Live data from Hacker News

Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

blog.c-mart.in

221–230 of 256 posts

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#221
post #59

We have 3 of the Ikea Bekant motorized standing desks in our office. They are great and we have had zero problems. My favorite feature is the simple mesh cable pocket underneath the desk, which is a great solution for hiding all the cable clutter.

How long have you been using them for, and how often are they raised/lowered?

Had a Bekant for over a year now. Lower it maybe 3 times per week. Works flawlessly! At the time I bought it for $500. Best setup "pound for pound" in my opinion.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#222
I was ecstatic to discover this desk in Ikea a month ago, and I bought it right away. It's so much less expensive than any alternatives I could find, and the material and build quality is superb.

Raising and lowering takes some time, but the brief mechanical labor involved in changing the height is probably a good mental and physical break for the operator. I don't change my desk height often - it stays in standing position 90%+ of the time.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#223

Earlier quoted context omitted.

15k steps per day is awesome! I have no idea how much 3kg is but that's awesome too ;) And it's cool to hear you say that last bit because I feel the same way. I really need to sit down to work through through a complicated problems that requires focus. Emails and phone calls are standing and furrowed brow activities are sitting.

According to Google 3kg is 6,61387 pounds. As a rule of thumbs if you multiply kilograms by 2 you get a rough equivalent in pounds ;-) I can manage inches, feet and pounds quite OK but Fahrenheit are a bitch though.

> ... but Fahrenheit are a bitch though.

Ha, ha, couldn't agree more... :)

Anyway, I looked it up just now, looks like you substract 32 from Fahrenheit and then divide by 1.8 to get Celcius: http://www.wikihow.com/Convert-Between-Fahrenheit,-Celsius,-...

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#224
post #127

IKEA apparently is phasing out this product, at least in SF/Bay area. If you want one, act now. :)

They only came out less then a year ago, it is because of a new version coming out or they are under pressure from other competitors for selling it too low priced?

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#226
> It's doubtful whether IKEA provides any warranty. It's not listed on IKEA's warranty page. When I called IKEA, I was told that there was a 90-day return policy with receipt.

Wow, I wasn't aware consumer protection was quite that bad in the USA. I've got a BEKANT (the smaller table-top version that the linked reviews say doesn't exist) and haven't had the slightest problem with it, but I admit I might have been more nervous if not for the 10 year guarantee it's given in the UK.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#227

> It's doubtful whether IKEA provides any warranty. It's not listed on IKEA's warranty page. When I called IKEA, I was told that there was a 90-day return policy with receipt. Wow, I wasn't aware consumer protection was quite that bad in the USA. I've got a BEKANT (the smaller table-top version that the linked reviews say doesn't exist) and haven't had the slightest problem with it, but I admit I might have been more…

It seems that BEKANT has a 10yr warranty in the USA as well, but what's more crazy to me is that you can offer products without any warranty in the USA at all. In the EU, 2 years warranty is the legal minimum, during the first six months of which the manufacturer has to prove that you caused the damage, and during the remaining 18 months you have to prove that it was damaged from the start (reversal of the burden of proof). That's the absolute minimum that's legally allowed, most manufacturers don't make use of the reversal of the burden of proof and will cover reasonable claims anyway. It's probably just too expensive to verify proof ;)

Oh and I also have a BEKANT at work and never had any issues with it. I honestly don't understand the review that was linked in the article. I use it with a different table top which was a complete non-issue to attach if you have a drill.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#228
post #67
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any idea what the maximum height of a person would be to use this?

For the Ikea Bekant desk, I'm 6'2" and usually have it near its maximum height. I like things a bit higher (relative to my own height) than most, but I still wouldn't expect it to work for someone over say 6'5". All these adjustable desks start to have perceptible sway when mostly extended. If this really bothers you, consider mounting your monitors separately.

The Bekant's EU version goes 3cm higher than the US version. I'm 6'1" and it's nowhere near maximum. A colleague of mine is 6'4" and doesn't max it out either. Height is between 65 and 125cm for the EU version, versus 56 to 122cm for the US version.

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#229
post #39
post #6

I have the motorized version of this desk and agree that it's not built for tall people. I'm about 5'11" and have to use it at its maximum height to be comfortable. Otherwise love it.

That's funny - 5'11 is just about average height for Scandinavian males, so IKEA being Swedish this is a bit surprising.

EU version goes higher than the US version, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10994429

Re: Sit/Stand Desk: IKEA Skarsta Review

#230

The main reason I prefer an electronic height-adjustable desk is the height presets. Imagine if every time you sat down in your computer chair you had to adjust it from the lowest setting to a comfortable height. How much time would be wasted? It's not the effort of cranking it there, it's determining where the optimal height is. With electronic, you set it once, and then whether you're sitting or standing, your surf…

I have electric ones as well (both at home and in the office), but I don't use presets. In fact, one thing I love about adjustable desks is the ability to move it up and down a little during the day. That way my posture is a bit dynamic even if I don't choose to stand up. Also, I don't really feel like I am "wasting time" finding the right spot -- it takes what, 5 seconds?
Post reply on HN