Live data from Hacker News

A cheating scandal in the world of professional bridge

newyorker.com

71–72 of 72 posts

Re: A cheating scandal in the world of professional bridge

#71
post #13

I enjoy bridge, but high level competitive bridge sounds like a nightmare. "Expert poker players often take advantage of a skill they call table feel: an ability to read the facial expressions and other unconscious “tells” exhibited by their opponents. Bridge players rely on table feel, too, but in bridge not all tells can be exploited legally by all players. If one of my opponents hesitates during the bidding or the…

You can't. It's a game that is fundamentally flawed at the base level, just like blackjack. The fact that both these games outlaw certain thought processes , be that counting cards in your head or acting on your partner's hesitation, shows that they've been shoehorned into something they're not.

If you don't want people counting cards, shuffle between plays. It is in no way a problem any game is faced with.

The weird thing about card counting is that casinos want the people who are bad at counting cards. So it is not a flaw in the game, but just a weird rule that in the casino world you are not allowed to win.

Re: A cheating scandal in the world of professional bridge

#72
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems very arbitrary. There's a very similar card game in Spain called Truco (and in Italy called Briscola). Truco accepts communication and even bluffing as a core component. There are very standard system for hidden communication, like a wink representating a particular strong card and pursing the lips means another. Because these are so well known, its common to either wait for the right moment to share info, or i…

In a similar way, another Italian card game, "tressette", has a set of formalized signals which you are forced to use (and are limited to) when opening a round, without lying - "i have other cards of this type", "this is my last card of this type" and "I want your strongest card" (I know them as striscio/volo/busso, but they change regionally). So you have a situation where card and signal technically mean one thing…

Something that leads to fights and loud arguments sounds like a pretty unsavory vice...
Post reply on HN