Live data from Hacker News

Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

techcrunch.com

81–90 of 414 posts

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#81
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've seen it. It depends on the referrer. When coming from Reddit, visitors will not be redirected.

test link: http://i.imgur.com/PhY2HUP.jpg is this happening for anyone in thread? maybe try holding down CTRL and hammering the link to see if it's a probability thing? I have never seen the behavior being described.

Following that link on mobile safari leads to a page that contains ads and comments in addition to the image.

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#82
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've seen it. It depends on the referrer. When coming from Reddit, visitors will not be redirected.

test link: http://i.imgur.com/PhY2HUP.jpg is this happening for anyone in thread? maybe try holding down CTRL and hammering the link to see if it's a probability thing? I have never seen the behavior being described.

Result: http://i.imgur.com/86BlJiS.png

There does appear to be some kind of heuristic at work here. For example, following the above link results in the traditional behavior for me, but following your link leads to the full imgur page.

EDIT: Ah-ha, figured it out.

1. Click on an i.imgur.com link

2. If it takes you to the full page, right click on the image and click "Open in new tab"

3. The original i.imgur.com link will now take you to the direct image.

Amusing heuristic. After following these steps, I'm unable to reproduce my own screenshot. http://i.imgur.com/PhY2HUP.jpg always takes me to the direct image.

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#83
post #31
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What dark patterns are they implementing?

"direct" links to an image uploaded sometimes/usually redirect to imgur page, with lots of ads and shitty content, obnoxious, animated overlays that block out part of the image on mobile, etc

also on mobile, every time you look at a photo there's a banner encouraging you to get its app

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#84
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair, bandwidth isn't free. Imgur can't serve hotlinked content for free, forever.

Then they should never have started. Why does every 'free' service on the Internet inevitably devolve into an ad-laden, tracker-enabled shitfest?

unfortunately nothing is free in this world

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#85

Looks like it's backed by S3 x-amz-storage-class: REDUCED_REDUNDANCY Content-Type: image/jpeg Server: AmazonS3 Can't imagine that AWS bill...

> Can't imagine that AWS bill...

That's not how things work over here.

We can and do imagine. We even calculate estimate values so we don't have to stay in the dark and reason without a solid basis.

I'd encourage you to find some traffic numbers provided by imgur and some S3 pricing to do a rough estimate. Maybe someone more knowledgable will pop in and improve on that. When we argue everyone involved shall be wiser after. That's how it works around here.

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#86
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've seen it. It depends on the referrer. When coming from Reddit, visitors will not be redirected.

test link: http://i.imgur.com/PhY2HUP.jpg is this happening for anyone in thread? maybe try holding down CTRL and hammering the link to see if it's a probability thing? I have never seen the behavior being described.

huh interesting. the first time it brought me to a page but after that it's direct link

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#87

Looks like it's backed by S3 x-amz-storage-class: REDUCED_REDUNDANCY Content-Type: image/jpeg Server: AmazonS3 Can't imagine that AWS bill...

At Reddit's scale they would be able to negotiate directly with AWS for lower rates. I'm sure they already do so with servers.

[ deleted ] -- I removed it because I got tired of trying to explain the nuance.

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#88
post #23

I don't know why reddit would want to take on the burden and cost of dealing with images. It might make it incrementally easier, but with something like RES the entire thing was seamless. Seems like a misplaced focus on a feature that doesn't bring that much value, and a lot more cost. I'll be curious to see how successful this ends up being. If they wanted to concentrate on making the site easier to use, they should…

Reddit basically needs an image hosting service to succeed, and Imgur is now at least as obnoxious as all the previous generation of hosts that lead to it being created in the first place

The bigger issue is Imgur has been leveraging their monopoly on Reddit's image hosting to build a new social commentary system to replace Reddit. If Reddit didn't do something then maybe in five years Reddit will be dead and Imgur will be the front page of the internet.

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#90
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At Reddit's scale they would be able to negotiate directly with AWS for lower rates. I'm sure they already do so with servers.

[ deleted ] -- I removed it because I got tired of trying to explain the nuance.

That is absolutely false. Plenty of large companies are able to negotiate their rates on AWS. You just have to be huge.
Post reply on HN