Live data from Hacker News

iTunes Has Slowly Destroyed My Will to Collect Music

slate.com

1–10 of 114 posts

Re: iTunes Has Slowly Destroyed My Will to Collect Music

#3
From what I've seen of iTunes ability to keep album art that I've added or automatically download ones I'm missing, there's no way in hell that I'd let it match my music collection.

Some of the cover art is ok, some is meh (special edition banners), and some is in the WTF range (one zydeco album especially).

Not that I have that much that's not mainstream, but I'm kind of particular about the stuff that's in there.

Re: iTunes Has Slowly Destroyed My Will to Collect Music

#6
I was thinking about this while driving recently - both the iTunes / Apple Music approach, and the way I go about organizing and sorting my things.

As a guy who grew up with Mac until playing catch-up with Win95 (and some DOS to fit in), being familiar with digital storage techniques has formed over time. I get the concept of certain files being certain places - system files versus personal files versus program resources. This kind of structuring appeals to me.

Thus, rather than totally embrace the "OS as Helper" technique that Windows likes (put everything in "Music") or going the iTunes route (behemoth management program with hooks to other stuff), I maintained some of my fencing habits. Sure, I use the "Music" folder but that's only for purchased music. In a separate folder - which makes things easier to back-up I think - I have my "Music Projects" folder.

In my workflow I've got my DAW projects and output separate from what I'd consider the 'commercial music' area, and this might have saved a lot of stress that Pinkstone went through. Maybe not, but my hunch is it might have helped. iTunes can't touch what it can't see, and letting it anywhere near a collection of bootlegs and/or "less than legal" origin files is something I would avoid out of general suspiciousness. That applies to original works that don't fit any standard cataloging function either; I don't think that would help me.

Personally I'm still satisfied with Winamp, a couple skins and visualization things (it does help me ID3 tag my music as well), and honestly can't recall if I've ever installed iTunes in the past 10 years. I genuinely don't think so, and while my own process has flaws and issues (overlap of versions, DAW files are big, etc) there's some protection I kind of like in a way.

Re: iTunes Has Slowly Destroyed My Will to Collect Music

#8
In recent years iTunes on OS X has managed to achieve the feat of becoming more bloated, sluggish, and yet also losing important features.

I've spent most of the last five years hoping Apple are re-writing the thing from scratch, and have been neglecting any meaningful updates to the current fork in the meantime, but I'm losing hope.

Re: iTunes Has Slowly Destroyed My Will to Collect Music

#9
post #4

Wasn't that claim determined to be a hoax?

I know something has deleted several dozen MP3s from my collection. The end result of which is iTunes would refuse to sync my phone. Because those two features belong in the same app, and all. In the end I had to delete my entire iTunes music library and start fresh, just so my phone would sync
Post reply on HN