Live data from Hacker News

Stone Tools in Sulawesi Point to Neighbor of Flores ‘Hobbit’

news.nationalgeographic.com

1–5 of 5 posts

Re: Stone Tools in Sulawesi Point to Neighbor of Flores ‘Hobbit’

#4
post #2

"... perhaps descended from Homo erectus individuals washed eastward atop tsunami debris" Is this really the general consensus about how pre homo sapiens human species traversed bodies of water?

It sounds a little ridiculous, but it seems just about as plausible as most things in paleo-archeology[1]. I've been on a kick of reading a lot of nautical fiction and autobiography, and you come across a lot of accounts of plant and animal life transported surprising distances in the aftermath of severe storms.

[1] Could archaeologists, or really, the media reporting on it, be more upfront about the fact that virtually everything they are talking about is wild speculation based on very tenuous evidence? I don't want to knock the people doing the work of digging this stuff up and trying to understand it; but really, when you find one jawbone and extrapolate an entire organism, complete with artists renderings and even taxidermied monstrosities, or compare incomplete, fragmentary, dried out, degraded DNA material from Hominid A and B to conclude which is more closely related to modern man, my bullshit detectors start going off. The sample size is just too small.

Re: Stone Tools in Sulawesi Point to Neighbor of Flores ‘Hobbit’

#5
Fascinating.

I believe we're nowhere near a full understanding of the diversity of pre-H. sapiens species. Just last year the discovery of another Homo species, H. nadeli, was claimed [1]. I feel like we're going to keep finding more and more of these folks, and - like the Neanderthals and Denisovans - discovering through genetic analysis that we interbred [2].

Also, the thing that complicates paleoanthropology, especially in regions like the Indonesian archipelago, is that most of the areas where prehuman Homo populations would have lived for significant lengths of time are now underwater.

Frustrating, but if we knew all the answers, what fun would that be?

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/sep/10/new-species-o... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archaic_human_admixture_with_m...