Live data from Hacker News

Facebook at Work

work.fb.com

61–70 of 304 posts

Re: Facebook at Work

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People who use Slack do.

Slack charges. When is "Work" going to end up like Parse?

My guess is "Work" is a ploy to get Facebook un-blocked by corporate firewalls.

The business functionality has already existed (since FB uses its own platform internally), so its comparatively minor in engineering effort.

Re: Facebook at Work

#62

I clicked this hopeful that Facebook had made a new product tailored to the needs of an office. Instead it seems like they recently decided that their existing product just happens to already be the perfect product for the office and rebranded it. I don't buy this at all, teams don't actually collaborate by sending each other green giraffe stickers.

[deleted]

Re: Facebook at Work

#63

I'm pretty sure this is going to be big. I think Slack is so successful not just because of the chat interface and the integrations, but because people reliably receive notifications, messages can contain attachments that are presented in a helpful way, and because it has good ways of organizing groups. Facebook has everything but the chat interface and the integrations. I don't see any reason for them not to add the…

I agree! Although, I am curious about some of the privacy concerns that are being raised.

To further your point, I think Facebook's timeline dynamic complements Slack quite nicely. Slack is great for broad, real-time communication, whereas Facebook posts can be much more hyper-focused and the conversation can revolve around the specific topic over a long period of time.

For example, we have a development channel in our Slack. I can go back and browse through the chat log, but it's awkward to contribute a suggestion or thought to a conversation that happened yesterday. Everyone has moved on. Not the case on FB.

Re: Facebook at Work

#65
Considering I'm already Facebook friends with all my coworkers, being FB Work friends with them feels like presenting fake versions of ourselves to each other.

Keeping Facebook for personal stuff, and Hipchat/Slack/Google for professional communication seems to work well for me.

Re: Facebook at Work

#66
I wonder if this product was conceived in a Utopian vacuum by FB employees where they think all other companies operate in a similar fashion as theirs, where everyone is brilliant, motivated, young, high-tech, and are always aiming at the apex of the Maslow's pyramid; and have similar pain points.

I'm not being sarcastic (to the down voter). If you're an "A" talent, and are always used to working in certain type of environment, your view is quite skewed. How do you really know how a normal 30-people small business operate?

Re: Facebook at Work

#67
I agree with a lot of the concerns in the posts so far.

As of now it is simply Facebook with a different colour and focused on a group. Nothing special.

But I do think that Facebook will end up releasing a better collaboration feature to help integrate teams into Facebook At Work.

The reason I love Slack currently is the various apps and addons you can add, like the Github bot that posts when a pull request is created, or the Trello one that posts when someone completes a task.

If FB adds something like this (or better), I think they will grab a large portion of the market that isn't already dedicated to Slack.

Then it will slowly be improving features to steal Slack users after that.

Re: Facebook at Work

#68
post #27

I will not use a product supported by advertising for internal communication. The demographic data they would mine would be invaluable to them, but for a company would be unconscionable to give to a third party. Especially one so historically lax about privacy. You can mine my social life all you want, but when it comes to business, get the hell away.

Facebook at Work isn't going to be free. I also highly doubt they'll be touching any of the FB@Work data for mining, just like Google Apps for Business doesn't mine business accounts or serve ads.

Re: Facebook at Work

#69
post #53

I'm pretty sure this is going to be big. I think Slack is so successful not just because of the chat interface and the integrations, but because people reliably receive notifications, messages can contain attachments that are presented in a helpful way, and because it has good ways of organizing groups. Facebook has everything but the chat interface and the integrations. I don't see any reason for them not to add the…

But Slack is a chat service. I'm struggling to imagine what I would ever want to see in my Work News Feed.

Think knowledge base, all that information trapped inside Email which requires people to answer the same question 1000 times. Each one incomplete.

Re: Facebook at Work

#70
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Slack charges. When is "Work" going to end up like Parse?

My guess is "Work" is a ploy to get Facebook un-blocked by corporate firewalls. The business functionality has already existed (since FB uses its own platform internally), so its comparatively minor in engineering effort.

Ha! Nice theory!

No seriously, that's pretty brilliant.

Post reply on HN