Live data from Hacker News

I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

news.ycombinator.com

581–590 of 768 posts

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#581
post #570
post #568

Hey Sam: So I've been working diligently for the last few weeks putting the final edits on my application to YC. I'm 68 years old an the only founder. On the positive side I've got almost 50 years of work in the project that defines the state of the art. Am I wasting my time in applying considering my age and singleness?

Holy wow! I'm not Sam but kudos, keep at it no matter what. Inspired right now.

Thanks! That's a very nice thing to say.

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#582
As YC's portfolio of established companies gets bigger (and more valuable), do you think YC's focus will eventually shift from "facilitating innovation" to simply "maintaining the status quo" (particularly if the latter becomes more lucrative)?

What measures do you have in place to make sure that YC's financial interests remain geared towards innovation?

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#584
post #120

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tech needs to run a candidate in the next election. I still am hopeful Trump will not win the general.

Thanks, Sam! I'm hopeful too, but prediction markets still, distressingly, give Trump a 20% chance of winning it all. I'm sure there are a lot of people in CA who have skills that are in short supply (familiarity with stats, social networks, programming, etc. -- think Nate Silver), and who would want to volunteer on a part-time basis. It's not clear at the moment how they could put these skills to good use, other tha…

Some things are more important than political positioning. Even an incorrect belief that leaders are corrupt will influence culture, making corruption more acceptable to society. Laws can be changed back and forth, and walls can be torn down, but corruption is mighty hard to fix once it has solidly taken root in society.

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#585

I'm working on a piece about universal basic income, and I have the following summary of the how I think that many tech people like yourself believe UBI is going to work: 1. Companies innovate by doing things more cheaply with automation than human workers can do them. 2. As a result of automation, the more efficient companies reap all the profits in a market as they drive the less efficient companies out of business…

> This bonanza of profits that automation yields is taxed. Optimizing companies will do everything possible to avoid the corporate taxes (>60%) required to make universal basic income a reality. If you are assuming that winning companies are the best at implementing automation and reducing cost, it is a fatal mistake to assume that they will suddenly become charitable when it comes to wealth redistribution - no, they…

It is a job of the government to counteract destabilizing influences such as the wealth concentrating effects of technology and under-competition. As a foreigner living in the US, the US government honestly sucks eggs at it. Healthcare, banks, cable, broadband, cell phone service, Google, Apple, Microsoft... all classic antitrust cases across the board, waiting for an un-captured regulator.

If world governments continue to fail also at corporate tax, the current dystopic situation of regressive effective corporate tax rates through profit export will persist, and risks everything we have gained through capitalism and democracy.

I encourage you to read the definition of UBI. Universal means you give to everyone, from the homeless guy on the street, to Bill Gates. Not just laid off people. Also, your top-of-head speculations are not the best evidence available for its effects.

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#586

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The concept of ideas being worth near to nothing is new to me, can you explain that thinking? Without monetary arguments this seems not right.

If ideas worth something, then an idea would be a commodity being traded among people in markets. Since there isn't a market where people trade ideas with something else, like money, there simply isn't a market for ideas. Hence, ideas are worth nothing.

Eh... no.

Most markets are for items there are many of. There are lots of apples, people see friends enjoying them, people buy one, like it, buy another, a price is established. Key facts: you get to buy it more than once, more than one person gets to buy it, you can tell in advance it is worth something. Take too many of those away, and the market goes away.

An idea (for a venture) is: unique (a close variant missing a key part has completely different value), you would not pay for it twice, and selling it to multiple people diminishes its value. Why would you think the value of an idea would be well captured in a market?

You do realize a market is just one mechanism for expressing value, right? or is air value-less?

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#587

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If ideas worth something, then an idea would be a commodity being traded among people in markets. Since there isn't a market where people trade ideas with something else, like money, there simply isn't a market for ideas. Hence, ideas are worth nothing.

I don't buy this; I think starting off in the right market is a huge determinant of success. The reason there's no market is because it takes an idea and a person who can execute -- knowledge, skills, connections, experience, etc. Ideas aren't separable from people in a way that would make a market possible.

Inventions are worth money, ideas are not.

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#588
post #463

Last March, you mentioned on twitter that you are a customer of/financially support Shanley Kane's organization, Model View Culture. Since since then (and before then too), she has made a variety of racially and sexually charged statements, such as, "fire some fuckin white guys to get it done" ( https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:KtAdEv... ). Do you or Y-Combinator still patronize or support Model…

I'd love to hear what you find so objectionable about the tweets to linked to. It seems radical but not offensive.

She wants mass firings of people like me and you for no other reason than our sex and the color of our skin.

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#589
post #351

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly, we are so busy, there are so many companies, and ideas are worth so little, that most of us don't think twice about a specific company once we move on to the next applications. The very best ideas usually don't seem worth stealing.

Sam, this conception of an "idea" is in astoundingly strong conflict with the conceptions of ideas elsewhere in business and national security that are commonly strongly and seriously protected as classified national security secrets (e.g., how stealth works, how the engines on the SR-71 worked, the details of the Navy's version of GPS), intellectual property, trade secrets, patents, how academic honors are awarded,…

You are actually citing examples of execution excellence and IP, rather than "ideas" as the word is used in early stage VC circles. For example the idea of making a low radar cross section aircraft is not new or valuable since right after radar was first developed. However executing on that idea to create the stealth fighter design produces something very valuable.

Re: I Am Sam Altman, President of Y Combinator. AMA

#590
post #393

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey DK, Just another entrepreneur here, but I'm a Canadian citizen and also need a VISA. I've received excellent help from Julie Pearl's firm: https://www.immigrationlaw.com/ They work with plenty of startup founders and I was recommended her through fellow immigrant founders. :) Hope this helps!

As a Canadian, I'd suspect entering the US under a TN visa (Free trade agreement if you have an applicable university degree or 10 years experience) would probably do it. Anybody have experience with that when attending YC?

For TN you need a job offer. Specifically, when you try to enter the US on the TN status (it's not a visa technically), you'll be asked to show an offer letter from a US company that clearly states your intended role and salary.
Post reply on HN