Live data from Hacker News

The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

npr.org

151–160 of 218 posts

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#151
post #145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some laptop do. Most? I'm not so sure of that.

Do MacBooks?

Not the 2008 model. I don't know about newer ones.

"iSeeYou: Disabling the MacBook Webcam Indicator LED"

https://jscholarship.library.jhu.edu/bitstream/handle/1774.2...

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#152
For a while there, when built-in webcams weren't quite as common, my employer would either remove the camera completely or, if that wasn't possible, they would smash the lens and sensor with a metal punch.

They eventually quit (now we can use Lync to do video calls, even) but a lot of people now put little sliding windows over their cameras (you can get them at conferences these days, branded with the Splunk logo or whoever's giving them out)

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#153

EFF sells a sticker set specifically for this purpose: https://supporters.eff.org/shop/laptop-camera-cover-set

They're really nice, too. Thick enough to block almost all light. And Post-It Note-like glue, so you can remove and replace the sticker occasionally.

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#154
post #15
post #3

I don't really understand the webcam paranoia. If my computer is completely compromised, somebody watching my face is the least of my worries.

The first Apple iSight cameras, back in the days of Firewire, had this nifty mechanical iris that covered the lens. A twist of the bezel ring and it opened, another and it closed. Granted, just that feature was 6 times the volume of a modern webcam and probably three times the cost, but it did perfectly address people's discomfort with the eye staring at them. For some reason, the ear listening to them doesn't seem t…

Early SGI cameras had a physical lens cover, too. I wish that were still the norm, although I certainly see how hard it'd be to build into the frame of a thin laptop.

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> they know the metrics they need to hit to advance within that organization This is really the one. It seems like the country is in a crisis of metrics. Nobody trusts anybody to do their job anymore so everything has to have a surrounding bureaucracy with the stated purpose of keeping everybody honest but having the actual consequence of setting many misguided and contradictory rules and then strictly enforcing an a…

Wish I could upvote you a million times. Many supposedly capitalistic organizations are in fact like miniature Soviet Unions.

Bureaucracy and hierarchy are the same no matter the ideological varnish.

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have no reason to believe that he's a snake - quite the opposite. He seems to be a man with strongly held convictions and a keen eye for reason. I certainly don't always agree with him, but he's thoughtful and thorough, as can be observed from his many interviews and his recent book. I can respect a person without agreeing wholeheartedly with them, and such is the case for Hayden. Comey, on the other hand, seems to…

I am hesitant to engage at this level, but - you just couldn't be more wrong about Comey. I know him to be every bit as thoughtful and reasonable as your glowing description of Hayden. That doesn't mean I agree with all of his positions, but he is one of the smarter people I've met, and I do not believe that is an indication of how sheltered my life has been. I also know him to be perfectly capable of acknowledging w…

Might you share an example of what leads you to believe that Comey is capable of acknowledging when he's gotten things wrong, changing course, and moving on? I've never had the chance to meet him but even General Hayden's remarks on Comey seem less glowing than yours. For example, while Hayden does describe Comey as a "very competent" and "very honourable man", Benjamin Wittes, in a conversation with Hayden, described some "not so veiled hostility to Comey" in Hayden's recent book [0]. Hayden has, in my view, been able to weigh the national security benefits on encryption alongside the national security risks. I've never once heard Comey speak with any degree of clarity or comfort on the issue, and has instead doggedly pursued his goal of ensuring the FBI's access into content data. Thus, I've described him as a 'one-track-mind kind of guy'.

Well, I'm not sure if my comment about "the worst kinds of cops" is necessarily hyperbolic or even emotional, but I can see how it does make having 'purely rational discourse' more difficult. Surely, a singular focus and unwillingness to consider the validity of alternative perspectives is not unique to some members of the law enforcement community, but I think that the shorthand I employed does cut to the core of my understanding of Comey; He doesn't understand this issue as well as the technology experts who, virtually uniformly, disagree with his position on crypto.

[0] Hayden did rebuff that characterization, though I think the public forum might have had something to do with it.

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#157
post #105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Stop using it altogether" isn't a viable option, because it's not this particular laptop whose security is questionable, it's every laptop.

That may be true, but again, what do you care about more, your files and key strokes, or your webcam. If you have tape over your webcam but you still use online banking, you are a fucking idiot. You either have faith in the security of your computer, and log into your bank (risking hackers stealing all your money) or you don't. But if you don't think twice about saying anything you want in front of your computer or l…

My Laptop is issued to me by my employer, and I have no control over the security of it..

I have no personal information on it

and you bet I have tape over the camera. Not just because of security, but many communications apps simply turn it on by default when you start a session... Lync, WebEx, Hangouts etc...

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a pattern you see in a lot of high-performing people. They aren't particularly interested in the 'big picture'. They may say they are, they may think they are, but on a practical, day-to-day basis, it's irrelevant. They know the mission of their organizational unit, they know the goals that need to be accomplished to achieve that mission, they know the metrics they need to hit to advance within that organizat…

> they know the metrics they need to hit to advance within that organization This is really the one. It seems like the country is in a crisis of metrics. Nobody trusts anybody to do their job anymore so everything has to have a surrounding bureaucracy with the stated purpose of keeping everybody honest but having the actual consequence of setting many misguided and contradictory rules and then strictly enforcing an a…

What are the alternatives? I'm honestly asking. How can I coordinate the activities of 100+ people to a common goal, without providing intermediate goals to individuals?

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#159
post #29

I care about audio so much more than video, and text/keys/etc captured from the machine even more. As long as my screen and keyboard are out of the frame of the camera, I don't really care about it getting RATed. At worst, you'll see me naked, or making angry/etc. faces at someone on irc or email. While embarrassing it would be less bad than most of what you could accomplish by stealing actual information. OTOH, carr…

How can you trust Dell or Lenovo, if you don't trust the FB I or NSA (or Chinese intelligence community)?

Re: The FBI Director Puts Tape Over His Webcam

#160

To me, Comey is a man who has lost the goal in pursuit of his particular mission. Defense, intelligence, policing, all these things exist in order to uphold the constitution, protect the "American ideals", etc. Many of his statements pretty directly show that he doesn't care about the collateral damage to innocent people's privacy or any founding principles, he just wants his mission to be unhindered. It's the same m…

Something else to consider: Comey is also the man who famously rushed to the bedside of a very ill John Ashcroft who was being asked by Alberto Gonzales to reauthorize the warrantless wiretapping [now known as STELLAR WIND] to stop it because he felt it was illegal. Like he actually threatened to quit and was acting AG. [1] I'm no way trying to defend his agency's actions on encryption - it's chilling and probably on…

This just underscores that people are complex, fallible, and inconsistent and that we rarely have the full story.

With people like this, I'd just really like to get them alone in a room, off the record, and probe their beliefs, motivations, why they did things, etc.

I wonder what it was like to work with Comey at Bridgewater Associates.

Post reply on HN