Live data from Hacker News

Reddit in 2016

reddit.com

21–30 of 122 posts

Re: Reddit in 2016

#21
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

AlienBlue was the de facto reddit app for years on iOS, to the point that reddit actually bought it / accqi-hired the dev for it a year or so ago. Unfortunately it's been pretty stagnant since it was acquired, very few bug fixes and afaik no feature enhancements.

>it's been pretty stagnant since it was acquired, very few bug fixes and afaik no feature enhancements It's become noticeably buggier since the acquisition, in my opinion.

[deleted]

Re: Reddit in 2016

#22

Reddit is the worst. I created a sub that ended up becoming a default (/r/lifeprotips) and ended up getting banned when I tried to promote a site that I built (which was my original intention with the idea). They banned me because I had adsense on the site (funny because Imgur was/has been the golden child for reddit and they've had advertising for quite a while). I sent them a DMCA to remove the logo that I had comm…

Is lifeprotips.com the site you were trying to promote? I see that the banners are really similar.

Re: Reddit in 2016

#23

Reddit is the worst. I created a sub that ended up becoming a default (/r/lifeprotips) and ended up getting banned when I tried to promote a site that I built (which was my original intention with the idea). They banned me because I had adsense on the site (funny because Imgur was/has been the golden child for reddit and they've had advertising for quite a while). I sent them a DMCA to remove the logo that I had comm…

I'm working on a site: https://skimur.com

I plan on making like Twitter, but "followers" "vote" for "tweets" so that the collective community sees the best content. Reddit isn't really meant for personal usage. Subs are typically topic related there.

Re: Reddit in 2016

#24
Reddit's a neat idea, but I had to abandon it. Had just hit five years of daily participation on the site, too.

If we look past all the controversy and all the other reasons most people point at the site as a negative, it boils down to one thing in my mind:

Base cynicism.

There's cynicism when someone else reposts something.

There's cynicism over imaginary internet points.

There's cynicism by, from, and to the moderators and site owners.

There's cynicism every time something with a brand name gets mentioned (zOMG it's an ad!)

There's cynicism among communities.

It just goes on and on and on. Never-ending negativity. Everyone always assuming the worst of the other person (rather than trying to have an understanding discussion) and taking snarky potshots at them (and then hiding their comments by -1's in a fit of pique, rather than any kind of thoughtful analysis of quality).

I'm quite happier (and not a little bit more productive) not participating anymore. Reddit is, IMO, the world's greatest concentration of negative, irreverent, straight-up dickhead behavior in one convenient place.

(feh, word filter plugin went a little crazy there, sorry for the unreadable comment earlier)

Re: Reddit in 2016

#25
post #23

Reddit is the worst. I created a sub that ended up becoming a default (/r/lifeprotips) and ended up getting banned when I tried to promote a site that I built (which was my original intention with the idea). They banned me because I had adsense on the site (funny because Imgur was/has been the golden child for reddit and they've had advertising for quite a while). I sent them a DMCA to remove the logo that I had comm…

I'm working on a site: https://skimur.com I plan on making like Twitter, but "followers" "vote" for "tweets" so that the collective community sees the best content. Reddit isn't really meant for personal usage. Subs are typically topic related there.

Interesting idea, but right now this is just a self-hosted instance of Reddit, is it not? How do you plan to develop the idea further and (most importantly) attract actual visitors/users?

Re: Reddit in 2016

#26
post #6

While I can understand the sentiment that spam and abuse threaten our communities I can't help but think - based on outside observations - that some of the biggest threat to the Reddit communities are people within Reddit communities. Though admirable and well-meaning, it's a flawed model at the core, at least this is what I've come to believe. In the most recent flare-ups, the "call is coming from inside the house!"…

What specifically leads you to conclude it's a "flawed model"? Is it the problem of private ownership of a semipublic community, through individual accounts "owning" a subreddit?

As a model, user generated / sourced content blended with user sourced moderation under a private enterprise with "standards and expectations" will always have issues regarding the (occasional) desires of users to share and embrace things which are not welcome by the private enterprise. That's kind of the flaw in the model. The 'image' of community and ownership breaks down when there's a dispute, most frequently seen with respect to rules.

Re: Reddit in 2016

#27

Reddit is the worst. I created a sub that ended up becoming a default (/r/lifeprotips) and ended up getting banned when I tried to promote a site that I built (which was my original intention with the idea). They banned me because I had adsense on the site (funny because Imgur was/has been the golden child for reddit and they've had advertising for quite a while). I sent them a DMCA to remove the logo that I had comm…

You tried to use their site to promote your site and they banned you? And then you threatened legal action to get them to take down an image that you yourself posted?

Re: Reddit in 2016

#28
post #5

> Our new Android app is going into beta today, and our new iOS app should follow it out soon. It's amazing how long Reddit existed before rolling out a mobile app. Now I'll finally have something other than Facebook to check compulsively on my phone.

Just now? There's a bunch of excellent 3rd party Reddit apps on many mobile platforms. Even BB10 and WP have solid Reddit clients. I don't think you were trying very hard :P

A mobile app that isn't third party. If something happens with your data or your account through a third party app, Reddit isn't responsible. This hasn't been an issue with Reddit, but it's a risk the end-user accepts when the app isn't "official".

Re: Reddit in 2016

#29

I found this rather disturbing: > "Recently we built an A/B testing system, which allows us to test changes to individual features scientifically, and we are excited to put it through its paces. " Does this mean that Reddit made it all the way to 2016 without an A/B testing tool?!

Automated A/B testing isn't super important. Especially for sites like reddit which have been basically the same since launch.

You can still get feedback from users, and I would argue this is more important than automatically detecting which button has a 2% higher CTR.

Re: Reddit in 2016

#30
post #15

Reddit is a great platform to disguise sponsored content as organic. If you are really good the users won't even notice. I wonder whether they have started monetizing that yet. There is clearly a lot of it on Reddit. It's just not clear whether it is with the help of Reddit or despite of them.

Can you describe this sponsored/organic content dichotomy? To get noticed, you have to have upvotes. If you have upvotes, that means that users appreciated the content. If, say, a company or person is promoting themselves and the community upvotes it, I don't see any problem with it. That's how it's supposed to work. But I don't think that's what you mean by 'disguise'. I would guess rather that you mean that some en…

http://www.slideshare.net/reddit/reddit-brands-of-the-year-2...

I assume that's the official Reddit SlideShare account.

Post reply on HN