Live data from Hacker News

Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participating Companies

aboutads.info

51–60 of 81 posts

Re: Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participating Companies

#51
post #26

Is there any legitimate use for third-party cookies (which is all this seems to analyze)? I disabled third-party cookies years ago and I have never noticed any negative side effects at all.

I've had third-party cookies disabled for ~five years and noticed no problems.

Re: Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participating Companies

#52
Facebook just broke their site if you have Facebook's social media plugins blocked. Unclear if this is an anti-Ghostery measure or they just screwed up. Their code uses "require", which is not standard JavaScript, and whatever loads "require" needs a social media plugin.

Re: Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participating Companies

#53
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think it's that simple. I believe people do care if they're getting tracked, for what reason, and for the possible repercussions. We can compare the issues between a marketing on Facebook re-targeting you and the government recording your text messages. In one scenario, your preferences are exposed and used to present you with an advertisment to buy a good. In the other scenario, you can be analyzed for wheth…

Compare these scenarios: 1 a cop is passing by your house and sees you commit a murder. 2 government finds out from your phone's GPS data + public camera face recognition that you committed a murder 3 you admit to a murder on phone with an accomplice Why is one way of collecting evidence any better than the other. If you commit a crime, you should be convicted. Just because you are able to hide certain types of evide…

What makes scenario 2 egregious is how easy it would be to use that evidence to implicate someone for parking nearby the victim's house while the real killer took the bus. That kind of mass data collection lets you get really convenient answers from the data, and I don't trust the police to do the additional work of physically placing me at the scene if they can get a prosecutor to railroad me using my gps data.

Re: Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participating Companies

#54

People don't care. It is funny that smart people don't care about tech and ad companies violating their privacy by collecting data and profiting from it. But they have an issue with the government doing it to protect them. Perhaps has something to do with the fact that silicon valley's success is based on the advertising business model and violation of people's privacy.

Or perhaps it's because people don't trust that the government is interested in protecting them. If a private company uses the information it has on you maliciously at least you have some recourse - a competitor, or the justice system. When the powers in charge decide to use your data against you because they don't like your political stances, who is going to protect you?

But at the moment, it is just some laws that are protecting you from this malicious behavior by a non-benevolent government. If such a government comes to power, why would they follow this law.

The real solution should be to use encryption so that only you as a consumer holds the keys to your data. The reason the tech industry will never implement something like this is because it will kill their profit machines - not because it is not possible to implement this.

Re: Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participating Companies

#55
post #5

Gives me some confidence in uBlock & Privacy Badger... The first time I ran it there was 1 site tracking me (adbrain).. I adjusted my PB settings accordingly and got 0. It's a useful site for calibrating those tools! http://i.imgur.com/hdReODM.png

What's your reason for running both uBlock & Privacy Badger?

I'm curious about this as well; wouldn't an appropriate filter for uBlock Origin eliminate the need for Privacy Badger, except to detect new things to block?

Re: Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participating Companies

#57
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Be careful, some sites/services don't function correctly without that set.

Such as? It's been years since I allowed third party cookies and I've never noticed any issues.

Amazon Payments will not work with third party cookies turn off. PayPal actually works better than Amazon in that regards.

Re: Opt Out From Online Behavioral Advertising By Participating Companies

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Compare these scenarios: 1 a cop is passing by your house and sees you commit a murder. 2 government finds out from your phone's GPS data + public camera face recognition that you committed a murder 3 you admit to a murder on phone with an accomplice Why is one way of collecting evidence any better than the other. If you commit a crime, you should be convicted. Just because you are able to hide certain types of evide…

What makes scenario 2 egregious is how easy it would be to use that evidence to implicate someone for parking nearby the victim's house while the real killer took the bus. That kind of mass data collection lets you get really convenient answers from the data, and I don't trust the police to do the additional work of physically placing me at the scene if they can get a prosecutor to railroad me using my gps data.

How is that any different to the neighbor seeing you park your car in that street and not seeing the actual killer. Is there a difference in whether this evidence got collected by a person or a camera? What you do with this(and all other collected evidence) comes later. Eq - what if the government hires millions of police and place them on every intersection - that is acceptable, but having a camera on every intersection is not?
Post reply on HN