Live data from Hacker News

Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

blog.c-mart.in

241–250 of 256 posts

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#241

I've used an Alvin minimaster drafting table ($129) for the past 4 years: http://www.amazon.com/Alvin-MiniMaster-Adjustable-Drafting-T... I like it so much that I bought a second one for more desk space. Along with a drafting chair ($150): http://www.amazon.com/LexMod-Office-Drafting-Chair-Leatheret...

Interesting setup. Is the table deep enough? Seems like when sitting, your knees could hit that shelf under the table.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#242
post #237
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just had a genius revelation: I, like another poster here, don't like resting my feet on a bar all day. I like to have them planted firmly. What if we had tall desks and tall office chairs with a flat, elevated platform? Then you could easily plant both feet on the platform and it would feel just like a regular chair, but then you could easily stand up and have a standing desk? Something like this: http://www.lkgoo…

I find the notion of a specialized, adjustable standing desk ridiculous. Why raise and lower the WHOLE DESK, when you could just fix the desk at a high point and raise and lower your chair? It seems so much more efficient and convenient.

Probably so but no one makes chairs that go high, except drafting chairs which are extremely uncomfortable and even more so unergonomic for computer use.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#243
I have the IKEA Skarsta desk too. I am 6'3" tall. Yes, it does wobble a bit. It wobbles less if all pieces are tightened well. For me it is a non-issue even at full height with my laptop. Overall, it's a solid purchased depending on your use case.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#244
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I spend entirely more time than I should being semi-baffled at the way the internet has largely forgotten that you can just buy tall chairs and never have to worry about motors or adjustment speed or weight limits (to say nothing of cost).

I just had a genius revelation: I, like another poster here, don't like resting my feet on a bar all day. I like to have them planted firmly. What if we had tall desks and tall office chairs with a flat, elevated platform? Then you could easily plant both feet on the platform and it would feel just like a regular chair, but then you could easily stand up and have a standing desk? Something like this: http://www.lkgoo…

Why not use a stool instead of a specialized chair?

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#245

Uplift will also sell you the legs (~US$500) which you can mate with an inexpensive desk-top (or maybe one that you already have): http://www.upliftdesk.com/uplift-height-adjustable-standing-... We've used these at my work and they're pretty nice.

I really like my Uplift I have for my home office. I have the one with 4 presets, works well especially with kids :) If you live in Austin you can take a look at them at http://www.thehumansolution.com/. That's where I bought mine.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#246
post #195

I bought a treadmill desk recently. It's fantastic. I'm walking 15k steps at 2.3km/h daily, and slowly increasing the speed. I've dropped 3+kg and will soon have a healthy BMI again. After the first few days, the novelty wore off and I stopped noticing it while I worked. If I want a standing desk, I just turn the treadmill off. One thing I've noticed is that I still have to sit down to maximize focus and think throug…

Do you have a link for the one you bought?

It's the Lifespan TR-1200 DT.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#247

I bought a treadmill desk recently. It's fantastic. I'm walking 15k steps at 2.3km/h daily, and slowly increasing the speed. I've dropped 3+kg and will soon have a healthy BMI again. After the first few days, the novelty wore off and I stopped noticing it while I worked. If I want a standing desk, I just turn the treadmill off. One thing I've noticed is that I still have to sit down to maximize focus and think throug…

15k steps per day is awesome! I have no idea how much 3kg is but that's awesome too ;) And it's cool to hear you say that last bit because I feel the same way. I really need to sit down to work through through a complicated problems that requires focus. Emails and phone calls are standing and furrowed brow activities are sitting.

I know you're half joking, but if you really don't have a feeling (or actual understanding) of the units of the metric system you should spend some time acquiring that knowledge. There are reasons that 95% of the world and the entire scientific community uses it.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#248
post #2

I still don't get standing desk, how can you can concentrate deeply while standing? I guess not for everyone.

I guess I don't see the connection between standing, sitting, and concentration? I definitely think typing and using a mouse while standing takes some getting used to (in particular if you rest your arm on an armrest while seated); but concentration itself, to me at least, is not correlated. I will say I think simply standing as a health benefit exists but is overblown. If you really want health benefits you have to…

For many people (myself included), standing up feels like working, sitting feels like being lazy.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#249
post #158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If all you are trying to accomplish is to move from sitting/standing while working at a computer, they solve the same problem in a way that has been solved for at least a hundred years and is generally cheaper. There are some merits to adjustable desks above and beyond that though.

What are they?

Standing work on a computer is different than standing work for a soldering is different for drafting is different for drawing. A moving desk can support all those use cases but a adjustable chair and static desk can't.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#250

(for the sake of discussion) Why sit or stand when you can lie down? http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/10/sit-stand-nifty-new-w...

Yeah, always liked the idea since I saw ErgoQuests zero gravity workstations - http://www.ergoquest.com/zero-gravity-workstations.html - a few year back.

But 4000-5000 is a little bit too much for me personally.

Post reply on HN