Live data from Hacker News

Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

telegraph.co.uk

31–40 of 99 posts

Re: Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

#31

In my almost 40 years of living, I've learned one thing about women, they love attention, and you better learn when is necessary to give it to them and when is better for both if you ignore them.

True but trivial, in that what you say is also true for men.

It might still be useful to say, since some men occasionally need reminding that women are humans with human behavior.

Re: Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

#33
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there any research that show being peer reviewed in fact makes a difference? General speaking, I would think research should just speak for itself.

Generally speaking, you think... well that's nice. Meanwhile, in the world of the scientific method, the issue is that everyone needs to know that you didn't just write something down for fun or profit. If your results can't be replicated... thbbpt.

> If your results can't be replicated

Results aren't replicated during peer review, are they?

Re: Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

#34
Anecdotal hand-waving BS: Something I've noticed over the last several years are people who feel so victimized in some way that they actually begin acting like their victimizer. Gay people who anonymously act violently homophobic. Black people who paint KKK images on campus property. Weird.

I'd guess it's just a very small minority of people who are like that, but online, in aggregate form, it could turn into a significant number. It'd be interesting to see some stats about this.

Re: Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

don't worry, females are probably responsible for half of that other stuff too.

I don't see it that way at all. I think the sort of casually calling other women slags and hoes or whatever (ie normalised internalised misogyny) is a very different ball game to the gamergate style evil shit that happens.

(Anecdotal) Doxxing long predates Gamergate and from what I've seen from BBS and hacker communities on IRC, women participate in doxxing just as much as men.

Re: Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

#37
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Generally speaking, you think... well that's nice. Meanwhile, in the world of the scientific method, the issue is that everyone needs to know that you didn't just write something down for fun or profit. If your results can't be replicated... thbbpt.

> If your results can't be replicated Results aren't replicated during peer review, are they?

Not necessarily, but at least the methods can be evaluated to see how likely it is that they can be. A black box with, "Trust us, here's what we found" is weak as hell, unless you're still into Pons and Fleischmann I guess.

Re: Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

#38

A woman calling another a whore is misogyny? Being against promiscuity is misogyny?

Being against female promiscuity while praising or ignoring male promiscuity is definitely misogyny.

Edit: Additionally, being against both in the current society is, while not necessarily misogynist in itself, contributing to a misogynistic society - there's many more people who will speak up to tell a man that the weird-ass person who told them they're bad for being promiscuous is wrong then would tell a woman the same, the result being that telling a woman that she's bad for enjoying sex has more impact than telling a man the same. You don't actually see many masculine-gendered terms for shaming the enjoyment of sex, and those that do exist are not used in a derogatory context very often.

Re: Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

#39

Headline seems a bit misleading. "Half of online abuse" seems to suggest that this study is representative of the internet as a whole instead of just twitter. While the findings are still worthwhile, I think we'd see different results if the study could have included sites like 4chan, reddit, tumblr or even facebook. Of course, there are practical challenges to getting accurate demographic information on those platfo…

Additionally it wasn't looking at broad online abuse, it was looking specifically at (according to the Guardian reporting of this study) the uses of the word "slut" and "whore" in terms of online misogyny.

Re: Study finds women are responsible for half of some online abuse on Twitter in UK

#40
post #24

I'd like to know what percentage of online abuse was directed at women. My hunch would have been 50/50 for dealing it out, but I am not so sure the split is even for taking it.

The article does link to one investigation from The Guardian about abusive comments left on articles written by journalists whose genders are known.

I don't know, then. The Guardian is a leftist newspaper that is known for posting articles written by feminist trolls as a bait.

https://i.imgur.com/9sxIFSP.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/Ve6XWIa.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/3VWWYqZ.jpg

Obviously, with articles like these, what kind of comments do they expect?

Post reply on HN