Live data from Hacker News

Mysterious Martian “Cauliflower” May Be the Latest Hint of Alien Life

smithsonianmag.com

11–20 of 84 posts

Re: Mysterious Martian “Cauliflower” May Be the Latest Hint of Alien Life

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From what I recall, she keeps on going on about the beauty of the empty landscape, and the possibility of martian life is mentioned less often.

Who is she?

Probably Ann Clayborne - the original Red:

http://www.kimstanleyrobinson.info/d/content/ann-clayborne-2

Re: Mysterious Martian “Cauliflower” May Be the Latest Hint of Alien Life

#12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A variant on this features prominently (through one of the main characters/factions) in Kim Stanley Robinson's excellent Red Mars trilogy.

From what I recall, she keeps on going on about the beauty of the empty landscape, and the possibility of martian life is mentioned less often.

Kim Stanley Robinson is male.

Re: Mysterious Martian “Cauliflower” May Be the Latest Hint of Alien Life

#15

Sci-fi scenario: We find evidence of microbial life from billions of years ago, when Mars was briefly a warm, wet place. Decades hence, a researcher realizes that Mars still has microbial life, but that it has evolved as its environment has, so it's as arid and rarefied as its present atmosphere, wispy and almost not there. Sadly, she realizes that human activity has already doomed it to extinction.

Similar idea, but the Martian Chronicles by Ray Bradbury touched on this heavily. Although it was humans and humanoid martians instead of microbial life.

Re: Mysterious Martian “Cauliflower” May Be the Latest Hint of Alien Life

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A variant on this features prominently (through one of the main characters/factions) in Kim Stanley Robinson's excellent Red Mars trilogy.

From what I recall, she keeps on going on about the beauty of the empty landscape, and the possibility of martian life is mentioned less often.

The reason why the beauty is more prominent is political in my opinion: The people on Mars can relate to and see the changing environment in the later books. The possibility of Martian life is a mere academic motive.

Also some characters begin to spread earth life already in the first book. So if they would find Martian life after this event it could be just mutated Earth life...

Re: Mysterious Martian “Cauliflower” May Be the Latest Hint of Alien Life

#17

Sci-fi scenario: We find evidence of microbial life from billions of years ago, when Mars was briefly a warm, wet place. Decades hence, a researcher realizes that Mars still has microbial life, but that it has evolved as its environment has, so it's as arid and rarefied as its present atmosphere, wispy and almost not there. Sadly, she realizes that human activity has already doomed it to extinction.

A variant on this features prominently (through one of the main characters/factions) in Kim Stanley Robinson's excellent Red Mars trilogy.

Caution: I found the Red Mars trilogy excruciatingly boring. YMMV.

Re: Mysterious Martian “Cauliflower” May Be the Latest Hint of Alien Life

#18
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A variant on this features prominently (through one of the main characters/factions) in Kim Stanley Robinson's excellent Red Mars trilogy.

Caution: I found the Red Mars trilogy excruciatingly boring. YMMV.

I'm glad it wasn't just me. That book had the largest gap between how much everyone else hyped it and how much I hated it that I've ever encountered. I think the main problem for me was that it introduced so many characters and it rarely (if ever) returned to them in later chapters, that I just didn't care about any single character at all. And that makes reading about them so tedious.

Re: Mysterious Martian “Cauliflower” May Be the Latest Hint of Alien Life

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a quite likely scenario since collective human activity has so far spelled doom to most species other than humans and our parasites, commensals and domesticated species. If we are serious about researching or preserving alien life in our solar system, we would have to be very cautious with what we do. But most likely, economic forces will start to dominate our actions in space, as they have always done on Ear…

> But most likely, economic forces will start to dominate our actions in space, as they have always done on Earth. Perhaps most advanced intelligence comes in the form of distributed hive minds, and something like a "civilization" is regarded by most sentients as something akin to a pack of wolves or an uncontrolled mob? Maybe we're the ultimate ethical dilemma: All of the bad qualities of a cancer, but you can't eth…

How could aliens have the ability to destroy us if they didn't have their own technological civilization?

Manufacturing spacecraft capable of traveling between the stars in any reasonable amount of time, if possible at all, would be an immense industrial undertaking, the pinnacle of not just scientific knowledge but societal complexity in order to coordinate the resources involved. Any alien race capable of doing these things must have also committed the sins that they're smugly damning us for, and to a far greater degree than we have.

Post reply on HN