Live data from Hacker News

Jawbone stops production of fitness trackers

techinsider.io

11–20 of 57 posts

Re: Jawbone stops production of fitness trackers

#11

I have the slight impression that the fad is wearing out on fitness trackers It most likely will be replaced by "in watch" features or just left in a drawer

I use my phone as a cycling computer and only need a $50 heart-rate monitor to make it as fully featured as I need.

Re: Jawbone stops production of fitness trackers

#14
post #10

For Jawbone, Fitbit et al. the hardware has been commoditized, the software has limited utility and the whole 10,000 steps a day seems like a fad. It's incredibly hard to maintain users once the honeymoon period ends. Personally, I'm long on UA, but I still have some lingering doubts about their acquisitions with ConnectedFitness and the their Healthbox or whatever. I'm a pretty competitive triathlete and all of my g…

Ok, I bough a suunto last year, and I have been hesitating between it a a garmin. It's not a big deal, eventually what ever does the job is good enough, I just want to run. But as a geek I like gadget review :) So, why do you prefer garmins ?

Re: Jawbone stops production of fitness trackers

#15
post #10

For Jawbone, Fitbit et al. the hardware has been commoditized, the software has limited utility and the whole 10,000 steps a day seems like a fad. It's incredibly hard to maintain users once the honeymoon period ends. Personally, I'm long on UA, but I still have some lingering doubts about their acquisitions with ConnectedFitness and the their Healthbox or whatever. I'm a pretty competitive triathlete and all of my g…

lol... every triathlete is "pretty competitive" ;). My wife and I switch to running and are using garmin vivoactives. The battery life is amazing and works great swimming (no gps)

My non-active friends mostly ditch their fitbit style devices after a few months. Its either an apple watch, microsoft band (not joking) or some type of running/multisport watch.

Re: Jawbone stops production of fitness trackers

#16
Too bad. My UP3 is pretty new, so I can't comment on longevity, but I like the idea of something that doesn't try to be a watch, and, in the case of the UP3, knows its limits and doesn't try to measure active heartrate when it can't do it right.

Hopefully this is just clearing out the warehouse before releasing something better.

But yeah, the app could use some bug-fixing.

Re: Jawbone stops production of fitness trackers

#18
post #11

I have the slight impression that the fad is wearing out on fitness trackers It most likely will be replaced by "in watch" features or just left in a drawer

I use my phone as a cycling computer and only need a $50 heart-rate monitor to make it as fully featured as I need.

Sorry for the offtopic, but can you explain a bit more about your setup? Which phone app do you use while cycling? Android or iOS?

Re: Jawbone stops production of fitness trackers

#19

Personal anecdote: I had three Jawbone fitness trackers that stopped working within months. Granted, two of them were replaced by Jawbone, but after a third I stopped bothering. The bracelet design was thin and elegant as opposed to the bulky Fitbits. Inside, jawbone bracelets had several very small PCBs arranged in a row, connected by wires, with a protection layer of epoxy glue or something. The whole construction…

Same exact experience. I had my jawbone, had it replaced for free, now broken again. I still use it for sleep tracking/alarm.

I have a Fitbit brand new still in its package that I will never open and wear, too wide and unaesthetic for my taste.

Re: Jawbone stops production of fitness trackers

#20

Personal anecdote: I had three Jawbone fitness trackers that stopped working within months. Granted, two of them were replaced by Jawbone, but after a third I stopped bothering. The bracelet design was thin and elegant as opposed to the bulky Fitbits. Inside, jawbone bracelets had several very small PCBs arranged in a row, connected by wires, with a protection layer of epoxy glue or something. The whole construction…

I can also attest to the poor quality of the UP bands. I'm currently on my 5th band in 3 years. One lost band and 4 replacements later, I'm really only using them to continue with the sleep tracking.

I discovered early on that the step counting wasn't really that great of a feature or selling point. I made it a habit to inform people around me that really the best feature and the only reason why I continued to use the UP was for sleep tracking.

Post reply on HN