Live data from Hacker News

Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 414 posts

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#12
post #3

Bad news for Imgur...

Yep. Imgur realized that being solely a user-friendly image host wasn't much of a money maker, so they started gradually turning into the Photobucket style messes that it was originally aiming to destroy. Now they run their own community/discussion site and try to show it down the throat of anyone who lands there trying to look at a picture. It's not been good for the user experience of anyone who was just there for…

Question. What's wrong with making just a little bit of money?? (which is presumably still more than i will ever see!)

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#14

It seemed like Imgur has been getting ready for this for awhile. The experience using it hasn't been that great since direct linking stopped working on mobile.

Last time I've opened an imgur link on mobile I got served with an ad popup and a "virus warning" dialog. That is something I haven't seen in a long time. Imgur seems to go the way of SourceForge.

To be fair, I think those are usually the fault of malicious ads getting into whatever ad networks imgur uses and they usually get rid of them fairly quickly. They used to pop up every few weeks but I haven't seem them recently (in my experience as a daily imgur user for the past year or so).

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#15
I don't know why reddit would want to take on the burden and cost of dealing with images. It might make it incrementally easier, but with something like RES the entire thing was seamless. Seems like a misplaced focus on a feature that doesn't bring that much value, and a lot more cost. I'll be curious to see how successful this ends up being. If they wanted to concentrate on making the site easier to use, they should have hired the people who made RES.

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#17
post #7
post #3

Bad news for Imgur...

Still it is used by StackExchange

Plus countless forums and community sites around the internet. And it's not like redditors will switch away from imgur all at once, it's going to be a long process..

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#18
Having a third party host Reddit's images gave away a bunch of control to the point that imgur has its own community based upon the site . At the time Reddit didn't have the resources to make a competitor but this seems to be a good move now that imgur is doing dark patterns.

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#19
post #3

Bad news for Imgur...

Bad news for the current shareholders of imgur.

All we want is an easy and reliable image hoster. You upload an image, they host it, you can link it, fin.

Perfect plan!

Except for the plot hole of not generating any money this way. That's where the suits creep in. First they finance you to grow and grow quickly you must. Imgur did it. Then you experiment with some methods of generating ad views or other revenue. People realize they hit on a gold mine and business starts to grow like cancer. Then there are some minor changes to optimize revenue. Then some founders start to cash out and jump the ship. Then the suits, loudmouths and ginas slowly but surely take over the company and due process replaces the dictatorship of the personal union of owner and leader. There's guitars and barbecue as the corporate drones dance around the firepit of burning money as they hurry to please the gods of corporate capitalism. A spiral is forming like a siphon circling around itself pulling everything in like a black hole. And it's great.

If you listen carefully in the storm of excitement you can hear a faint voice who still remebers the core of the business: Provide the service and don't fuck with the customer.

Or as some politicians said: You can fuck over some of your customers all the time and you can fuck over all of your customers for some time. Both is a great business plan. But you cannot fuck over all of your customers all of the time. Especially not if you don't have a stranglehold on their necks like a dictator or monopoly has.

The imgur we have today deserves to die.

It may redeem itself by remembering its roots and not wanting to become more than it is. That would be great!

One thing that is more important over the whole debacle is to watch reddit closely and be ready to jump ship quickly as they stumble deeper into the corporate trap. Having a plan B "just in case" for everything important will cost you resources but it pays out for itself in the long run.

Re: Reddit launches image uploads, ditching alliance with Imgur

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Last time I've opened an imgur link on mobile I got served with an ad popup and a "virus warning" dialog. That is something I haven't seen in a long time. Imgur seems to go the way of SourceForge.

This seems like a common pattern 1. Realize you need to make a lot more money (to meet investor expectations, pay for the fat the company has accumulated, etc) 2. Panic 3. Apply dark patterns ( http://darkpatterns.org/ ) 4. Something better comes along and eats your lunch 5. Repeat. It's sad because imgur was originally created as the "something better".

I'm sure they made mistakes but when you see massive growth like imgur did someone's gotta pay the sever bills somehow. Plenty of image uploading sites have come and gone because of server costs.
Post reply on HN