Live data from Hacker News

A house that costs $20k

fastcoexist.com

61–70 of 212 posts

Re: A house that costs $20k

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Icelander here, I'm more concerned how well does this house work in icelandic conditions? Does it handle earthquakes well? What about regular storms? Being wet for months end? Constant freezing and thawing? Can you put it in an active volcano? Does if float on magma? There are lot of questions here!

Does it float on magma? Do houses in Iceland really do that?

Magma is pretty dense (it's molten rocks, after all), so many things float on magma.

Re: A house that costs $20k

#62
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

6k = 12 working days for a builder skilled enough to do everything from working an excavator to hooking up hvac. So they're claiming a house that can be build in 12 day, by a single person, ready to move in? Clickbait.

Prefab houses can be built in a single day. In fact in china they built a prefab skyscraper in 15 days.

Including plumbing, flooring, electricity, hooking up utilities etc. ? Please cite your sources because extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Re: A house that costs $20k

#63
Reads too much like an advertisement piece.

Building a 60 m2 wooden shack have always been cheap compared to a proper house.

Much of the cost of a house lies in the cost of land and the cost of connecting it to water and electricity.

These costs are high because of scarcity and the policies of cities. Policies that ensures that values of houses do not fall and people do not go under water in debt, that areas are filled with proper gentry, that there are nice open spaces, nature, farmland etc.

Even if you could build a house for 0 dollars many places would still have an affordability issue.

Re: A house that costs $20k

#64
post #7

> How do you design a home that someone living below the poverty line can afford Why not rent a flat instead? Wouldn't that be much more economical (no property prices, lower heating costs, less maintenance work, less risk, not built on the cheap)? I don't understand the fixation on owning a house / living in a single-family house many americans seem to have.

One facet of it is cultural: For a lot of people, someone isn't seen as a "real adult" until he or she owns a residence. (Obligatory "if you have a mortgage you're just renting from the bank and have to fix the water heater yourself" line here.) Another is financial: There are heavy tax incentives towards ownership, though this is lessened in the era of cheap money. (On the other hand, if a mortgage can be had for ch…

>"Still another is logistical: Most areas of the U.S. have very few renter protections. If your landlord wants you out and you're not under a current lease, you're out"

This sort of thing happens when you don't have a contract that enumerates what happens if either party wants out.

Re: A house that costs $20k

#65
post #7

> How do you design a home that someone living below the poverty line can afford Why not rent a flat instead? Wouldn't that be much more economical (no property prices, lower heating costs, less maintenance work, less risk, not built on the cheap)? I don't understand the fixation on owning a house / living in a single-family house many americans seem to have.

When a section of society is forced to rent off a richer section of society, then you have a self perpetuating financial inequality - a poverty trap. For people in poverty, house ownership isn't a financial option. Giving poorer people the option to own or rent, gives people empowerment over their future.

Re: A house that costs $20k

#66
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Prefab houses can be built in a single day. In fact in china they built a prefab skyscraper in 15 days.

Including plumbing, flooring, electricity, hooking up utilities etc. ? Please cite your sources because extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

https://www.google.ca/search?q=china+skyscraper+15+days

It's been discussed on HN half a dozen times. "Extraordinary claims" is a context-dependent idea.

Re: A house that costs $20k

#67
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Prefab houses can be built in a single day. In fact in china they built a prefab skyscraper in 15 days.

Including plumbing, flooring, electricity, hooking up utilities etc. ? Please cite your sources because extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

iirc the designer of that skyscraper admitted that the plumbing was not ideal.

Re: A house that costs $20k

#68
I like the concept of small and cheap houses, unfortunately in my country, Europe/Germany this would not qualify as a house built to the newest regulations. It's just a shack.

Re: A house that costs $20k

#70

Probably nice for the US, but in much of the rest of the world, it is the price of land which dominate the price. Any system that aims to reduce house prices really need to deal with limited supply of land to build on. Even on Iceland which has vast amounts of space and tiny population, house prices are high because the areas where people want to live is in high demand. Now if you could just build your house at any a…

Icelander here, I'm more concerned how well does this house work in icelandic conditions? Does it handle earthquakes well? What about regular storms? Being wet for months end? Constant freezing and thawing? Can you put it in an active volcano? Does if float on magma? There are lot of questions here!

While I'm not really concerned about it, I doubt that it would live up to Danish building regulations. I'm mean we pressure test our homes... then install ventilation systems because living in a house that can parse the pressure test would be unhealthy. We then continue to get headaches and stuffed noses because the ventilation systems aren't any good either.

Anyway, it doesn't look like this house would fit the required amount of isolation.

Post reply on HN