Live data from Hacker News

Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

blog.whatsapp.com

11–20 of 228 posts

Re: Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

#11
Windows 8 minimum? Is this an UWP app or what's the reasoning here?

Edit: I downloaded and successfully launched this on Windows 7. It seems like a standard Electron app. Now I wonder if the Windows 8 requirement is purely for tech support reasons, or if there's some specific feature that would fail on Windows 7.

Re: Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

#12
post #5

This just seems to be exactly like the Whatsapp Web running in the browser. I don't understand what benefit comes from the native client.

I see three "nice to have" benefits: full keyboard, copy and paste text/links when you're browsing the web and sending images taken with a traditional camera. None of these are essential for sure and I for one prefer using my phone but sometimes it can be handy.

Re: Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

#14
post #13
post #7

This is not an independent app. It is still tethered to the phone, and can't work without it :(

Their servers do not store unencrypted messages so they need to come from the phone.

I guess they could do an "untethered" desktop version but they don't really want to. Solve syncing of history etc but it's doable. But they just love living in your pocket. It's all about owning you, and that's easier if they stay with you all the time.

Re: Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

#15
Is anyone qualified to comment on what this will do with my OS X address book and similar data should I open it?

edit: on the plus side, looks like it's just their web app repackaged using Electron. Still not sure what all these helpers are for though

Re: Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

#16
post #2

No linux version. I was almost convinced that this was going to be another Electron app (after slack went that route)

I recommend Franz (http://meetfranz.com/). Does Whatsapp, works on Linux, mac, pc. Supports Slack, WeChat, HipChat, Facebook Messenger, Telegram, Google Hangouts, GroupMe and Skype.

Re: Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

#17
post #5

This just seems to be exactly like the Whatsapp Web running in the browser. I don't understand what benefit comes from the native client.

With a desktop app you can easily and quickly command-tab to it if you want to use it. In contrast with a web app it's often awkward and time consuming to find the window/tab of the web app you're running amongst your other browser windows/tabs.

Chrome has that sorted already on android, where you can run up a site with a home screen link, different icon and separate listing in the task list. Given the work they've recently put in on full screen mode on desktop it looks like they're maybe a couple of versions away from having something similar on desktop

Re: Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

#18
post #10

Still tethered to a phone... i'll just keep using this https://github.com/Aluxian/WhatsApp-Desktop

Of course its still tethered. Does the app you linked bypass the tethering ? I fail to see the benefits offered by the app you linked over the official client.

Re: Introducing WhatsApp's Desktop App

#19
post #11

Windows 8 minimum? Is this an UWP app or what's the reasoning here? Edit: I downloaded and successfully launched this on Windows 7. It seems like a standard Electron app. Now I wonder if the Windows 8 requirement is purely for tech support reasons, or if there's some specific feature that would fail on Windows 7.

Microsoft doesn't support Windows 7 any more, why should WhatsApp?
Post reply on HN