Live data from Hacker News

Russian photographer matches random people with social network photos

rbth.com

11–20 of 135 posts

Re: Russian photographer matches random people with social network photos

#11

I keep trying to figure out why this feels so wrong and creepy. You're in public, you can't avoid some random person from taking your picture. You have a public profile, you post pictures of yourself there, in public. But some how this feels... wrong, why is that? Something about the surprise of it? It feels like a surprise, it feels like something that shouldn't be so easy.

> But some how this feels... wrong, why is that?

It is not voluntary.

Re: Russian photographer matches random people with social network photos

#13
post #7

So, you can no longer assume being anonymous when walking down the street. If your random photo is matched with your profile, you can be basically fully identified anywhere. With all those cameras everywhere, you could be fully tracked.

Given that there are public images with your face in them and name connected to them, that can be searched by a neural net... Yes.

Re: Russian photographer matches random people with social network photos

#15

I keep trying to figure out why this feels so wrong and creepy. You're in public, you can't avoid some random person from taking your picture. You have a public profile, you post pictures of yourself there, in public. But some how this feels... wrong, why is that? Something about the surprise of it? It feels like a surprise, it feels like something that shouldn't be so easy.

There's a... presumption that this is difficult and that all these disparate services and fragments of identity are distinct and separated. This stunt demonstrates that this is not true. It violates some basic assumptions.

Re: Russian photographer matches random people with social network photos

#16
post #2

The artist (or the article) suggests that the pictures he took on the metro are the 'real' person, whereas the pictures on the social site are the 'ideal' person. I'm not so sure. I think its very possible that the person in the social network photographs is actually far closer to the person they really are than the photo of them riding alone on the subway.

I don't think we are very good barometers for what kind of people we are. This is why having a confidant/BFF is so important.

Re: Russian photographer matches random people with social network photos

#17

I keep trying to figure out why this feels so wrong and creepy. You're in public, you can't avoid some random person from taking your picture. You have a public profile, you post pictures of yourself there, in public. But some how this feels... wrong, why is that? Something about the surprise of it? It feels like a surprise, it feels like something that shouldn't be so easy.

I'm more surprised that people are surprised. You provide images to the public with your name and face connected to even more personal data.

Why are you surprised that this data can then be used by a third, or even a fourth party?

Re: Russian photographer matches random people with social network photos

#18

I keep trying to figure out why this feels so wrong and creepy. You're in public, you can't avoid some random person from taking your picture. You have a public profile, you post pictures of yourself there, in public. But some how this feels... wrong, why is that? Something about the surprise of it? It feels like a surprise, it feels like something that shouldn't be so easy.

I think it feels wrong because for all of human history a person could take for granted a degree of anonymity while among strangers, and more and more that seems to be no longer the case.

Forever, if someone recognized you, chances are you recognized them. People were either within some extended social circle or they were not, and this social circle was face-to-face. Now, we have something of an arms race going on with respect to anonymity, or the lack thereof. Maybe someone will scan me and identify me. What's my recourse? Either I go about in disguise, or I scan everyone around me in order to equalize things.

How could all this not feel strange or wrong? Based on the norms of 10,000 years of human society, it's either a-social or downright anti-social.

Re: Russian photographer matches random people with social network photos

#19
This is one of the cool features people have discussed for the past 20 years for wearable computers. I was hoping it would come to fruition with Google glass until Google got all weird about facial recognition on glass (and subsequently glass as a whole).

On one side it is creepy, on the other it would be nice to have your digital assistant suitably remind you the name of the person who is walking towards you and recognizes you but you cannot remember who they are. A quick summary of who they are and perhaps a summary of your last interaction whispered in your ear could be handy. Or even a couple of relevant recent headlines about their company, etc.

Of course creepy side is pointing at random stranger on street and instantly having their digital dossier overlaid on their face.

Post reply on HN