know that people have forgotten how hard the free software community had to fight to be able to even have free software. I don't understand the sudden amnesia when Microsoft releases one part of their stack under the MIT license while still enslaving users. It's doublethink.

Re: GNU Taler 0.0.0 released

#14
post #9
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Linux. Systemd. GNU. YaST. Git. Blender. These are all programs under the GPL, and the reason they are so successful is because of the defense that copyleft provides against proprietary software. In short, no. Not dead in the water.

While parent post may be overstating , GPL does hinder software adoption now days.

When I hear "GPL" I get an instant software arousal so I disagree.

Re: GNU Taler 0.0.0 released

#15
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Taler uses various *GPL3+ licenses, including parts under AGPL3+ Linux, Systemd, Git, and Blender are all (L)GPL v2, and none are AGPL. There are thousands of open source projects I could name that are far reaching and have enormous success, released under permissive licenses such as Apache, BSD, MIT, etc. If the system wasn't so fucked I'd down vote you.

Noted. Good to know that people have forgotten how hard the free software community had to fight to be able to even have free software. I don't understand the sudden amnesia when Microsoft releases one part of their stack under the MIT license while still enslaving users. It's doublethink.

Did I once mention proprietary software or Microsoft?

Is that really how you see the software world, GPL vs Microsoft/proprietary?

Re: GNU Taler 0.0.0 released

#16

So, semver is great and all, but 0.0.x releases just look silly, in my opinion. I've never seen someone zero index the least significant column before though, which makes it look even worse. Would people actually expect w piece of software marked as version 0.0.0 to be anything more than a placeholder?

It's funny that programmers treat zero-indexing arrays and things as normal (even "correct"), but suddenly zero-indexing versions is something wacky. What's weird to me is that 0.0.0 isn't more common in the developer world, given how frequently we start counting from 0.

Re: GNU Taler 0.0.0 released

#17

So, semver is great and all, but 0.0.x releases just look silly, in my opinion. I've never seen someone zero index the least significant column before though, which makes it look even worse. Would people actually expect w piece of software marked as version 0.0.0 to be anything more than a placeholder?

I'm happy to see the 0.0.0 release - it means that I might just be using this some day. Few weeks ago, having not heard about the project for a while, I was afraid it had become vapourware.

Re: GNU Taler 0.0.0 released

#20
post #5
post #4

GPL'ed. Dead in the water. But it looks interesting. Good luck guys!

Linux. Systemd. GNU. YaST. Git. Blender. These are all programs under the GPL, and the reason they are so successful is because of the defense that copyleft provides against proprietary software. In short, no. Not dead in the water.

All software primarily used on Linux systems. You'll never ever see systemd outside Linux. Ever. BTW good luck with that mess too. Same with yast. You'll never see that outside Linux. Ever. You're creating quite the ecosystem of NIH and Linux only software. Btrfs, systemtap, etc. So "successful" is a seriously objective word as you use it. But good luck, you're going to need it methinks.
Post reply on HN