Live data from Hacker News

Learning from Tay’s introduction

blogs.microsoft.com

11–20 of 204 posts

Re: Learning from Tay’s introduction

#11
If you're not asking yourself "what could a small but well-coordinated group of bad actors accomplish with our online tool" you're just being negligent.

This 'but we did it in China' rationalization is so flimsy. What happened with Tay was easily predictable given the nature of Twitter.

Re: Learning from Tay’s introduction

#12

Anyone see this in action? What sort of vulnerability was being exploited? What types of things was the chatbot saying?

Not sure of a "vulnerability", would like to hear more about that. Unless the "repeat after me" feature is a vulnerability or it learns to copy too much from input?

Here's a small sample: http://imgur.com/gallery/VhlAW

Re: Learning from Tay’s introduction

#13
This reads like science fiction:

Learning from Somebot's introduction.

Last week we deployed Somebot to $location. Our confidence in Somebot was high because we had thought about all likely scenarios in our comfortable offices. We are deeply sorry and assume the full responsibility from Somebot's actions. Moving forward we will make sure to include safeguards to reduce the amount of pain caused by Somebot's deployment.

Our deepest condolences to the families of the affected and to the survivors. Megacorp cares about your well being. To help cover expenses from the tragedy we will deposit $money in your Megacorp account.

God bless the federated nations of Megacorp.

Re: Learning from Tay’s introduction

#14

Anyone see this in action? What sort of vulnerability was being exploited? What types of things was the chatbot saying?

The bot learned from interacting with users. A bunch of people took to bombarding Tay with racist/sexist/antisemitic remarks which worked their way into its vocabulary. I'm not sure if you could really call it a vulnerability as this is pretty much what the bot was designed to do. It's more of a flaw in the inability to properly filter the content that works its way into the AI.

Re: Learning from Tay’s introduction

#15

Anyone see this in action? What sort of vulnerability was being exploited? What types of things was the chatbot saying?

The specific one they're describing is, I think, a feature that would have Tay echo anything you sent it. That one was somewhat more "annoying embarrassment" than "coordinated attack." The bigger problem was that Tay began spontaneously tweeting ugly statements, a problem that can be summed up as "When Twitter is your learning corpus, you are at risk of your learning corpus being made up of tweets."

Re: Learning from Tay’s introduction

#17

Anyone see this in action? What sort of vulnerability was being exploited? What types of things was the chatbot saying?

https://www.reddit.com/r/tay_tweets has lots of examples, most of them 4chan-level.

These few are completely different and certainly interesting: https://i.imgur.com/iVof3D4.jpg https://i.imgur.com/YwlfwyL.png https://i.imgur.com/IlpFUiZ.png (though it's hard to confirm they're legit, as Retr0spectrum points out).

Re: Learning from Tay’s introduction

#18
This is an apology, but Microsoft got a ton of attention in the past few days from the press. Could the Tay incident be a marketing ploy (that took a worse turn than expected) to bring the public's attention to Microsoft's work on AI?

Re: Learning from Tay’s introduction

#19

Anyone see this in action? What sort of vulnerability was being exploited? What types of things was the chatbot saying?

I think the vulnerability was msft underestimating the extent of effort 4chan users would put into trolling Tay.

By the end of the day, Tay could 4chan with the worst of them.

Post reply on HN