Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Mailhero – a more permanent temporary email

mailhero.io

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–30 of 91 posts

Re: Mailhero – a more permanent temporary email

#21

Post by ehnto »

schneems wrote: post #15

I made something almost exactly like this 6 years ago. Called whyspam.me Good luck.

I feel like this kind of service would be used for nefarious means pretty regularly, and subsequently the people trying to track that kind of activity would be knocking on the door quite often. Did you find that to be an issue?

Once upon a time I considered a similar service that could be abused and ultimately chose not to go ahead because it simply "isn't my problem" to deal with those two groups of people. I wanted no part in it, for good or evil, even as an unbiased conduit.

Re: Mailhero – a more permanent temporary email

#25

Post by derekja »

guptaneil wrote: post #9

Sounds awesome, would love to try it. Spent 5 minutes trying to sign up, but every variation of usernames that I tried were taken. This normally wouldn't be an issue to complain about, except that in order to test whether a username is available or not, I have to enter the username, password, and captcha every time. Please please please tell me whether or not a username is taken as a type it before I go further.

yeah, total fail. Every variation of my fairly uncommon name including random numbers at the end of my full name.

Re: Mailhero – a more permanent temporary email

#26

Post by tempestn »

ceejayoz wrote: post #5
nfirvine wrote: post #4

How is this different/better than Gmail's address+spammer@gmail.com?

Spammers know to take off the +spammer part.

Also you have to maintain the rules filtering out all the +spammers indefinitely. Presumably with this service or something like it, whenever you wanted to you could just create an entire fresh id. (As well as the ability to turn off specific addresses as they describe.)

Re: Mailhero – a more permanent temporary email

#27

Post by wtbob »

barbs wrote: post #23
newman314 wrote: post #19

Why can't it just be some random hash? For me, a key benefit of a disposable mail account is not to have any identifiers including username.

You could make your username be some random hash?

> You could make your username be some random hash?

Why not? 285e5c0452918bf77370c4a013317be4cf5e1ff690cc33a7346e837f59cdca58@foobarbaz.invalid is, I believe, a valid email address. If that's too long, you can always truncate it.

Re: Mailhero – a more permanent temporary email

#30

Post by kenshaw »

findjashua wrote: post #28

With gmail, you can create a custom email for each service, like so: youremail+service@gmail.com Later on, if the service doesn't let you unsubscribe, or sells your email to other spammers, you can just set a filter to trash emails sent to youremail+service@gmail.com

Anyone with half a clue that is doing heavy marketing via email, knows to strip the stuff after the +. BTW, the + is part of the email specification, and technically any email server not supporting it is broken.
Post reply on HN