Live data from Hacker News

O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

theawl.com

121–130 of 187 posts

Re: O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

#121

There are decent readers out there. Liferea or Thunderbird will do in a pinch, and much as I hate to admit it, Netvibes is actually superb. The tragedy isn't some Google tool being retired, the tragedy is the way feeds are slowly disappearing. It's a slow and creeping death, but it's a death. More and more sites are dropping their feeds and replacing them with some twitterish Facebook nonsense. [edit: typo]

> The tragedy isn't some Google tool being retired, the tragedy is the way feeds are slowly disappearing. It's a slow and creeping death, but it's a death. More and more sites are dropping their feeds and replacing them with some twitterish Facebook nonsense.

It's certainly painful, made all the more painful by the death of Yahoo! Pipes which was helpful in turning these (once rare) non-RSS sites into something usable.

The closing of Reader signalled this change (which is why so many of us lamented it so much; not for the product itself, but for what it meant for the web). If you fight hard enough, you can still turn all of this garbage into RSS and toss it into your feed reader (I like tt-rss), but RSS as a mainstream tool is already dead (outside of a few niches, like podcasts, which are also slowly moving into walled gardens of their own).

Re: O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

#122
I am obligated to post a link to BazQux[0], which completely nails the RSS reading experience that Google Reader once had. It's absolutely worth the $20/yr subscription.

I am still amazed that it doesn't seem to get any discussion or attention whenever these "favorite RSS reader" threads come up.

[0]: https://bazqux.com

Re: O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

#123

I am obligated to post a link to BazQux[0], which completely nails the RSS reading experience that Google Reader once had. It's absolutely worth the $20/yr subscription. I am still amazed that it doesn't seem to get any discussion or attention whenever these "favorite RSS reader" threads come up. [0]: https://bazqux.com

And it's made with Ur/Web, which deserves to be used a lot more.

Re: O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

#126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is that... normal? 2350 feeds seems like an astronomical amount of news feeds. Can I ask how much of that do you read?

Agreed, very curious how much of that actually gets even glanced over. I thought I was information overload with ~150 sites. I hope OP uses the 'focus' features so they can get a modicum of information from those 2350 feeds.

But is your intention really to read every post by every site you're subscribed to? Someone subscribed to over 1000 sites isn't trying to avoid missed posts - they're just dipping into the stream of sites they're interested in at any given moment.

Re: O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

#127
post #105
post #101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry, I don't agree: heavy Google Reader user and now a NewsBlur one. While I appreciate the NewsBlur existence it is very very very slow while Google Reader was extremely fast. I don't know if NewsBlur only retrieves my feeds when I start a request or if it constantly retrieves them on the backend. Disclosure: I have 2350 feeds in NewsBlur.

Downvotes to this are very suspicious since it is a fact that goes in the opposite direction of other comments in the thread.

I suspect your disclosure (2300 feeds!) overly negated what would have been valid criticism of the tool...

Re: O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

#128
post #101

I've been paying for newsblur ( http://www.newsblur.com/ ) ever since google reader bit the dust. It's pretty much a direct replacement. Interface has come a long way since day one and is sufficiently slick now (UI, keyboard shortcuts, etc) that I don't really notice it. Highly recommended by a (former) hardcore google reader user. If I recall correctly, got quite a good bit of press here on HN at the time.

Sorry, I don't agree: heavy Google Reader user and now a NewsBlur one. While I appreciate the NewsBlur existence it is very very very slow while Google Reader was extremely fast. I don't know if NewsBlur only retrieves my feeds when I start a request or if it constantly retrieves them on the backend. Disclosure: I have 2350 feeds in NewsBlur.

Maybe try bazqux. Super fast, written in haskell https://bazqux.com/faq

Re: O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

#129
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

RSS feeds were just never easy enough for most people to bother. And not just the proverbial grandma, most techies don't use RSS either. Sites will run analytics and see that nobody is clicking the feed button. RSS certainly solves a real problem, so I think there is an opportunity for reinventing RSS with better UX. Don't ask me how though.

How do you get better UX than clicking an RSS link and it adding itself to your feed reader? It isn't the protocol, it is that there is no profit in an open standard like that. Google killed their Reader because they wanted everyone forced into G+, rather than consuming content from around the Internet. It is the same thing with messaging and VOIP. Nobody wants to use an open standard like XMPP or more recently Matri…

> How do you get better UX than clicking an RSS link and it adding itself to your feed reader?

Well, you need to have a feed reader set up.

Re: O Reader My Reader – Remembering Google Reader

#130
I am maintaining an open source simple aggregator: https://github.com/JARR/JARR and using it since more than 5 years. It has evolved a lot since...

It is possible to test it here: https://jarr.herokuapp.com This instance is limited in resources... It is deployable quite easily (a vagrant configuration file is also provided).

Post reply on HN