Live data from Hacker News

WordPress Sites Now Support Google’s AMP to Make Mobile Pages Load Faster

techcrunch.com

51–52 of 52 posts

Re: WordPress Sites Now Support Google’s AMP to Make Mobile Pages Load Faster

#51
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see what makes it different from any other open source project. Of course it's going to have technical leads and core committers, it's not like you can go force a PR merge on jQuery trunk any time you please. I'm aghast that you would even suggest such a thing. And CLA's aren't fun, but they're hardly new, either.[1] If you don't like that it's Google, that's fine, but at least be honest with yourself about i…

To me the problematic part that makes it different to at least some open source projects is that all those technical leads and core committers are apparently employed by Google (and working on company time, I assume). That could mean Google, and Google alone, gets to decide where it goes.

Honestly, the only criticism I'm hearing over and over is "because Google", and considering their track record with Chrome, Android, Angular, Polymer, Go, and literally hundreds of other open-source projects, I'm perfectly okay with that.

Re: WordPress Sites Now Support Google’s AMP to Make Mobile Pages Load Faster

#52
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

AMP erects walls around the Open Web and enshrines Google as the gatekeeper. Want to embed content from another site? Great! You can choose from , , , , or . Building an advertising startup? Hooray! I hope you're one of the dozen whitelisted ad networks that allows. In Russia or China? Maybe Google will deign to implement and if we're sufficiently humble. This is not the Web I want.

The project is open source and open to contributions from anyone. Every single time this comes up the project contributors have said that they will gladly modify to support any network they can. They're also constantly developing new components to fill in the gaps for other embeddable services. You want ? Submit a PR! Open an issue! It's open source! And please, please tell me what's wrong with using e.g. ? It's just…

> you can just submit a PR.

And wait for google to accept it at their own discretion. That's exactly what a gatekeeper is.

Post reply on HN