Live data from Hacker News

Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

bloomberg.com

31–40 of 237 posts

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#31

Finally he gets caught out for saying stupid shit. Every thing this man says is self serving (which is fine) but he tries to disguise it as profound knowledge. Ben Evans is 10x worse however, he is one idiotic twat.

One of Evans' favourite debate tactics is to tweet something brimming with subtext, then when someone calls him out on it, takes a literal approach to what he said. It's infuriating.

You summed up exactly what I thought it in my head about his Tweets, he is positively juvenile.

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#32

Extremely stupid tweet by Andreessen. He probably doesn't even realize that, like most ignorant people. FYI it was socialism that held back the Indian economy during the 70s and 80s. And it was colonialism that drained the country's wealth for over two hundred years. Here, Mr. Andreessen, educate yourself: https://www.google.com/search?q=bengal+famine

He probably meant "Anti-West" attitudes, not anti-colonialism. Coming from a third world country myself, I know there is a tendency to deny and dismiss some socially disruptive innovations because of their origin. There is a cultural trust issue there.

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#33
post #14

I don't particularly like the guy, but is there a campaign of deliberate misinterpretation going on? Yes, probably a really stupid thing to say, and perhaps wrong for many reasons. No, he did not say India should have kept Britain as its colonial power, or any of the other incredible interpretations now flying around the Twittersphere. Jonny Axelsson: Anti-semitism not the opposite of semitism. Now whether anti-colon…

This exactly. What's going on here is the internet hate machine has found a new target, and is eager to assign the least generous possible interpretation so they can feel good about themselves, look nice and self-righteous to their friends, get up votes, and so on. If you want to attack a man, maybe it's best to figure out what he was trying to say first.

Some of the comments even in this thread are disgusting, and they are getting plenty of upvotes; and I find it curious how a community that usually decries this sort of thing becomes so quick to engage in it.

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#34

    > Anti-colonialism has been economically catastrophic
    > for the Indian people for decades. Why stop now?
I assumed anti-colonialism meant the license raj, protectionism, central planning, import substitution, and other illiberal policies brought in in 1947, that were sold at the time as being anti-colonial.

Can someone tell me what it actually means, or is the suggestion that these policies weren't economic suicide?

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#35

Andreessen is such a drama queen. I said something clever and a little critical to him on twitter once and he blocked my ass. He runs his mouth off and says stupid shit all the time.

The tone of your comment comes off as drama. When it doesn't include the details of the tweet, people are left guessing. If no mention of the other things you find questionable are explained, then it's just flaming. This isn't to defend him, but to suggest this style doesn't help solve the problem of sloppy social media commentary.

Marc Andreessen has a well-documented record of blocking people liberally for very little reason:

https://medium.com/@aminatou/to-marc-andressen-6d09239f0065

https://twitter.com/triketora/status/677597576183480320

http://money.cnn.com/2015/12/23/technology/marc-andreessen-b...

https://blogdotitrendcorporationdotcom.wordpress.com/2014/05...

And, confusingly enough, doesn't really respect other people's blocks:

https://twitter.com/pmarca/status/622911480841699328

I can anecdotally confirm that piratebroadcast's claim is not unusual, as I got blocked sometime after this tweet: https://twitter.com/geofft/status/458371450052022273 To be fair, maybe I should have attempted some substantive discussion instead.

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#36

Extremely stupid tweet by Andreessen. He probably doesn't even realize that, like most ignorant people. FYI it was socialism that held back the Indian economy during the 70s and 80s. And it was colonialism that drained the country's wealth for over two hundred years. Here, Mr. Andreessen, educate yourself: https://www.google.com/search?q=bengal+famine

To be fair, it was stupid, however it was also a tongue in cheek tweet that was not an endorsement of colonialism and more poking fun at the sluggish Indian economy once they freed themselves of colonial rule. He was essentially making the point you made.

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#37
post #14

I don't particularly like the guy, but is there a campaign of deliberate misinterpretation going on? Yes, probably a really stupid thing to say, and perhaps wrong for many reasons. No, he did not say India should have kept Britain as its colonial power, or any of the other incredible interpretations now flying around the Twittersphere. Jonny Axelsson: Anti-semitism not the opposite of semitism. Now whether anti-colon…

Although I think you may be right in your interpretation how is maintaining net neutrality by India 'anti-colonialist'?

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#38
post #23

Extremely stupid tweet by Andreessen. He probably doesn't even realize that, like most ignorant people. FYI it was socialism that held back the Indian economy during the 70s and 80s. And it was colonialism that drained the country's wealth for over two hundred years. Here, Mr. Andreessen, educate yourself: https://www.google.com/search?q=bengal+famine

FYI it was socialism that held back the Indian economy during the 70s and 80s. Which is exactly what he says he meant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11072752

If I were him, I'd say I meant that too!

The original was catastrophically dumb. Was it because it's what he actually believes, or because he didn't spend more than fifteen microseconds considering his words? Beats me. Fun to watch, though.

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#39
post #14

I don't particularly like the guy, but is there a campaign of deliberate misinterpretation going on? Yes, probably a really stupid thing to say, and perhaps wrong for many reasons. No, he did not say India should have kept Britain as its colonial power, or any of the other incredible interpretations now flying around the Twittersphere. Jonny Axelsson: Anti-semitism not the opposite of semitism. Now whether anti-colon…

Are we supposed to disagree with his actual point, or with this obvious retcon you've quoted here?

Re: Marc Andreessen Pro-Colonialism Tweet Riles India Tech World

#40
post #14

I don't particularly like the guy, but is there a campaign of deliberate misinterpretation going on? Yes, probably a really stupid thing to say, and perhaps wrong for many reasons. No, he did not say India should have kept Britain as its colonial power, or any of the other incredible interpretations now flying around the Twittersphere. Jonny Axelsson: Anti-semitism not the opposite of semitism. Now whether anti-colon…

Although I think you may be right in your interpretation how is maintaining net neutrality by India 'anti-colonialist'?

I have no position on this. Please disagree with Andreessen about that, not with my objection to wild misinterpretation of him.

I have zero qualifications to have an opinion on the question you raise.

Post reply on HN