Live data from Hacker News

Virtual Reality is a Fad

pigsdontfly.com

1–6 of 6 posts

Re: Virtual Reality is a Fad

#2
tl;dr This headline is clickbait. Early in the article, the author admits that VR is not a fad:

> No doubt, VR will have many uses. It's fairly disruptive

The article is really arguing that this particular generation of VR hardware is a fad, not that VR itself won't become mainstream.

Re: Virtual Reality is a Fad

#4
post #2

tl;dr This headline is clickbait. Early in the article, the author admits that VR is not a fad: > No doubt, VR will have many uses. It's fairly disruptive The article is really arguing that this particular generation of VR hardware is a fad, not that VR itself won't become mainstream.

The article can be read both ways (also saying that VR is a fad long term).

The fact that it admits that VR is "disruptive" and has "many uses" doesn't mean it's not a fad when it comes to the general population. Something that's trully useful in a lab or educational setting can still be a useless fad gadget people have bought for personal use.

Re: Virtual Reality is a Fad

#5
post #4
post #2

tl;dr This headline is clickbait. Early in the article, the author admits that VR is not a fad: > No doubt, VR will have many uses. It's fairly disruptive The article is really arguing that this particular generation of VR hardware is a fad, not that VR itself won't become mainstream.

The article can be read both ways (also saying that VR is a fad long term). The fact that it admits that VR is "disruptive" and has "many uses" doesn't mean it's not a fad when it comes to the general population. Something that's trully useful in a lab or educational setting can still be a useless fad gadget people have bought for personal use.

That's still an assessment of VR as it currently exists in current products. It's ludicrous to argue that VR as a whole (immersing someone in a believable, manufactured reality) is a fad. IMAX movies, video games, Second Life, and even role-playing are poor versions of VR that demonstrate that humans are striving toward it.

Re: Virtual Reality is a Fad

#6
post #5
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article can be read both ways (also saying that VR is a fad long term). The fact that it admits that VR is "disruptive" and has "many uses" doesn't mean it's not a fad when it comes to the general population. Something that's trully useful in a lab or educational setting can still be a useless fad gadget people have bought for personal use.

That's still an assessment of VR as it currently exists in current products. It's ludicrous to argue that VR as a whole (immersing someone in a believable, manufactured reality) is a fad. IMAX movies, video games, Second Life, and even role-playing are poor versions of VR that demonstrate that humans are striving toward it.

Are humans really taking to IMAX movies or Second Life -- or even Role Playing these days? I'd call those fads too.