Live data from Hacker News

New Photoshop UI has become a major problem on the official feedback forum

feedback.photoshop.com

61–63 of 63 posts

Re: New Photoshop UI has become a major problem on the official feedback forum

#61
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It took roughly 40 years for cars to work out what equipment would be standard and where it would go. I'm reading Robert J. Gordon's The Rise and Fall of American Growth , which looks at trends and patterns over the period since the Civil War (1870), most especially what he terms "the special century" (1870-1970), and also examined as three periods, 1870 - 1920, 1920 - 1970, and 1970 - present (almost even 50 year in…

I think they finished working out most the standard inclusions like that about a decade ago, at this point people get mad over their placement. I would consider the following an incomplete short list of essentials that all (desktop) operating systems offer: - File storage and manipulation - File search - Networking - Application installation, management and (local) discovery - Application running and managing multipl…

There's far more that was finalised nearly 50 years ago, with the Mother of All Demos, than anyone today cares to admit.

Computers are problematic in large part because of the tremendous range of environments and uses:

1. Domain experts with decades of experience and highly-tuned, fixed-location, immersed interfaces. Old-school workstations. Heavy on CLI or usually really idiosyncratic GUIs.

2. More casual office users. This is your general file/task approach. I still think that could be improved, though the question is how. Having to consciously consider applications is IMO an error.

3. Mobile. Suboptimal conditions for viewing, entering, reading, etc. Some of the audio input (Amazon Echo, Google Now, Apple Siri) systems may address parts of this.

4. Appliances / controls: anything from digital clocks to DVD/BluRay players to microwaves and kitchen stoves and thermostats and washing machines. LED / LCD displays, anything from 2+ buttons to numeric keypads to dials to full keyboards. Incredible inconsistency across and even _within_ applications.

Of three sets of digital kitchen timers:

One blinks the minutes:seconds colon to indicate it is counting down, the other to indicate it isn't.

A microwave control allows use of either the timer or the microwave, but not both simultaneously.

Several chime repeatedly, others only once (and woe be you if you happen to miss the timer).

None have a count-up feature telling you _when the timer went off_.

I prefer a wind-up dial timer. Simple interface, and it's obvious when and how it's working. The bell is loud enough to hear rooms away.

Re: New Photoshop UI has become a major problem on the official feedback forum

#62
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think they finished working out most the standard inclusions like that about a decade ago, at this point people get mad over their placement. I would consider the following an incomplete short list of essentials that all (desktop) operating systems offer: - File storage and manipulation - File search - Networking - Application installation, management and (local) discovery - Application running and managing multipl…

There's far more that was finalised nearly 50 years ago, with the Mother of All Demos, than anyone today cares to admit. Computers are problematic in large part because of the tremendous range of environments and uses: 1. Domain experts with decades of experience and highly-tuned, fixed-location, immersed interfaces. Old-school workstations. Heavy on CLI or usually really idiosyncratic GUIs. 2. More casual office use…

I won't argue that all interfaces to digital devices have reached a good set of intuitive interfaces, it's clear they haven't. If we're just talking about desktop computers though, I think we're much closer. That said, of the first three groups you mentioned, I think there's relative examples in our analogy group. Workstations (in the professional sense) are like the semi-specialized vehicles that people use. Rock crawlers, off-road vehicles, etc. Mobile is like motorcycles. Each provides the same essential service, but the amenities, configuration and details wildly differ.

Re: New Photoshop UI has become a major problem on the official feedback forum

#63
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's far more that was finalised nearly 50 years ago, with the Mother of All Demos, than anyone today cares to admit. Computers are problematic in large part because of the tremendous range of environments and uses: 1. Domain experts with decades of experience and highly-tuned, fixed-location, immersed interfaces. Old-school workstations. Heavy on CLI or usually really idiosyncratic GUIs. 2. More casual office use…

I won't argue that all interfaces to digital devices have reached a good set of intuitive interfaces, it's clear they haven't. If we're just talking about desktop computers though, I think we're much closer. That said, of the first three groups you mentioned, I think there's relative examples in our analogy group. Workstations (in the professional sense) are like the semi-specialized vehicles that people use. Rock cr…

I've got to think about this. Not sure I agree or don't, but some good ideas.
Post reply on HN