Live data from Hacker News

This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

bloomberg.com

31–40 of 48 posts

Re: This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

#31
We don't need super-solutions/magic bullets for electric generation. Tidal could fill in where its best suited, such as Newfoundland. Imagine if we had:

20% Nuclear (been this for decades)

25% Natural Gas (27% now)

23% Wind (4% now)

22% Solar (1/2% now)

5% Tidal (none now)

5% Hydro (6%-7% for decades)

and no coal at all. (35%-50% for decades)

Re: This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

#32

We don't need super-solutions/magic bullets for electric generation. Tidal could fill in where its best suited, such as Newfoundland. Imagine if we had: 20% Nuclear (been this for decades) 25% Natural Gas (27% now) 23% Wind (4% now) 22% Solar (1/2% now) 5% Tidal (none now) 5% Hydro (6%-7% for decades) and no coal at all. (35%-50% for decades)

We kitesurf in a river mouth, the river is tidal. Behind the beach are a couple of pools that are huge, these get filled and emptied by the tide twice a day. The volume of water that slooshes out is amazing. Staggering. We love to kite there cos we convert the energy into speed.

Re: This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

#34

David MacKay's "Sustainable Energy - without the hot air" [1] does a good job of putting energy sources like this in perspective. Wave energy is indeed challenged by issues with mechanical parts; however, the reality is that there isn't much wave energy their to begin with. As MacKay puts it, "sun makes wind and wind makes waves" [2]. Waves are just diluted sunshine. Sandia National Labs does a good job of putting th…

Wind generators and some aspects of solar cells use rare earth metals. The big advance of this particular company is not using rare earth magnets.

Re: This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

#35
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's literally what every species on the planet is trying to do, as well as they can.

All species self-regulate. If you feel you're able to provide notable research countering this, please do; happy to admit I'm wrong. https://www.google.com/search?q=species+self-regulation

The first page of results* from your own recommended search will provide you an answer: ecosystems self-regulate. Animals starve. It's not quite the same thing as the wise and forward-looking animals of the forest that you appear to be arguing for.

*I realize that my first page might not be your first page - perhaps based on our differing search histories.

Re: This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

#36
post #35
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All species self-regulate. If you feel you're able to provide notable research countering this, please do; happy to admit I'm wrong. https://www.google.com/search?q=species+self-regulation

The first page of results* from your own recommended search will provide you an answer: ecosystems self-regulate. Animals starve. It's not quite the same thing as the wise and forward-looking animals of the forest that you appear to be arguing for. *I realize that my first page might not be your first page - perhaps based on our differing search histories.

Yes, I'm aware of that search result, and for the matter the concept; sometimes being direct is less useful than being indirect.

Expecting all animals to be wise in my opinion is unreasonable, I would hope that some animals are able to be reasonable.

Cyanobacteria is the only animal I am aware of (beyond homosapiens) that has been responsible for a significant extincion event on Earth.

Re: This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

#37

We don't need super-solutions/magic bullets for electric generation. Tidal could fill in where its best suited, such as Newfoundland. Imagine if we had: 20% Nuclear (been this for decades) 25% Natural Gas (27% now) 23% Wind (4% now) 22% Solar (1/2% now) 5% Tidal (none now) 5% Hydro (6%-7% for decades) and no coal at all. (35%-50% for decades)

I am personally excited about tidal as it is almost completely predictable. The wind may die down and clouds may block the sun, but the tide always comes in on schedule.

Re: This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

#38
How do these things stay on station? I live near the Gulf of Maine. When we have an ocean storm, the lobster buoys and sometimes the navigation buoys end up on the beach and have to be put back where they go. Other times they end just lost in the ocean.

Sometimes divers have to go find the lobster pots. Pots that can't be pulled are very wasteful.

Putting these generator things back might be quite costly. It will certainly create jobs for commercial divers.

How do they keep the cables (surface to that big old tire thingy hanging in the water) from getting tangled or broken in storms? That U. Maine wave tank should be able to help them figure it out; its purpose is storm simulation.

How do they get their power to a shore-based distribution point?

Re: This Device Could Provide a Third of America's Power

#40

David MacKay's "Sustainable Energy - without the hot air" [1] does a good job of putting energy sources like this in perspective. Wave energy is indeed challenged by issues with mechanical parts; however, the reality is that there isn't much wave energy their to begin with. As MacKay puts it, "sun makes wind and wind makes waves" [2]. Waves are just diluted sunshine. Sandia National Labs does a good job of putting th…

Wind generators and some aspects of solar cells use rare earth metals. The big advance of this particular company is not using rare earth magnets.

Not sure that is true, the large generators don't use permanent magnets. Old school generators used a small DC motor with permanent magnets to power the field windings. However I think the generators in large wind turbines use an inverter to proved power to the field windings. (So that they can account for small mismatches between the line frequency and shaft speed)
Post reply on HN