Live data from Hacker News

SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

wired.com

31–40 of 107 posts

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#31
post #29

While I like SoundCloud a lot, what the hell have they been up to for the last few years? From where I'm sitting Spotify, Apple Music and many more out-innovated them and SoundCloud did... well, nothing.

Just want to throw Google Play Music into the mix (pun intended!) as I have been using it exclusively for the past few months.

It is excellent and I cannot recommend it enough, and it is available in Canada (unlike SoundCloud Go).

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#32
post #15

I'm not sure I see what this is really offering customers. It seems like just another paywell for creators to put their content behind. While that's good for them, as a consumer I don't really have much motivation to sign up for another streaming service when I already pay for Spotify. If an artist is on Spotify, great, I'll listen to their songs a bunch and they'll make a little money off of me. If it's a group I ha…

Hey there - It's a huge catalog of tracks which contains all content from both emerging and established creators. The full details of which can be found on https://blog.soundcloud.com/

You mean https://blog.soundcloud.com/2016/03/29/introducing-soundclou...

I assume SoundCloud will at some point post other blog content and so in a matter of days/weeks this general link will not go to the right spot.

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#33
post #15

I'm not sure I see what this is really offering customers. It seems like just another paywell for creators to put their content behind. While that's good for them, as a consumer I don't really have much motivation to sign up for another streaming service when I already pay for Spotify. If an artist is on Spotify, great, I'll listen to their songs a bunch and they'll make a little money off of me. If it's a group I ha…

Hey there - It's a huge catalog of tracks which contains all content from both emerging and established creators. The full details of which can be found on https://blog.soundcloud.com/

I read the article - the pros seems to be:

- Ad free music - Listen offline - More tracks from established creators

The first two are a given with any streaming service. My point was their catalog isn't enough to make me switch over.

As an artist, unless you're getting some kind of crazy deal to just be on one of the services, your best bet is to be on every one out there.

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#34

How much Spotify cost in the states? As a Swede it costs 99kr which is more than $9. I use Groove and that costs $9 which translates to about 79kr or something like that. It's 20% cheaper for a little less content and a not as good client. The lesser price alone makes the service worth it.

So, we're talking 20% cheaper for less content and worse client?

How does that make the service "worth it"?

It sounds like subpar crap in every way but price, and even at that it's nothing to write home about either (a measly $2.5 savings).

If one can afford $9/month, I don't see how $11.5 month are prohibiting for a better experience and more content.

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#35
This would explain why they have removed the local cache option in their Android app.

In previous versions, you could select how much content to cache locally on the device, up to 100%. This meant if you listened to a song once, you could listen to it again offline.

From using their app now, and the website (non-mobile) it seems they have removed all caching completely.

Anyway, it's absolutely trivial to download the raw songs (MP3) from SoundCloud using Developer Tools in your favourite browser. It's not the highest quality, but since SoundCloud is 90% user contributed tracks, the original quality is often questionable anyway.

I see no added value from this service. Just download the songs as MP3 files and listen to them, offline and ad free!

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#36
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey there - It's a huge catalog of tracks which contains all content from both emerging and established creators. The full details of which can be found on https://blog.soundcloud.com/

I read the article - the pros seems to be: - Ad free music - Listen offline - More tracks from established creators The first two are a given with any streaming service. My point was their catalog isn't enough to make me switch over. As an artist, unless you're getting some kind of crazy deal to just be on one of the services, your best bet is to be on every one out there.

Where in the article does it say you have be exclusively on this platform? The word is exclusive is mentioned twice and both times in relation to Tidal.

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#37
post #29

While I like SoundCloud a lot, what the hell have they been up to for the last few years? From where I'm sitting Spotify, Apple Music and many more out-innovated them and SoundCloud did... well, nothing.

I think that's a fair perspective. With all these deals shaking out as a customer I'm quite happy with Amazon Prime Music for streaming/mainstream and then purchasing tracks or the occasional album via Beatport/CDs/etc. So now SoundCloud wants creators to pay for a Pro account and listeners to pay for a Go account...hmmm...well it does sound like they are genuinely trying to get revenue up. We'll see if this works.

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#38
post #12

"If you’re an iOS user, it’ll cost more, with the company charging $12.99 for signups to account for Apple’s mandatory 30 percent cut." I'd be a little surprised if Apple will allow them to do this. It's kind of like credit card companies requiring stores to charge the same price regardless of if you use the credit card (which has fees) instead of cash (which doesn't). Charging different prices is a negative signal f…

Spotify have the exact same pricing model/discrepancy http://thenextweb.com/insider/2015/07/08/spotify-is-actively...

Huh. I guess since I signed up for it through their website so it was always $10/month for me, so I didn't notice.

But see, I was an iOS user paying $10/month for Spotify (because I paid on the web). Does Soundcloud offer this, or is it truly every iOS user has to pay through Apple for their subscription to Soundcloud Go, and thus have no choice but to pay more? It seems like it's the latter by the wording of their copy.

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#39
post #24

The actual offering left aside, the naming is quite unfortunate.

>> "The actual offering left aside, the naming is quite unfortunate." It seems good to me. One of the major features is offline listening to you can now listen 'on the go'. Am I missing something?

HBO Go Go (golang) Go (game)

Re: SoundCloud launches Go: a subscription service

#40

why doesn't any music service come up with a less expensive price plan? I would like to try one, but am pretty sure I would not use it so much as to justify paying 10$ (or £) per month. How about a less expensive plan with limited features (e.g. only n hours of music per month)?

$10/month is extremely affordable if you enjoy music.
Post reply on HN