Live data from Hacker News

Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

iceddev.com

21–30 of 79 posts

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#21
post #3

Yeah it's a clone of the trivial parts of the Echo, but not the difficult parts that are necessary to make it great, specifically: * Beamforming microphone array (this is a real clone: http://www.xmos.com/products/microphones ) * Wake-word / hot-word detection ("Ok Google", "Alexa", etc.) * Intent recognition / NLU

wow, that microphone array you linked costs USD$750! Are there any cheaper alternatives?

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#22
post #3

Yeah it's a clone of the trivial parts of the Echo, but not the difficult parts that are necessary to make it great, specifically: * Beamforming microphone array (this is a real clone: http://www.xmos.com/products/microphones ) * Wake-word / hot-word detection ("Ok Google", "Alexa", etc.) * Intent recognition / NLU

I'm not sure why posters on HN are so eager to shit on other people's work. Maybe something to do with arrogance or insecurity (leading to a need to bash on others)?

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#23
Does anyone know how the Google TTS voices in the example are exposed by Google? Is there an API / service for these? I haven't been able to find it.

I was able to use them on PageNodes via the "espeak" output just fine, but would like to use them directly in my own apps.

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#24
post #3

Yeah it's a clone of the trivial parts of the Echo, but not the difficult parts that are necessary to make it great, specifically: * Beamforming microphone array (this is a real clone: http://www.xmos.com/products/microphones ) * Wake-word / hot-word detection ("Ok Google", "Alexa", etc.) * Intent recognition / NLU

I'm not sure why posters on HN are so eager to shit on other people's work. Maybe something to do with arrogance or insecurity (leading to a need to bash on others)?

Or maybe calling it an "Amazon Echo clone," which insinuates it covers almost all the bases Echo does, was a bit premature? It could have just been called "voice controlled PDA"

I don't think it's "shitting on" it (although text is notorious for making things seem far more serious or critical than they actually are), just clarifying the remaining differences.

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#25
post #23

Does anyone know how the Google TTS voices in the example are exposed by Google? Is there an API / service for these? I haven't been able to find it. I was able to use them on PageNodes via the "espeak" output just fine, but would like to use them directly in my own apps.

This might help you: https://github.com/monteslu/pagenodes/blob/7388ce58726836cf6...

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#26
post #23

Does anyone know how the Google TTS voices in the example are exposed by Google? Is there an API / service for these? I haven't been able to find it. I was able to use them on PageNodes via the "espeak" output just fine, but would like to use them directly in my own apps.

The source for pagenodes is here: https://github.com/monteslu/pagenodes and you can look at src/editor/nodeDefs/core/espeak.js as an example.

Also MDN has some pretty good documentation on the WebSpeech API https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Web_Speech_...

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#27
post #23

Does anyone know how the Google TTS voices in the example are exposed by Google? Is there an API / service for these? I haven't been able to find it. I was able to use them on PageNodes via the "espeak" output just fine, but would like to use them directly in my own apps.

[deleted]

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#28
post #11
post #3

Yeah it's a clone of the trivial parts of the Echo, but not the difficult parts that are necessary to make it great, specifically: * Beamforming microphone array (this is a real clone: http://www.xmos.com/products/microphones ) * Wake-word / hot-word detection ("Ok Google", "Alexa", etc.) * Intent recognition / NLU

Even if true, not sure why you wrote such a snarky comment. This obviously is a side project of the author and just serves as an inspiration, it's not like he is asking money for it or anything.

I think it's probably because the headline called it a clone, which sort of implies 1:1 feature parity. It's neat, but it's not a clone.

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#29
post #21
post #3

Yeah it's a clone of the trivial parts of the Echo, but not the difficult parts that are necessary to make it great, specifically: * Beamforming microphone array (this is a real clone: http://www.xmos.com/products/microphones ) * Wake-word / hot-word detection ("Ok Google", "Alexa", etc.) * Intent recognition / NLU

wow, that microphone array you linked costs USD$750! Are there any cheaper alternatives?

Xmos mainly sells development kits to showcase their chips - that's why they're that expensive.

Re: Jarvis: an Amazon Echo clone in your browser

#30

Unfortunately, I think my first chatbot that I wrote about a year ago, and named Jarvis (based on Hubot by Github) will be cloned by a million of these projects... I admit, it's not the most creative name; I just thought it would be cool a year ago to feel like Iron Man as I asked Jarvis to deploy my application to production...

Are you trying to imply that this project is copying your name...?
Post reply on HN