Live data from Hacker News

Google Saves

google.com

31–40 of 84 posts

Re: Google Saves

#31
post #3

The problem I have with Google tech, especially after the new Nest stuff has to come to light, is that there's no guarantee they'll support it for very long. It's entirely possible that I'll incorporate this into my workflow, just for Google to kill it off a year later.

You can say the same for every early-stage startups since most of them die anyway.

Re: Google Saves

#33
post #3

The problem I have with Google tech, especially after the new Nest stuff has to come to light, is that there's no guarantee they'll support it for very long. It's entirely possible that I'll incorporate this into my workflow, just for Google to kill it off a year later.

Yeah this is way too niche, ill-defined, and overlapping with existing products to ever survive. Why don't they just make a convenient set of clients or extensions to map into a product that's not going to disappear next quarter, like Drive/Docs/whateverthehellitisnow.

If you use Google Chrome, there is a official Save to Google Drive extension which appears to do the same thing as Google Saves, and more, minus the Material layout.

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/save-to-google-dri...

Re: Google Saves

#35
post #3

The problem I have with Google tech, especially after the new Nest stuff has to come to light, is that there's no guarantee they'll support it for very long. It's entirely possible that I'll incorporate this into my workflow, just for Google to kill it off a year later.

Should Google only work on things that it could guarantee to run for at least a few years no matter how it is performing?

Re: Google Saves

#36
post #35
post #3

The problem I have with Google tech, especially after the new Nest stuff has to come to light, is that there's no guarantee they'll support it for very long. It's entirely possible that I'll incorporate this into my workflow, just for Google to kill it off a year later.

Should Google only work on things that it could guarantee to run for at least a few years no matter how it is performing?

No. They're free to pull the plug on whatever. I will just make all future decisions knowing that this will probably happen. i.e. I won't rely on anything Google releases unless I know it makes them money.

Re: Google Saves

#37
post #3

The problem I have with Google tech, especially after the new Nest stuff has to come to light, is that there's no guarantee they'll support it for very long. It's entirely possible that I'll incorporate this into my workflow, just for Google to kill it off a year later.

Out of curiosity, but what's your gold standard for companies that sustain services over time? Or is your suspicion scoped to free services, of which Google has dropped a number of well-liked but non-revenue-generating services?

For their most popular products...I've found them to be pretty stable...little apps I've created using their Javascript mapping still function even though I knew so little about JS back then. I keep forgetting that I have a Google Voice number, and it still works fine even though it's been years since I've last used it on a regular basis.

Of course I think of Amazon being the most stable of platforms, but those are dev focused, with APIs that they've dogfooded too much to just drop. OTOH, they've cut a few public-facing conveniences, such as Send-to-Kindle integration from third parties (or, that's what I'm assuming, given the roundabout way that is now needed to import O'Reilly ebooks).

Re: Google Saves

#39
post #35
post #3

The problem I have with Google tech, especially after the new Nest stuff has to come to light, is that there's no guarantee they'll support it for very long. It's entirely possible that I'll incorporate this into my workflow, just for Google to kill it off a year later.

Should Google only work on things that it could guarantee to run for at least a few years no matter how it is performing?

Google can do what they like -- but at this point, without such a guarantee, their history shows that it would be unwise to take the time to integrate their side projects into one's life or workflow.
Post reply on HN