Live data from Hacker News

Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide

nytimes.com

111–120 of 150 posts

Re: Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide

#111

Although these pranks are funny they highlight a something very serious - the failure case of direct democracy. When minor issues come up for vote not everyone cares. The people who do care enough to vote can easily be trolls. As an example, imagine that a vote comes up for raising tolls from $1 to $2 on little used street. It's one of 1000 votes a month in a direct democracy. There's little chance of getting attenti…

Another problem with direct democracy is consistency. In one vote the people will overwhelmingly support a constitutionally mandated limit on taxation. Then in the next vote they will overwhelmingly vote in mandatory ring fenced high spending on health care, education, etc, etc with automatic inflation-busting increases every year.

This is why you need a government with the power to govern, because someone has to be able to make the trade offs between different and changing demands and priorities that one-off, single-issue referenda can't make.

Re: Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide

#113

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm from Gothenburg, Sweden, which is a city known for its bad puns and where most larger buildings are usually referred to by silly nicknames. Last year, there was a competition to name the new swimming pool by the harbor which they put there to keep people from swimming in the rather filthy water of the nearby river. As expected, most of the names which received a lot of votes were silly puns and, you know what? Th…

I'm from Stockholm and would like to denounce that Gothenburg is known for its bad puns. Gothenburg is only known as a fisherman village.

I thought it was also known for melodeath metal?

Re: Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide

#114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There were actually some hilarious suggestions on Reddit (not sure if they're all actual submissions) like Usain Boat, Ice Ice Baby, Boatimus Prime, Notitanic, Boats by Dre or Pier Pressure.

My old university town of Aberystwyth has a club called Pier Pressure which, rather pleasingly, is on a pier.

[deleted]

Re: Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide

#116
post #49

Truly the wisdom of crowds. I am reminded once again of the perils of direct democracy.

Ah now that's an excellent topic, because the root of the problem is the participants don't think wisdom is the correct source for boat names. Some may not like it, but its still their culture.

Re: Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide

#117
post #50

I love this kind of british humour, however crude. In my mind, it's similar to the campaigns (most years?) to have a non-christmas song be the #1 christmas single.

There's nothing particular English about "Boaty McBoatface" to my mind, it's just standard internet humor.

Re: Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide

#118

Back in the 90's, People magazine ran an internet competition for the most beautiful person alive. Hank the Angry Drunken Dwarf won by a mile.

That is the first thing that came to my mind as well. Must have been the first popular internet voting campaign to go wrong.

And for those that do not know the story, Hank the Angry Drunken Dwarf (RIP) was very much a real person.

Re: Boaty McBoatface: What You Get When You Let the Internet Decide

#119

They should run with it, the positive PR now and in the future when the RSS Boaty McBoatface docks would be worth it. It would also show a sense of humour and make it something fun.

They got off easy. At least the top entry wasn't SS Hitler Did Nothing Wrong.
Post reply on HN