Live data from Hacker News

Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

jpost.com

11–20 of 139 posts

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#11
post #10

what confuses me about the US-Israeli relationship is that the most of the times they work well but at times one is always sabatoging each other in a manner that makes you reconsider, is Israel and enemy or a friend to the United States? I don't think Japan would pull off shit like this. It's like there's a four tier system to what defines a US Ally. Platinum - Gets you exclusive access to black funds & latest weapon…

America has interests and not friends. Israelis understand this. Similarly Israel has interests and not friends. They are interested in protecting their own interests. Even if it costs Americans for them to do so. So you can basically say Israelis learned how to play these games from Americans.

> So you can basically say Israelis learned how to play these games from Americans.

I think you can probably trace such realpolitik and statecraft back to Mesopotamia and beyond.

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#12
post #2

Stuxnet was such an amazing event. The speculation at first, the quasi confirmation a little later based on certain items in the code. The dissection of it and the tech talks by Microsoft and others on its design and build... And then that it had a successor - and now it comes out that Israel and US squabbling over what team did what which allowed it to be exposed. It is such an amazing cornerstone in the cyberpunk r…

>If you haven't watched the tech talks on stuxnet and duqu, please do - super interesting.

If you or someone else has some recommendations on which ones are worth watching, please do let us know.

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#13
Hate to turn this into a political thread when there is so much info about software but....

The sheer arrogance with with Israel operates is just something else. They seem to to believe that no action they take will ever be questioned or lead to any blowback.

The almost total control of US Foreign policy that they have now makes me think that the Iran deal being operationalized was nothing sort of a coup for Pres. Obama.

If I were a conspiracy nut, I would be looking very closely at how those two US naval boats drifted that close to an Iranian base on the eve of the agreement coming into force.

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#14

Hate to turn this into a political thread when there is so much info about software but.... The sheer arrogance with with Israel operates is just something else. They seem to to believe that no action they take will ever be questioned or lead to any blowback. The almost total control of US Foreign policy that they have now makes me think that the Iran deal being operationalized was nothing sort of a coup for Pres. Ob…

The sheer arrogance with with $country operates is just something else.

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#15
post #2

Stuxnet was such an amazing event. The speculation at first, the quasi confirmation a little later based on certain items in the code. The dissection of it and the tech talks by Microsoft and others on its design and build... And then that it had a successor - and now it comes out that Israel and US squabbling over what team did what which allowed it to be exposed. It is such an amazing cornerstone in the cyberpunk r…

I read this: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/18465875-countdown-to-ze... but haven't watched anything related to Stuxnet. Do you have any specific talks to recommend?

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#16
post #12
post #2

Stuxnet was such an amazing event. The speculation at first, the quasi confirmation a little later based on certain items in the code. The dissection of it and the tech talks by Microsoft and others on its design and build... And then that it had a successor - and now it comes out that Israel and US squabbling over what team did what which allowed it to be exposed. It is such an amazing cornerstone in the cyberpunk r…

> If you haven't watched the tech talks on stuxnet and duqu, please do - super interesting. If you or someone else has some recommendations on which ones are worth watching, please do let us know.

Updated with some linkage

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#17
post #15
post #2

Stuxnet was such an amazing event. The speculation at first, the quasi confirmation a little later based on certain items in the code. The dissection of it and the tech talks by Microsoft and others on its design and build... And then that it had a successor - and now it comes out that Israel and US squabbling over what team did what which allowed it to be exposed. It is such an amazing cornerstone in the cyberpunk r…

I read this: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/18465875-countdown-to-ze... but haven't watched anything related to Stuxnet. Do you have any specific talks to recommend?

Updated

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#18
post #8

what confuses me about the US-Israeli relationship is that the most of the times they work well but at times one is always sabatoging each other in a manner that makes you reconsider, is Israel and enemy or a friend to the United States? I don't think Japan would pull off shit like this. It's like there's a four tier system to what defines a US Ally. Platinum - Gets you exclusive access to black funds & latest weapon…

And the crazy thing is the other country doesn't even have to behave well or keep up its end of the bargain to maintain top-level status.

Alliances are about geopolitics as much as how much we like countries' behaviour. Israel is an invaluable intelligence partner in the War on Terror and a natural ally against Iran. They're also the closest thing to a liberal democracy in the Middle East.

As long as the US continues to gain more from its alliance with Israel than it loses, the alliance will endure. No matter how much individual leaders may loathe each other.

Re: Unilateral Israeli changes to Stuxnet caused its exposure, angering US

#20
post #11
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

America has interests and not friends. Israelis understand this. Similarly Israel has interests and not friends. They are interested in protecting their own interests. Even if it costs Americans for them to do so. So you can basically say Israelis learned how to play these games from Americans.

> So you can basically say Israelis learned how to play these games from Americans. I think you can probably trace such realpolitik and statecraft back to Mesopotamia and beyond.

You can certainly trace it to Prussia/Germany and Bismarck. The "no permanent friends, only permanent interests" line people usually attribute to Kissinger originally came from Lord Palmerston in the 1800s.
Post reply on HN