Live data from Hacker News

Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

code.google.com

41–50 of 119 posts

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#41

I wonder if people at Google know how awful it is to report an Appengine bug. You have to battle for days to get your bug acknowledged. I've noticed that they've added more support people since the early days but it's still a pain as they seem to have an incentive to answer the tickets as fast as possible without doing any real investigation. The linked issue is a good example of this behavior.

They have paid support if you want it.

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#42
post #7

Sendgrid is a great alternative and not hard to set up.

Yeah, but pricing is ten times Appengine's (actually more - recently we don't seem to be being charged for email at all). Amazon SES is the only service with a comparable cost that I've found. I'd love to hear of other alternatives at the 1c/100 level.

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#44
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They should be working on a migration tool for users of AppEngine to migrate to Google Container Engine.

We wouldn't use it. To me, the whole point of Appengine is to abstract out system administration. GCE (like AWS) abstracts out the systems, but not the administration - you suddenly become responsible for all the scaling, fault-tolerance, and all the subsystems that Appengine manages for you.

Confusingly enough Google Container Engine != GCE. GCE is Google Comput Engine, which doesn't abstract out much of the administration. Google Container Engine (or GKE) on the other hand does abstract out most of the administration via Kubernetes. We were recently attempting to use appengine for something but gave up due to how bad the support for Go is and migrated to GKE. It definitely isn't quite as abstracted as Appengine but it's darn close.

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#45
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They should be working on a migration tool for users of AppEngine to migrate to Google Container Engine.

We wouldn't use it. To me, the whole point of Appengine is to abstract out system administration. GCE (like AWS) abstracts out the systems, but not the administration - you suddenly become responsible for all the scaling, fault-tolerance, and all the subsystems that Appengine manages for you.

I believe you're talking about GCE (Compute Engine), while @kordless is talking about Container Engine.

I've tried Containers with Google App Engine Flexible Environment (in beta now) and liked that it's much more customizable than standard GAE. Basically, you just need any Docker container listening on port 8080. But deploy time took 10-20 minutes, so I'm still preferring Standard. Hopefully they'll fix that before GA release.

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#46
post #16

Reading through the thread, it looks like in the last few days it's been narrowed down to "messages which contain the URL of the App Engine instance silently disappear with no bounces or errors."

And only sometimes. The issue resolved itself on my app two weeks ago. My guess is there is an outgoing spam filter run amok in some of the clusters.

I wrote about this last year, but I feel it's still relevant. Spam filters, especially Google and Microsoft's (whose e-mail servers don't play by any of the standard rules nor do they send DMARC reports), are horrible over aggressive.

http://penguindreams.org/blog/how-google-and-microsoft-made-...

I have seen more phishing/ransomware e-mails come through mine (lots of malicious Javascript made to look like Excel files), so I can understand how great the risk is. The fact still remains though. E-mail is broken and is less reliable than an envelop dropped in a letterbox.

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#47
post #8

At least a few reported that it was bouncing at the destination once they set up an appropriate handler. They are only "not being sent" when there is a url in the message and that is a big red flag on the receiving side (not much text but a url). It doesn't look like an App Engine problem. It looks like messages being identified as spam problem.

Not the case for me. No bounces being reported. In any case, gmail and outlook don't bounce messages for spam; They put them in the spam bin. Nothing whatsoever changed in my code. I haven't touched it in a year, and all of sudden email stopped on the 1st of April. There's nothing in the changelogs to indicate there was a change that should cause this behaviour. It's absolutely an App Engine problem. https://cloud.go…

No, gmail constantly drops messages without putting them in spam. That's actually a huge problem. Microsoft does the same. That's for e-mails that don't even contain any links!

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#48

I wonder if people at Google know how awful it is to report an Appengine bug. You have to battle for days to get your bug acknowledged. I've noticed that they've added more support people since the early days but it's still a pain as they seem to have an incentive to answer the tickets as fast as possible without doing any real investigation. The linked issue is a good example of this behavior.

I wonder if people at Google know how awful it is to report... No. (Or they don't care.)

[deleted]

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#49
post #8

At least a few reported that it was bouncing at the destination once they set up an appropriate handler. They are only "not being sent" when there is a url in the message and that is a big red flag on the receiving side (not much text but a url). It doesn't look like an App Engine problem. It looks like messages being identified as spam problem.

I ran into a similar problem a while back (using Heroku) --- after a brief foray into the world of spam filtering, it turned out to be caused by our domain being identified by SpamAssassin (IIRC) as a spam signal. We changed the wording of our emails and moved to a different subdomain and suddenly all the email got through. It was.. interesting to debug.

Re: Google App Engine Silently Stopped Sending Email 5 Weeks Ago

#50

I'm pretty surprised by the long wait times between "updates" from support... that's pretty rough. I understand it can be hard to get a good signal to noise ratio with support, but when so many other people are reporting issues, perhaps it's time to take it a bit more seriously? This thread is a great example of why support is so hard.

not really. I wish I could get away with providing such crap support as the big players do.

If my customers don't get a reply within a few hours, then all hell breaks loose. Even if, there request comes in at 3am / 0300 on a Sunday morning my time.

To be fair, when I point this out to them they do apologise, didn't realise time difference, are in a different part of the world where Sunday is not a day off etc. I then ask what they expect from some billion dollar companies support wise and they say they are happy with a reply within a week. Asking them why a one man shop doing quite a bit less than billions of dollars is expected to provide so much more.

Anyway, rant over. Support isn't hard. You hire enough competent people as your customers require. The end. Happy customers

Post reply on HN